A QUEER MIXTURE

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 14, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 28.

Read the full edition

A QUEER MIXTURE.

BY L. C. CHADWICK.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
Under the above heading, the Christian Statesman of May 23 refers to an article that had recently appeared in the Messiah's Herald, of Boston, concerning a liturgy proposed for use in the public schools of New Haven, Conn. It seems that at the recent election of the school board, the Protestants and Roman Catholics united and secured the election of men who favored the restoration of religious exercises in the school. The committee of five persons,—consisting of three Protestant ministers and two Catholic priests,—was appointed to arrange a form of worship to be submitted to the Board of Education. They have agreed upon a liturgy which the Christian Statesman publishes and comments upon as follows:—
“Teacher.—In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. Amen.
“Let us pray:
“Direct, we beseech thee, O Lord, all our actions by thy holy grace, and by thy assistance bring them to a happy issue: that every prayer and work of ours may always begin by thee, and under thy guidance may be finished; through Christ our Lord.
“Children Respond.—Amen.
“Teacher.—Come, O Holy Ghost, replenish the hearts of thy faithful, and enkindle in them the fire of thy love. Send forth thy Spirit, and they shall be created.
“Children Respond.—And thou shalt renew the face of the earth.
“Teacher.—Let us pray:—
“O God, who by the light of the Holy Ghost didst instruct the hearts of the faithful, grant us, we beseech thee, through the same Holy Spirit, a love and relish of what is right and just, and a constant enjoyment of His consolation who lives and reigns world without end.”
Then follow the Lord's Prayer, the Apostles' Creed, and the Ten Commandments, between the first two of which, however, is sandwiched the following astonishing act of worship and supplication:—
“Teacher.—Hail, Mary, full of grace; the Lord is with thee; blessed art thou among women, and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus!”
“Children Respond.—Holy Mary, mother of God, pray for us sinners, now and at the hour of our death. Amen.”
There is no danger that any Protestant community will ever tolerate such an exercise as that in any public school. But the very proposal of such a form of worship illustrates the peril of all attempts at compromise. In the days of the slave power, the compromises to which the nation was schooled were always deeds of surrender. So in this case the proposed liturgy contains not one single idea to which the Romanist objects, while it does contain and inculcate one distinctive idea of the Roman system, the worship of the Virgin Mary. We join in the Herald's condemnation of this attempt “to force by the aid of the law Roman teaching upon the children in public schools,” but we do not acquiesce in its further suggestion: “Let Rome complain that the schools are ‘godless’ rather than permit this.” When we are asked to choose between superstition and atheism, we answer, Neither! The American common school is Christian but not sectarian; bearing no mark of any single denomination, and yet not irreligious.
The Statesman applied the title, “A Queer Mixture,” to the liturgy, but it seems that the title is equally applicable to its comments and the position which it takes in explaining the logical results of their favorite schemes for teaching religion in the public schools. They object seriously to sandwiching in between the first two commandments the supplication to the Virgin Mary, and say that the very proposal “illustrates the peril of all attempts at compromise.”
To the mind of one who looks at this question from the standpoint of the true principles of religious liberty, it only illustrates the peril of any effort to secure the teaching of any religion in the public schools. The Christian Statesman and the association of which it is the organ are ready to join hands with the Roman Catholics or any other organization which will aid them in an effort to secure in our public schools the teaching of the sacredness of Sunday, and the need of its observance and enforcement by law, and they would doubtless raise no objection to having something sandwiched in after the fourth commandment upon this point. But the fact in the case is, that the Catholics have just as much Bible authority for the worship of the Virgin Mary, as have the National Reformers for the observance of Sunday.
There are thousands of people who support and patronize our public schools who do not believe in the sacredness of Sunday, nor wish their children taught it, who have just as much right to protest against the line of instruction which the Christian Statesman frequently urges, as has the Statesman and all Protestants to protest against the insertion of any such Catholic ideas as are referred to above in a form of public worship.
When any person or class of persons separate themselves from the true principles of religious liberty, and undertake to formulate theories of their own in harmony with their own peculiar ideas, there is no telling what “queer mixtures” they will find themselves led into. The Messiah's Herald seems to have had about the right idea when it said: “Let Rome complain that the schools are ‘godless’ rather than permit this.” The Statesman says, “The American common school is Christian but not sectarian.” The common schools could not be Christian without being sectarian. The Roman Catholic has as good a right to ask for his peculiar views to be taught, as the Presbyterian or the Methodist has to ask that his views be taught, so long as there is a single individual citizen of the United States who does not agree with these views or wish his children taught them. When we make our public schools Christian, they cease to be public schools because there are in every community those who have as high views of education as those who would teach religion in the schools and yet do not believe in the Christian religion. May every lover of religious liberty unite to vigorously withstand any effort to make the public schools of our fair country Christian in the sense that the Christian Statesman wants to see them do.