WILL THE EARTH BURN UP?

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 22, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 50.

Read the full edition

WILL THE EARTH BURN UP?

BY W. E. SPERRA.
(Randolph, Ohio.)
The above is the heading of an article in Word and Works, by A. G. Hollister of Mt. Lebanon, N. Y. The writer answers it in the negative, and endeavors to vindicate his position by the Holy Scriptures, presenting Isa. 2: 2–4, referring to Dan. 7: 27, the sounding of the seventh trumpet (Rev. 11: 15, 18), and Isa. 66: 24, and then says:—
These things are not accomplished yet, and great and mighty changes must be wrought before they are fulfilled. All signs declare that the agents of this mighty revolution are being prepared and set in operation with greater activity and on a wider scale than ever before since the creation. And when it is done, when evil has been everywhere put down, and righteousness reigns, and equity sits in judgment, and all mankind are obedient to the moral laws of the good Creator, what motive then for destroying the planet?
Sure enough, what motive then for destroying the earth? But before we form our conclusions, let us inquire into these things. It will be seen that Isa. 2: 2–4 is said by certain nations in the last days, who are looking for a time of peace, and not by the Lord. Verses 6–9 describe the moral condition of those nations,—not very flattering for our temporal millennium friends,—and because they say so, the Lord forsakes them and forgives them not. The Lord’s words concerning this time are found in Joel 3: 9–11. Dan. 7: 27 refers to the setting up of the everlasting kingdom of God, but does not tell us by what means it will be accomplished, whether by converting the wicked or destroying them. But Dan. 2: 31–45, a parallel prophecy, tells us it is by destroying the wicked nations. By comparing Rev. 11: 15–19 with Rev. 16: 17–20; 6: 12–17; Jer. 25: 30–33; Isa. 66: 15, 16, we learn that God destroys the wicked at the setting up of his kingdom, by hail, sword, and fire, and at that time every island and mountain disappears, and the heavens are rolled together as a scroll. Isa. 34: 2, 4, 8, tells us that at this time, “the day of the Lord’s vengeance,” “the streams thereof shall be turned into pitch, and the dust thereof into brimstone, and the land thereof shall become burning pitch.” That this is a judgment on the whole earth is evident from verses 1, 2. Verse 3 tells us that the “mountains shall be melted.” Therefore if we can put any confidence in the words of Holy Writ, the earth will be burned or purified by fire from the curse of sin, at the time of the Lord’s vengeance and the day of his wrath. But hear the writer further:—
Even may they not bring back the beauty and glory of primitive Eden and exceed it? But what of Peter’s prediction that the earth and the works that are therein shall be burned up? The prophets made much use of figurative language. It was the style of the country, and the only way they could impress the minds of their hearers, or teach the nature of spiritual concepts to the natural mind.
It is true the prophets made use of figures, symbols, and similitudes, where the truth they wished to express was made plainer thereby, but if not, they used literal language. But it was not the only way they could teach the people. Below is our friend’s explanation of Peter’s prophecy above referred to, and the reader can judge whether the thought as explained by this writer could not be expressed better and in a plainer way by literal language instead of figurative.
The earth referred to must mean the earthly mind of man. The first man is of the earth, earthly. The mind is the man, not the body, which is only a tent that the man dwells in for a short time. The works stored in the mind are not burned with material fire, hence that burning refers to spiritual fire. The elements that melt with fervent heat, are the objects of earthly care and interest, which feed and support the earthly mind. The heavens that are to pass away, and which are passing away with a great noise of controversy, discussion, and debate, are the religious systems and creedal forms, invented to conserve and perpetuate the ancient régime of lust, avarice, injustice, oppression, and selfish greed.
But just where these “religious systems” and “creedal forms” are passing away with a “great noise of controversy, discussion, and debate,” it would be difficult to determine, as every year is adding new “creeds” and “religious systems” to the field of discussion and debate. Granting for a moment that the earth referred to is the earthly mind of man, let us examine the context in connection with 2 Pet. 3: 10–12, and see if it will harmonize with such an interpretation, and if it does, then the above figurative view may be correct, but if it does not, we will be compelled to adopt another explanation. In verses 3, 4 Peter tells us of scoffers who are mocking and scoffing at those who are looking for the Saviour’s return, and he says that they are “ignorant that by the word of God the heavens were of old, and the earth standing out of the water and in the water, perished.”
It is evident that this is a literal description of the earth when it was deluged by the flood in Noah’s time. Then Peter turns to the “heavens and earth, which are now,” and says they are “reserved unto fire against the day of judgment and perdition of ungodly men.” This can refer to nothing else than the present literal earth and heavens contrasted with the one which perished in the flood. Make it refer to anything else, the “earthly mind of man,” for instance, and we destroy Peter’s argument and make him argue thus: “In the last days there will be scoffers who say, Where is the promise of his coming? for since the fathers fell asleep, all things continue as they were from the creation of the world. But they are willingly ignorant that the world did actually perish in the flood, and because it perished, God has reserved the ‘earthly mind’ and ‘creedal forms’ unto the day of judgment and perdition of ungodly men.” This is wonderful logic that proves the burning of the “earthly mind” with “spiritual fire,” and the passing away of “religious systems” and “creedal forms” with a “great noise of controversy, discussion, and debate,” from the fact of the earth’s being once destroyed in the flood!
Again: the “earth” and “heavens” of the 10th and 12th verses must be the same as the “earth” and “heavens” of the 7th verse. If the “earth” means the “earthly mind,” and the “heavens” means the “creedal forms” which “conserve and perpetuate the ancient régime of lust, avarice, injustice, oppression, and selfish greed,” the conclusion necessarily follows that God is accountable for their existence, because in the 7th verse it is said they are kept in store by the same word which created the heavens and earth of old. Therefore, according to our friend’s interpretation, God authorizes “lust, avarice, injustice, oppression, and selfish greed.” Is it not clear to every candid mind, that an interpretation which involves such absurdities, and reproaches the name of Jehovah as this one does, is not in harmony with him who is love and wisdom?
If we make the “heavens” and “earth” of the last verses literal, meaning the present literal earth upon which we stand, then Peter’s argument is harmonious and logical all the way through, and is therefore the correct interpretation. But the above writer falls into his fatal error of a figurative interpretation by failing to see that the Bible nowhere says that the earth will be “burned to cinders” and entirely destroyed, but that it will pass through a renovating process in which the “works therein,” the result of sin, will be burned up, and from this cleansing fire the earth will come forth regenerated and clothed in Eden beauty. All the wicked, including Satan, having been consumed in ashes by this fire (Mal. 4: 1–3; Eze. 28: 17–19), the righteous only are left to inhabit the “new earth.” 2 Pet. 3: 13; Isa. 65: 17–25; 66: 15–24. And in this new earth Isa. 66: 23 has its application. We have not examined all the points in the above article, but enough to show the fallacy of its reasoning. When will men cease to pervert the pure words of God by human reason and tradition? Finally, we would commend a careful study of 2 Pet. 1: 20 to every one who sets himself as an expositor of scripture.