THE ease with which the way is being cleared before the Sunday institution at the present time is phenomenal. Principles are being discovered, it seems, which clear the ground of every conceivable obstacle. Its foundations are becoming absolutely colossal, and its top reaches unto heaven.
When the claims of Sunday and the Bible Sabbath began to be compared, the friends of the former stood aghast at the fact, then for the first time fully realized, that no proof of a change of the Sabbath could be found, and that no evidence for the first day, nor any law for its observance, could be discovered in all the New Testament. Then they seemed to think that a resort to casuistry and apostolic example would help them out. But it was long since discovered that nothing could be gained in this direction. Sunday-keeping is here, and is too firmly established to be given up; and so if there is no law for it, and no example for it, and no ground for it, it is because there is no need of any such thing! And this is now the turn that is being taken on the subject. “Sunday doesn’t need any statute nor any proclamation.” It is as evident as the sun, as inevitable as the seasons.
The relief which this discovery must bring to Sunday champions is beyond calculation. Nevertheless, it must appear a little strange that if it is so self-existent an institution as not to need any divine law in its support, such great fear should be expressed that the whole observance will go to the dogs unless some human laws can be obtained to back it up.
We are led to these reflections by a sermon by J. H. Barrows, of Chicago, on closing the World’s Fair, as printed in the Inter Ocean of March 30, 1891. Like the majority of Sunday advocates, he quotes as a text, “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy” (Ex. 20:8), notwithstanding it doesn’t mean the day he is going to talk about at all. He rightly places the origin of the Sabbath in Eden, and says it was “ordained for universal humanity; not for a handful of Hebrews only, but for mankind.” He is also right on the question of the perpetuity of the fourth commandment when he says:—
“But did not Christ and the apostles, did not the early Church set aside the fourth commandment? Where? and when? But we are told that early Christianity observed the first rather than the seventh day of the week as the holy rest day. Yes, but in what sense did this abrogate the fourth commandment?”
He is obliged now to account in some way for the transference of the day from the seventh to the first, and here is where the circus commences and the music begins. He seems anxious to have it appear that no harm was done by changing to the first day, and so he says: “The transference from the seventh to the first day touched nothing that was fundamental and vital in the primitive enactment.” Then we ask, Why make any change? He continues:—
“It is not surprising that Christian believers began to observe the first day of the week, the day of the resurrection; it would have been surprising if they had forever observed the seventh day as Sabbath—that dark and awful day when their Lord’s body was in the tomb, and they in sorrow and despair.”
But why, we ask, should we have been surprised if they had continued to keep the seventh day? What was there in the fact that Christ lay in the tomb, that affected the commandment in any way, or changed their duty? This gives us altogether a new standard in reference to our obligations touching the observance of the Sabbath. Mr. B. would have us read the commandment in this way: “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy. The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God, till something awful happens to take place on that day, when it will not be expected that you will keep it any longer, but choose some other day!” He further says:—
“It is said that no statute is enacted appointing it, no proclamation is made announcing it. It needs neither statute nor proclamation [italics ours]; it follows the resurrection of Christ and the descent of the Holy Spirit, just as regular Christian worship followed.”
This is about the handiest part of the whole Sunday argument. It saves a vast deal of perplexity and trouble. The original Sabbath needed a statute. All the moral precepts of the Bible need a statute. Every Christian observance has its statute. But here is something that is so wonderfully constituted that it doesn’t need any. Why, then, we ask again, all this effort to show that somehow the fourth commandment has gigged along a day, so that it now requires the first day instead of the seventh? There is felt to be, after all, some importance to a statute. Next follows a quotation from Dr. Schaff:—
“As Dr. Schaff has said: The Jewish Sabbath rose with the Saviour as a new creation on the morning of the resurrection, and descended with the Holy Ghost on the day of Pentecost, to be observed as the Christian Sabbath, as the Lord’s day, to the end of time. Its temporal and ritual form was abolished, its moral substance was renewed. The Jewish Sabbath was baptized with fire and the Holy Ghost. It was Christianized and glorified.”
In this spasm of rhetoric, the Sabbath goes through some curious transformations. Sunday-keepers usually claim that the old Jewish Sabbath was left buried in the tomb; but Mr. S. has it rise with Christ, and come down on Pentecost. Where was it between these dates? But when it came down, it lit upon another day, the first day of the week, and had somehow changed its name from “Jewish” to “Christian.” But all the difference was, that now it got onto the first day instead of the seventh which God originally enjoined and had never changed, and now it was to be used to commemorate an event which is not embraced in the original command, which had already been provided with another memorial, and which we are nowhere commanded to commemorate by the observance of a weekly rest day. And by all this the institution was, forsooth, “Christianized and glorified”! What immense virtue there must be embodied in the first day of the week!
“Its temporal and ritual form,” he says, “was abolished.” What can this mean? God instituted in the beginning a memorial of his creative work. The only form it had was the dedication of the seventh day of the week to sacred and religious uses. This is what Mr. S. must mean by the “temporal and ritual” part of the commandment. This, we are told, was abolished. What was there left? He answers, Its “moral substance.” What was that? Then he takes the same institution, which he calls “the Jewish Sabbath,” places it upon another day, has that day observed in the same manner with just as much form, and for a like commemorative purpose, and then, lo and behold, the temporal and ritual part is all gone, and the “moral substance” is not only preserved, but renewed.
This puzzles us again. Why did its moral substance have to be renewed? Did it get damaged a little going through this wonderful change? But further, when God has given an institution as a unit, with no intimation of any distinct and divisible parts, what right has any man to cut and carve it up to suit himself, calling some parts temporal and ritual, and other parts moral, and then on the strength of that division, presume to re-adjust it to another day for another purpose?
Having thus fixed the Sunday from a biblical standpoint, it must now be adjusted to the legal machine of this country. It must be “religious” and yet only “civil”; it must be enforced upon all, and yet bind no man’s conscience. So Mr. S. says: “But Sunday in American law is not a religious but a civil institution.” Then we ask, Why all this special pleading to show its divine character? “It is,” he continues, “a weekly rest day prescribed for the public good.” Will those who try to put the matter in this specious light, please answer two questions: first, Where is the first particle of evidence that Sunday as a merely civil rest day, a day simply of enforced idleness, would be of any public good whatever? And, secondly, How much effort would there ever have been, or would there be now, to establish Sunday as a civil or any other kind of rest day, if it was not regarded as a Sabbath by professors of religion? The glamour of a “civil” Sunday “for the public good” can deceive no one.
Take another statement just now immensely current among Sunday law advocates, and consequently used by Mr. B.: “Its purpose [that of the Sunday law] is not to make men religious, but to protect all citizens in their right to the weekly day of rest.” Will he show us one who has not such right already? Does any law deprive any man of a day of rest if he wishes to take it? But it may be said, “There are men who would like to rest religiously on Sunday, but if they do they will lose their situation.” Oh! Then a law is wanted, not so much to protect their rights, as to relieve them from a cross and sacrifice in living out their Christianity! What is such so-called Christianity worth?
But Mr. B., like Mr. Crafts and others, seems to be unwilling to leave the Sunday entirely on a civil basis, and so he says: “And only the Christian observance of the Sabbath will make permanent the civil Sunday.” Thus the true intent, namely, to enforce religion by law, crops out in spite of them. The trouble with them is, they have only a piece of cloth about two yards square to cover an elephant; and when they pull it over to hide one part of the animal, they are sure to expose some other part.
But we need not pursue this subject further. O that men would come back to the old paths, the plain, straightforward truth of God’s word, which rests on the eternal rock, and will stand the test of the coming day!