THE publication of pope Leo's latest encyclical does not seem to have created any great sensation in either the religious or the political world. No one expected, perhaps, that it would; still, the knowledge of the fact that great care was being taken in its preparation, and that it was designed by its originators to be a document of more than usual importance, led the public to wait with more than ordinary interest its appearance. As was expected, it treats very largely upon some of the leading questions of the day; but it does not seem to have handled them in anything more than a commonplace manner. The general verdict of those who have finished the task of reading it, is evidently not far from that of the well-known English writer, contemporary with Milton, who expressed his opinion of “Paradise Lost” by saying, “If length be not a merit, it hath no other.”
The encyclical deals mainly with existing social difficulties, a large part of it being devoted to a maintenance of the individual right of private property, as against the views and demands of the socialists. In it, strange to say, the pope appears as the champion of individual rights, and takes a position far in advance of that of some Protestant journals which have taken occasion to express their views on the subject. He has carefully noted the strong democratic tendency which is being more and more felt in all parts of the civilized world, and deems it wise to place himself in harmony with it. Under his leadership, the papacy now aims to control and guide the spirit which manifestly it would be hazardous to repress. And in this doubtless her choice has been a wise one.
In what light is this lengthy and authoritative utterance of the papal church to be regarded? Is it to be judged simply by what appears upon its face? Such seems to be the opinion of some Protestant journalists who have given it their notice. Thus a leading New York journal speaks of it as a deliverance coming from a personage held in the highest honor, and speaking with supreme authority to half the Christian Church in the world; infused with a sweet spirit; and as being “the utterances of a good and earnest man who is a thousand-fold better than his predecessor.” We cannot logically arrive at that conclusion. We fail to see how Pope Leo can be a thousand-fold better than another pope whom he deems to have been infallible, and whose official doings he must accordingly himself indorse. Our opinion of the encyclical must be determined by a consideration of the motives which prompted it, and it must be borne in mind that the papacy does not speak at one time independently of all that it has asserted at other times. Its acts and utterances down through the centuries form a connected whole, and we cannot separate one act and judge it apart from all the others. The papacy of to-day is to be viewed and judged in the light of all of the facts of papal history. Rome never changes. She has ever one and the same object in view; namely, the subjection of the entire world, spiritual and temporal, religious and civil, to the authority of her head. The same motive which has actuated her in all the past, underlies her actions to-day. If this be not so, then Rome has changed, and now has some other end in view than that for which she has struggled for centuries in the past.
The only logical conclusion, therefore, is that motives of policy have had more to do with the wording of the present encyclical than any real sympathy with the democratic spirit of the age. The ignorance and superstition of past centuries have favored the method of propagation and preservation of the faith which came to an end with the reign of Pius IX. The mental and moral enlightenment of the present century have made another method of work an absolute necessity to success. This method Pope Leo has inaugurated, and the encyclical just issued affords perhaps the best illustration yet given of its milder and more conciliatory nature.
L. A. S.