AdventAI

S. D. ADVENTISTS AND THE ATONEMENT.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 28., July 14, 1891

Those who write and speak against the views of S. D. Adventists, would greatly oblige us if they would confine themselves to straightforward legitimate argument, and not deal so largely in misrepresentations. The man who has not discernment enough to understand our position, or, understanding it, has not candor enough to state it correctly, would better not exhibit his accomplishments or his character before the world.

These thoughts are suggested by the reception of a little tract which a friend has sent us, written by one Wm. Easton, of Wellington, issued from the “Bible Truth Press,” of New York, and being scattered, we are told, quite extensively through the country. This man professes to be horrified at our views of the atonement. He is evidently a person of no investigative turn of mind, and his views being run in a theological mold furnished by others, he can only repeat parrot-like what he has been taught. And when any variation is suggested from his established runway, he seems to know not what to do but to fall into a panic, and work himself up into a great fury until he subsides in a fit of nervous prostration.

A few expressions will reveal his state of feeling. Speaking of our doctrines, he says: “They are the worst—the most blasphemous I ever read or heard of, and shock, or ought to shock, every soul truly born of God.” And then occasionally, as he goes on misstating and perverting our views, he interlards the exclamations, “How awful!” “What a revolting idea!” etc., etc.

Now, we presume this man has read or at least “heard of” the worst and wildest blasphemies uttered by the wickedest men on earth; but he says the doctrines of S. D. Adventists are worse than these. Truly, then, they must be something phenomenally awful and revolting. And what is it that he is so disturbed about?—Oh! we do not believe the atonement was made on the cross; and we do not believe the atonement is yet finished. But what is there so terrible in this? He goes on to draw the false and foolish conclusions that if this is the case, Christ did not bear our sins in his body on the tree, that Christ’s blood does not atone for sin, and that Christ has not appeared in the presence of God for us, or at least had not till he entered the most holy place, as we hold, in 1844. Then he accuses us of having the Devil make the atonement, etc.

To any one who will read our views with even ordinary care, it will not be necessary to say anything with reference to such misrepresentations as these. This man fails to see the distinction between Christ bearing our sins as a sacrifice, which he did upon the cross, and his bearing them as a priest, which he does as our mediator before God. He ignores Christ’s service in the first apartment of the true sanctuary above, into which Christ entered when he ascended, and where he was in the presence of God, just as much as he is in the second apartment. He can see no difference between one bearing sins, as the priest did, to atone for them and put them away, and one bearing them, as the scapegoat did, to perish with them. According to his view, Christ must at last go into eternal destruction and oblivion. And these distinctions are generally overlooked in the theological world; and so we have the sacrifice and the priesthood, the offering and the atonement, the forgiveness and the extinction of sin, all thrown together into one “conglomerated mux,” which is a veritable Pandora’s box of vagueness and confusion which have so long afflicted the religious world on this all-important subject.

Mr. E. takes great exception to the idea that the atonement is not yet completed. But is it? Let us see. Are sins atoned for before they are committed, repented of, or forgiven? If so, the most ultra doctrine of predestination, election, and reprobation, is true; the human race is in the inexorable grasp of fate; there is no free moral agency; every one is a machine, and may as well, first as last, submit to the inevitable. If the atonement was made upon the cross, either the horrible doctrine just stated is true, or the doctrine of universal salvation is true; for Christ there bore the sins of the world. Why will not men learn the character and order of events in the work of Christ for the salvation of men? According to the type, the atonement comes at the conclusion, not at the beginning, of Christ’s work as priest in behalf of sinners; and those only will secure its blessings who have sought them through his name.