AdventAI

WHAT IS REQUIRED?

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 22., June 2, 1891

A brother has sent us the Advanced Quarterly, of April, 1891, containing the International S. S. Lessons for the second quarter of the present year, issued by the “American Baptist Publication Society.” The “Catechetical Lesson” for June 21, is concerning the fourth commandment. In answer to the question, “What is the fourth commandment?” the commandment is quoted in full from Ex. 20: 8–11. In answer to the next question, “What is required in the fourth commandment?” this answer is given:—

“The fourth commandment requires that we set apart one day in every week for the special worship and service of God, and that we abstain from worldly labors and pleasures, in order to seek him with undivided purposes and affections, that we may have grace to live unto the Lord all the days of our lives.”

This is an answer to which, so far as it goes, no exception can be taken; every statement it makes is true. But this is not sufficient; that “one day in every week” which we are required to set apart, must be specified; and in order to conform to present religious practices, it must be shown that that day is the first day of the week. Hence the next question and answer read as follows:—

“Ques.—Which day of the week is to be kept holy? Ans.—Before the resurrection of Christ, the seventh day was commanded to be kept holy; but since his resurrection, the first day of the week, on which he rose from the dead, is set apart as the Lord’s day. (Mark 16: 9; John 20: 19; 1 Cor. 16: 1, 2; Rev. 1: 10.)”

Our Baptist friends have here barred up against themselves several of the usual runways which many people are inclined to work so zealously nowadays to avoid the claims of the seventh day. First, they admit that all sabbatical obligation rests upon the fourth commandment; secondly, that that commandment has reference to the week, as it sets apart one day in every week for the worship of God; and as an inevitable consequence, thirdly, that the seventh day of the commandment is the seventh day of the week, as we now have it, which it is becoming so popular for ministers to deny; and this is further explicitly admitted, when it is asserted that formerly “the seventh day was commanded to be kept holy,” but now “the first day of the week is set apart,” &c.

On the basis of these principles, they will find it no small job to establish the Sunday: for,—

1. All the reason that ever existed for observing the seventh day, exists still; and the institution must exist so long as the reason exists, unless the Lord is a changeable being, acting without reason.

2. If the Lord should see fit to introduce a new institution for another purpose, that would not affect any pre-existing institution, the reason for which still remained.

3. If the fourth commandment ever required the observance of the seventh day of the week, it requires the same still, unless it can be found where the commandment has been abolished, or where a new commandment has been substituted for it by express announcement, putting some other day in place of the seventh. But this cannot be done.

4. For the seventh day we have the express command of God; for the first day we have the texts named, two of which simply assert that Christ rose on the first day of the week and met with the disciples that day, and the third appoints secular business to be done on the first day, which would not be proper on the Sabbath; and the fourth speaks of a “Lord’s day” without telling us which day of the week it is (and there was no need of its telling; for the Lord had already told what day was his, Mark 2: 28).

Is it possible that any one can take these texts as equivalent for the first day, to the fourth commandment for the seventh day? Is it possible that any one can suppose that these few historical statements, without any instruction to that effect whatever, have superseded the fourth commandment, and that by them “we are required” to discard the former day and keep another day?

But further, even if we grant that the first day of the week is called the Lord’s day, how and where and when has it been “set apart” in any manner whatever? Where has it been told us what we should do with it, and whether it should be observed at all or not, and if it is to be observed, how we should observe it? On all these points the Lord is silent; the “man of sin” alone has spoken.

Where, then, is the foundation for the institution of the first day of the week as the Sabbath? Would a little sawdust spread over water a hundred feet deep, be considered a good foundation to stand upon? It would be better than the foundation for Sunday-keeping.

Keep these facts before the people.