BY ELDER J. F. BALLENGER.
(Forest, Mich.)
A SISTER who has commenced the observance of the Bible Sabbath, received a letter from her brother in opposition to her views, advocating the no-law position. She requested Bro. Ballenger to reply to it, which he does in the following communication.—Ed.]
DEAR SIR: A letter was handed me by your sister, Mrs. H., written by you, in which you try to prove her in error in the keeping of the Sabbath “according to the commandment,” with a request that I answer it. I do so with no other motive than that the truth may be sustained, and God be honored.
You start out by saying, “In the name of Jesus Christ I declare the ten commandment covenant given on Sinai abolished.” Cruden defines “abolish” to mean, to do away, make void, destroy. How any person could ever declare in the name of Christ that the ten commandments are done away, made void, or destroyed, is more than I can tell. If there was no Scripture to prove the immutability of the decalogue, enlightened reason would teach us that such moral precepts as “Thou shalt have no other gods before me;” “Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image;” “Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain;” “Honor thy father and thy mother;” “Thou shalt not kill;” “Thou shalt not commit adultery;” “Thou shalt not steal;” “Thou shalt not bear false witness;” “Thou shalt not covet,” could never be done away, made void, or destroyed. If Christ did not refer to such commandments as the above when he said, “Think not that I am come to destroy the law” (Matt. 5:17), or “It is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one jot and tittle of the law to fail,” pray tell us, what law he did refer to? Do not the heavens and earth continue? If so, is not every jot and tittle of the law in force?
Again: You say the New Testament is to be the rule of judgment for sinners. True, but do not both Testaments present the same law as the rule of judgment? or does God have different rules of judgment for different dispensations? but if so, would it not prove that with God there is variableness and more than a shadow of turning? James 1:17. Solomon says: “Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter: Fear God, and keep his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man. For God shall bring every work into judgment, with every secret thing, whether it be good, or whether it be evil.” Eccl. 12:13, 14. Paul says: “As many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law; . . . in the day when God shall judge the secrets of men by Jesus Christ according to [or in harmony with, see Webster] my gospel.” Rom. 2:12–16. Both of these writers show that God “hath appointed a day, in the which he will judge” the secrets of men, by the law according to the gospel, the gospel being the same in all ages. (See Gal. 3:8; Heb. 4:2.)
Right here let me ask an important question: Will the rule of judgment which shows the secrets of men living in the past dispensation to be bad, show the same secrets in this dispensation to be good, and vice versa. Or, to make it still plainer, Will those living in the past dispensation who had the ten commandments written in the most secret recesses of the heart, and loved them, in the judgment hear the welcome “Well done,” while those living in this dispensation who have the same commandments written in their hearts, and love them, hear the words, “Depart from me, ye cursed;” “I never knew you”? (See Jer. 31:33; Heb. 8:10.)
You refer us to Gal. 3:10, and say Saturday-keepers are of the works of the law, hence under the curse. But why single out the fourth commandment, and say “Saturday-keepers.” If keeping the fourth commandment brings us under the curse, then keeping any of them will do the same. If keeping the ten commandments brings us under the curse, to get out from under the curse we must break them; then we must have other gods, worship idols, blaspheme, break the Sabbath, kill, steal, commit adultery, etc., to be free men and women in the gospel. How unreasonable some people will talk, rather than accept a plain commandment that is contrary to the carnal heart. Rom. 8:7.
You mistake the meaning of Gal. 3:10. Paul does not say that they that keep the ten commandments are cursed, but those who seek justification by works instead of by faith. (See chap. 2:16.) But if while we seek to be justified by faith we ourselves are found sinners, is Christ therefore the minister of sin? Does he save us in our sins or while we continue to break the law? God forbid! Verse 17. Faith does not abolish, destroy, or make void the law, but establishes the law. Rom. 3:31. Faith brings the Spirit which writes the law upon our hearts. Heb. 8:10. Faith keeps the commandments of God the Father, as well as the testimony of Jesus Christ. Rev. 12:17.
You say we teach the validity of the ten commandments, and claim that the rest of the law is abolished; but God’s word makes no such division of the law. Indeed, we do teach the validity of the ten commandments. We cannot see how any one could do otherwise, unless he loved sin and crime; for “by the law is the knowledge of sin.” Rom. 3:20; 7:7. Christ and the apostles taught that the law was as valid as the heavens and earth, as we have already shown. But you say that the Scriptures make no distinction between the two laws. Here is just where you, and all who believe as you do, make an inexcusable blunder. You may think these words seem harsh; but I cannot conceive of anything more wicked than to destroy the law that shows what wickedness is. Jesus says that whosoever “shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, shall be called the least [or of no esteem, as some translate the text] in the kingdom of heaven.” But what must the pure and holy beings in heaven think of a man that not only breaks one and teaches others to do so, but destroys the entire law?
Would space permit, I could give you fifty texts to show a plain distinction between the law that was done away, and the one that should endure as long as heaven and earth endures; but I will confine myself to four or five. In Eph. 2:15, Paul says that Christ abolished (Greek, katargeo) in his flesh the law of commandments contained in ordinances. Now turn to Rom. 3:31, where the same apostle says: “Do we then make void [Greek, katargeo] the law through faith? God forbid.” You see that the words for “make void” and “abolish” are the same in the original. Can a law be abolished and not abolished at the same time?
Again: In Rom. 7:14, Paul says we know the law is spiritual, and you admit that he is speaking in this chapter of the law of ten commandments. (See verse 7, which you quote.) Now turn to Heb. 7:16, where Paul is speaking of the law that made the Levites priests, and he calls the commandment carnal. Can the same law be both carnal and spiritual?—Yes, if black can be white and white black. In Heb. 7:18, 19, the apostle speaks of a law which was weak and unprofitable, that could make nothing perfect. Would not a law that is holy, just, good,p. 308 and spiritual, if obeyed, make a man perfect? David says it will. (See Ps. 19:7.) If these scriptures do not convince you that there are two laws, it would be a waste of time to quote further.
(Concluded next week.)