STATE SABBATH (SUNDAY) CONVENTION HELD AT INDIANAPOLIS, IND.
By A. W. Bartlett
According to the notice in the Review, that the National Religious Liberty Association would give reports of the Indiana State Sabbath Convention held at Indianapolis, Sept. 29, 30, we present the following:— Much to the disappointment of National Reform representatives, the congregations numbered from twenty-two to thirty-three, and about one fifth of the same were Seventh-day Adventists. Mr. J. P. Mills introduced the convention by an address on the “Aims and Status of the Movement.” He stated that the masses were unindoctrinated on the Sabbath question; some preachers have confessed to him that they never preached on that subject. To us it would not seem very difficult to discover the reason for this backwardness of the clergy in preaching on the Sabbath question, inasmuch as they find such an absence of scriptural proof in support of the observance of the first day of the week. Mr. Mills said further that this Government was set going by the pent-up passions of our forefathers. That this original moral force is nearly spent, and the Government is liable to go down unless we come to the rescue. Our forefathers dedicated this as a Sabbath-keeping land, and when landing, would not disembark from their ship on the Sabbath (Sunday). There is a religious and Christian Sabbath, and a civil Sabbath apart from any “Thus saith the Lord.” We would call the special attention of the reader to this point; that the civil Sabbath is entirely independent of any divine command, as it flatly contradicts the position of another speaker in the same convention. Mr. Mills stated that he visited the millionaires of Chicago to see what they would do in behalf of closing the World’s Fair on Sunday. He found them all in favor of Sunday opening, and that every daily paper in Chicago was in favor of the same. Also the local committee of the Exposition was in favor of opening on Sunday. In speaking of the foes of the American Sabbath, he said there was,— “(1) Worldliness growing in the church. The church has become rich, opulent, and sensual. In the more stylish and rich churches the services were turned into theatrical performances. “(3) Greed. The American father teaches his son this maxim, not as Solomon taught, ‘With all thy getting get understanding,’ but, ‘With all thy getting get money.’ “(4) The American Secular Union, whose object is to destroy faith in God, and secularize the Sabbath. “(5) Last, but not least; the brothels of this country.” It was stated by Mr. Mills that we have a large force in Congress that is twirled around by this power. The idea was suggested that many Congressmen desired Sunday for dissipation. The next speaker, Rev. W. H. French of Rushville, Ind., spoke on the Bible doctrine of the Sabbath. He said:— “If there is no Bible requirement for the Sabbath, I fail to see where a law could be derived for the civil Sabbath.” This speaker’s effort consisted mainly in arguing that the Sabbath was not ceremonial, but moral, and if moral, there was a basis for civil enforcement. He cited that the penalty inflicted upon the man for picking up sticks on the Sabbath, and the threatening of Nehemiah for Sabbath breaking, proved that ordinary labor upon the Sabbath was wrong, and should be punished by civil law. Mr. French’s position on the Sabbath contradicted Mr. Mills’s, which, as above stated, argued for a civil Sunday independent of the Scripture. Much was expected of the address advertised at 2 P. M. by the Hon. Stanton J. Peele, on the “Civil Sabbath.” An audience of about twenty-five persons greeted this distinguished lawyer and ex-Congressman. The disappointment occasioned by the small audience was exceeded by that experienced by the advocates of a Sunday law when Mr. Peele truly stated:— “To encourage individuals to such an observance of the Sabbath as will best tend to promote the welfare of society, depends upon parental instruction and example at home. There is where character is formed. There, too, is where habits become fixed, and where the responsibility in reality rests and properly belongs.” His concluding thought was this:— “Let us labor to reform the individual rather than the law. Let us depend more upon that higher law of man’s moral nature for restraint, and less upon human enactments.” At the close of Mr. Peele’s address, the disappointed National Reformers asked him questions as to the legality of Sunday base-ball. He stated that if base-ball players chose their game upon that day merely as recreation, the law could not interfere; that any one had a right to choose his manner of Sunday observance, as recreation, in the woods, at home, or worship at church. The next speaker, Mr. Wiley, dwelt particularly upon the responsibility of the church in Sabbath (Sunday) desecration. The object of Sabbath laws, he said, was not to compel any one to go to church or be religious, but to protect those who wished to keep the day. It was very evident from the views of other speakers that the only way Sunday observers could be protected in their observance of the day, would be by compelling everybody else to observe the day religiously. Mr. Wiley proposed that the church discipline every member that tampers with the Sunday newspapers. Mr. Mills closed the convention with an address on “National Responsibility touching the Sabbath.” He said:— “I believe in the separation of Church and State. Sabbath breaking is a matter of wicked lewdness, and thus comes within the pale of civil law. The State has a right to demand of its subjects that they work, and has of course the right to demand that they rest.” But to show the falsity of the statement by Mr. Mills, that he believes in the separation of Church and State, it is sufficient to notice that he is ardently seeking to enforce the religious observance of Sunday by civil law. “The manner in which the Sabbath is to be observed, is a great point,” said Mr. Mills. “The State must protect its own life. To allow this holiday observance of Sunday, and this Sunday toil to go on, would be suicidal to the Government.” And yet National Reformers claim that they seek not to compel the religious observance of Sunday, but only to protect those who desire to keep it. The interests of the working men came in for a share of his attention. While claiming that the working man should have Sunday for rest, and while decrying the monopolies that would deny him his boon, it will be evident that the toilers, while they may escape commercial monopoly, would fall under the crushing weight of a religious monopoly, the worst of all: for Sunday laws lead to religious despotism. Mr. Mills closed his remarks by this statement:— “Liberty and happiness will not come until the strong hand of civil law is put upon them (corporations), saying, ‘You must rest.’”