AdventAI

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 15., April 14, 1891

TEN MEN TAKING HOLD OF A JEW.

In Zech. 8: 23, we read: “In those days it shall come to pass, that ten men shall take hold out of all languages of the nations, even shall take hold of the skirt of him that is a Jew, saying, We will go with you: for we have heard that God is with you.” When does this prophecy apply, and what is its meaning? E. E. E.

Answer.—The prophecy was written some 518 years before Christ, and evidently had reference to a time when the Jews still existed as a nation, in distinction from other nations mentioned in the text. But that time is now past; and the Jewish nationality is never again to be restored; so we cannot look to any future date for the fulfillment of this scripture. The language, according to the context (see verses 20–22), is designed to show the great exaltation which the Jews would enjoy among the nations, and the honor in which they would be held. But all God’s promises are based upon uniform and invariable conditions. These are sometimes expressed, but exist just the same whether expressed or not. These conditions are set forth in Jer. 18: 7–10. They are, that when God promises good to a people, if they turn to wickedness and do evil, he will turn from the good he intended them, and instead bring judgments upon them; and when on account of their sins he purposes to pull down and destroy a nation, if they turn from their sins and repent before him, he will turn from the evil and do them good.

This is a just and consistent rule. Zech. 8: 20–23 is no exception to it. We do not read of anyp. 235 time when the Jewish nation ever enjoyed such distinction. Hence we conclude that they brought themselves into such moral relation to God, that he could not consistently fulfill that promise unto them, and hence it never was fulfilled; and the time being past, it never is to be fulfilled.

More attention to these principles would, it seems to us, save much misinterpretation of Old Testament prophecies relative to the Jews. Thus, when we read a prophecy which, according to the specifications, must apply when the Jews were nationally a distinct people, we know it cannot apply in, or subsequent to, the gospel age; for no such distinction now exists, or ever is to exist; and, secondly, if we cannot find any place where the terms of the prophecy were ever fulfilled, we conclude, according to the rule laid down in Jeremiah, that the people did not comply with the conditions, and consequently lost the good which was promised. According to this principle, many apparently perplexing questions arising from some of the prophecies of Isaiah, Ezekiel, and Zechariah, are easily settled.

LEAST IN THE KINGDOM OF HEAVEN.

What is meant by the expression, “least in the kingdom,” in Matt. 5: 19? and how is it reconciled with James 2: 19? E. E. E.

Ans.—The expression means that those to whom it is applied will not get into the kingdom of heaven at all; they will have no part therein.

At first thought people almost invariably draw from this text a conclusion which will hardly stand a close examination. They conclude it refers only to those who will be in the kingdom, or be saved in heaven, and is only a comparison of the different conditions of those there; that is, some will be in great honor, highly esteemed, but others in heaven will occupy a lower position, and be held in less regard. And then it is a query how any who break the commandments and teach men so, will ever get into heaven at all, even if they do there occupy a low position.

The word rendered “called,” means “to be regarded” or “esteemed.” Some will be regarded as least in the kingdom; and this distinction is owing to character; for the reason they are regarded as least, is because they broke the commandments and taught men so. Now, is it allowable to suppose that there will be in heaven some standing high on account of moral excellence, and others occupying a lower plane because they did not come up to the true moral standard? If so, we must set them down to the lowest degree; for they are regarded as least. But such a supposition is inconceivable; for there will be no such moral dwarfs in the kingdom of heaven.

Verse 20 explains verse 19. In verse 19, it will be noticed, there are two classes brought to view; namely, (1) those who break the commandments and teach men so, who are to be called “least”; and (2) those who do and teach them, who are to be called “great.” Likewise in verse 20, the same two classes are brought to view. Christ says, “For I say unto you [drawing a conclusion from verse 19], that except your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees, ye shall in no case enter into the kingdom of heaven.” The two classes brought to view here, are (1) those whose righteousness does exceed that of the scribes and Pharisees; and these will enter into the kingdom of heaven; and (2) those whose righteousness does not exceed the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees; and these shall in no case enter into the kingdom of heaven. The first class here mentioned correspond to those called “great” in verse 19; and the second class correspond to those called “least” in verse 19. But this second class of verse 20, whose righteousness does not exceed that of the scribes and Pharisees, are in no case to enter into the kingdom of heaven; and consequently those called “least” in verse 19, being the same class, are in no case to enter into the kingdom of heaven.

Some think it is of no consequence whether we keep the law and teach others so or not; but according to these texts, the great issue whether we shall, or shall not, enter into the kingdom of heaven, depends upon our course in this respect.

JAMES 5: 20. HIDE A MULTITUDE OF SINS.

“Let him know, that he which converteth the sinner from the error of his way, shall save a soul from death, and shall hide a multitude of sins.” Whose sins are here referred to, the sins of the one who turns the sinner from the error of his way, or the sins of the sinner who is thus converted?

S. M.

Ans.—The word “hide” means, to cover or conceal. When God treats the sins of the sinner thus, it means that he forgives them, as in Ps. 32: 1: “Blessed is he whose transgression is forgiven, whose sin is covered.” When the sinner is turned from the error of his ways and becomes converted, God forgives all his past sins, and thus they are covered; and the one by whose influence the sinner is thus turned into the path of right becomes indirectly a means of causing them to be thus covered, the sins referred to being the sins of the converted not the converter. The sins of the latter may be supposed to be already covered, or he would not be engaged in the work of turning others to righteousness.

So much for the past. But an equally important part of the subject pertains to the future. If the sinner is not converted, at any given point, he of course goes on from that time still sinning and adding to the multitude of his transgressions. But if he is converted, ceases to sin and turns to obedience, all the sins he would have committed had he not been so converted, are never committed, and so are never seen by mortal eye. In this way he who turns a sinner to righteousness is instrumental in covering a multitude of sins. On this point Dr. Deems (“Gospel of Common Sense,” p. 318) pens some thoughts which present the matter in a very forcible manner. He says:—

“If a man shall convert his neighbor from the error of his ways, the good that neighbor shall do after his conversion will become known to the world in some measure. But all the sins he would have committed but for the conversion, would be covered up and hidden away from human eyes. With these two things before us, namely, the prevention of a life of sinfulness, a thing so offensive to our Heavenly Father, and the production of a life radiant in truth, which is so delightful to our Heavenly Father, the one great work ought to be (to every moral man, to every man capable of ethical ideas, to every man who applies his common sense to the problems of human life and human destiny) the turning away of men from their wanderings, and fixing them in the realm, under the reign, of moral law. There, and there only, is liberty; liberty for which millions of souls have sighed; liberty for which millions of men have died. Liberty, in whose name, as the dying Mme. Roland said, so many crimes had been committed, real, manly, moral, intellectual, spiritual liberty, is secured only to the man who has been converted from the error of his ways, by a conversion from the error of his thoughts. Even as James’s great brother said, ‘Ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.’”