The next question to be considered in connection with the British Indian opium traffic, is whether it has been a detriment or a help to the foreign commerce of British India in the East. Has British India much commerce with China, Thibet, and the other countries which border upon her territory. We cannot ask or answer the question better than it has been asked and answered by a contemporary:—
Why is it that the western and southwestern borders of China are tight locked against Englishmen, while the northwestern borders of the same country hold out open arms to Russians? Why is it that Thibet, the dependent of China, is fast shut against the English on the southern side, while it is as easy for a Russian to cross from the northern side as it is to cross over the border from England to Scotland? There is no other reason but the fact that Russia in the Kuldja treaty puts in an opium prohibition clause, while England is notorious for her desire to flood every corner of the Chinese Empire with Indian opium. And so, for the miserable seven millions of opium revenue, thirty, forty, and perhaps fifty millions or more of honest English traffic is being kept out of the Chinese Empire.
From the foregoing it can easily be seen that there is an unpaying as well as a paying side to the opium traffic.
The opium curse has materially hindered the spread of the gospel in China and Thibet, and the passage of the Anti-opium Bill is only another evidence that God is opening the way for the heralds of his truth to proclaim it, with less to trammel them than in the past.
But although the bill has passed, it is not yet in practical operation, and it is a question whether Lord Salisbury’s government will enforce it as it ought to be enforced or not. It is possible that the present government will not enforce the measure; not because they do not believe in it, but because of the Indian financial deficit that it will cause in the Indian exchequer. If a motion can be passed through the House to the effect that “this House, feeling the pressure of taxation on the people of India, will take steps to re-imburse the deficiency so caused to the Indian Government,” then there will be no question about the enforcing of the anti-opium law itself; for it is this question of re-imbursement that causes the governmental party to halt.
Mr. J. C. Alexander, Secretary for the Society for the Suppression of the Opium Trade (Broadway Chambers, Westminster, London, S. W.), has defined the position of the government, and the present phase of the anti-opium bill, as follows:—
The House has, by a decided majority, affirmed the principle that the opium trade is immoral and unjustifiable. This is so far established that the speaker told Sir Joseph Pease that no amendment would be allowed to be put which would affect the spirit of his resolution (the anti-opium motion), but that the House has not yet decided the question in what way the loss to the Indian Government is to be made up. The government, according to Mr. W. H. Smith’s statement on April 13, have determined to avail themselves of this position to stand between the will of the House and the Indian Government, and decline to make any communication “to the government of India in any official form.”
My own view of the position under these circumstances, is that the House of Commons has now relieved itself from complicity with the opium traffic as far as it has had the opportunity of doing so. I think our agitation will have to go on for the present, but in a somewhat altered form. It will be needless any longer to send petitions to the House of Commons, as it has voted against the trade. It will be desirable in future at the meetings held, to adopt resolutions thanking the House of Commons for its memorable decision, and calling upon the government to give effect to that decision, and to instruct the Indian Government to carry it out; and copies of the resolution should be sent to W. H. Smith as First Lord of the Treasury, and to Viscount Cross as Secretary of State for India. It is also of the utmost importance that the government should be compelled without delay to place the sale of opium in India under restrictions similar to those in force in Great Britain.
But should the present government refuse to take steps to re-imburse the Indian exchequer, their successors in office will in all probability be obliged to. The closing words of the speech of Mr. Samuel Smith, the member for Flintshire, were significant on this point:—
At the next general election the country will make her voice heard on this question. The opium vote will become the test question to candidates in every constituency, and if this Parliament will not carry out her convictions, Great Britain will elect a Parliament that shall establish national righteousness in this direction throughout her empire.
Public opinion is in favor of the suppression of the trade; the secular press is crying out against it, with the exception of the Times and the Scotsman. We wait with interest to know the final result.
P. T. M.