Some weeks ago, the writer came to Spartansburgh, Pa., and opened meetings in the Congregational church.
Spartansburgh is a town of 600 inhabitants, nine miles from Corry, Pa., on the W. N. Y. & P. R. R. Having three church buildings, and only two congregations, an excellent opening was made for meetings in the Congregational church. Most of the Baptists and some of the Methodists attended our meetings, and after we had passed the Sabbath question we received a unanimous invitation to use the Baptist church. It being a much better and larger church, and as most of the Baptists were interested in the truth, we were glad to accept their offer. After having preached there about two weeks, two of the members wrote to Warren County for one Elder Willahan, as this man was their best historian and debater, having at one time (it is said) debated with Elder Whitney. He came to our meetings to debate, and we drew up articles for a four nights’ discussion, and appointed five judges. After the debate, the judges decided in our favor. Elder Willahan was so angry at being beaten, that he shook his fist in our face, and said he would have us locked out of the church. In harmony with this threat, a meeting of the Baptist Preachers’ Association was called to advise with the church. The Baptist ministers from Corry, Titusville, Warren, Bradford, Kane, Oil City, and other places were present. The first session was held with closed doors. The following resolutions were passed and carried to us:—
“Whereas, The conduct of Rev. E. E. Franke seems to be a matter of contention in this church, and must be considered in our deliberations; therefore,—
“1. Resolved, That he be allowed fifteen minutes during our afternoon sessions, to make a personal statement. Be it understood that this statement be confined to his relations to the Baptist church of Spartansburgh, and occupancy of this building.
“2. Resolved, That a copy of these resolutions be sent to him by a messenger from our number.
“P. F. De Lancey, Clerk of Council.”
In harmony with the above, we appeared before the council of Baptist ministers, and in a fifteen minutes’ talk pointed them to God’s truth. After our speech we gave an opportunity for questions, when some questions were asked and answered. It was the intention of the council to excommunicate those who had accepted the truth. But before they had an opportunity to do so, the following was handed in by Bro. Butzer, who was their leading deacon:—
“Spartansburgh, May 22, 1891.”
“TO THE FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF SPARTANSBURGH: We, the undersigned, respectfully request that our names be stricken out of your church books, and we shall no longer consider ourselves members.
“1. Deacon J. L. Butzer. “2. Mr. Newton Rhodes. “3. “ Frank T. Boyles. “4. Mrs. Jennie Boyles. “5. “ C. M. Butzer. “6. “ C. R. Rhodes. “7. “ F. L. White. “8. “ L. B. Lamb. “9. “ Harriet Clark. “10. Mr. Archie S. Rhodes. “11. Mrs. Carrie E. Warner. “12. “ Ella Boutwell. “13. Miss Ida Sliter. “14. “ Maud White. “15. “ Lulu White. “16. “ Louisa Baldwin. “17. Mrs. M. C. Hervey. “18. Miss Rose Baldwin. “19. “ Mary Baldwin. “20. “ Carrie Davis. “21. Miss Mattie March. “22. Mrs. Abnes White. “23. Miss Ella Fee. “24. Mr. Cliff Butzer.”
The ministerial council was wrought up to such an extent that they refused to consider the above, but referred it to the church. They then dismissed the congregation, and passed the following resolutions, which were handed to the Spartansburgh Sentinel, from which I quote the article entire:—
“THE FINDINGS OF THE COUNCIL.”
“The council called to advise with the Baptist church of this place, met last Friday, and after listening to the questions in controversy, promulgated the following resolutions for consideration, for the church to take action upon:—
“Whereas, The Baptist church of Spartansburgh has been disbanded and divided by the heretical teachings of a man named E. E. Franke, a member of the sect known commonly as Seventh-day Adventists; and,—
“Whereas, Said church has invited us to sit in council with them and advise them as to their duty toward Christ, the Church and New Testament truth; therefore be it,—
“1. Resolved, That replying to the question, ‘Can the views held by the sect known as Seventh-day Adventists be consistently entertained by members of Baptist churches,’ we would most respectfully submit that they cannot.
“2. Resolved, That in loyalty to New Testament truth, we feel called upon to recommend to the church, that it withdraw the hand of fellowship from all such brethren as profess and propagate the doctrines held by the Seventh-day Adventists.
“3. Resolved, That we re-affirm our full and definite conviction that the first day of the week is the New Testament Sabbath, or Lord’s day, and as such, is to be observed by Christ’s Church to the end of the world.
“Yet, while as a denomination our belief is clear and unalterable, nevertheless, we recommend Christian charity toward such brethren as, having conscientious doubts on this subject, are willing to walk with the church in all other particulars, participating in the worship on the first day of the week, and refraining from the propagation of dissent.
“4. Resolved, That replying to the question, ‘Whether we ought to allow the meeting-house of the church to be used for the propagation of such doctrines?’ we would answer distinctly and positively, No. The doing of this has already proved a source of distraction to the church, and the mistake made by this church in so granting should never be repeated.
“5. Resolved, That we feel called upon to warn the churches of our association against admitting to their house of worship, any advocate of heretical doctrines of the Seventh-day Adventists, believing those to be subversive of the faith once delivered to the saints.
“6. Resolved, That we earnestly urge the church to take immediate and active steps looking to the settlement of a pastor at once.
W. T. C. Hanna, P. F. De Lancey, Chairman. Clerk.”
“These resolutions the church adopted at their regular covenant meeting last Wednesday evening; they also granted the petition of the twenty-four members who wanted their names erased from the church record.”
In resolution 3, they re-affirm their conviction that the first day of the week is the New Testament Sabbath or Lord’s day, but we have not yet accepted their conviction as a standard of faith and duty. The Baptists have about eight or ten working members left, and the leading trustee and main opposer among them is a pronounced Spiritualist. This matter was also presented to the council by the writer in his speech, but without action. We suppose she can still be a good member of the Baptist Church and be a Spiritualist.
The Bible says in Rev. 18: 2: “Babylon the great is fallen, . . . and is become the habitation of devils, and the hold of every foul spirit.” Is it not true that they have retained the wrong (Spiritualism), and cast out those who follow God’s word?
We are glad that the twenty-four honest souls obeyed God’s word in Rev. 18: 4, where the angel says, “Come out of her, my people.”
May God by his Spirit keep them faithful to his truth. E. E. Franke.
Spartansburgh, Pa., June 7.