GOVERNMENTAL PATERNALISM.
By A. W. Bartlett
This is pre-eminently an age in which the cry of governmental paternalism rises above all other clamors for reform. It is proposed that nearly all the evils which afflict mankind may be abolished by the simple dictum, “Be it enacted.” The world has been oppressed for ages under monarchical and Church forms of government, and men in these latter days have turned for relief to a republican form of government. But what is this in the midst of republicanism that lifts its head for recognizance, claiming to bestow on mankind the largest measure of temporal and spiritual prosperity? On every hand we hear the cry, “Let the Government control the railways, and we will have cheaper transportation.” “Let the Government resolve itself into a great loan office, where unlimited money can be had at two per cent. interest, and hard times will cease.” “Let the Government take in hand the religious education of its people, and the millennium will soon be ushered in.” What is the despair of individualism is the hope of governmental paternalism. But is not every government made up of individuals? If corrupt, shrewd, and unscrupulous men now so manipulate elections and law-making bodies as to bring about the present state of oppression to the poor, and encourage thereby the mighty tide of lawlessness and crime now sweeping over the land, would these conditions be bettered by delegating these powers to a paternal form of government? or, in other words, can golden conduct be derived from leaden instincts? We have a few illustrations in our midst of the state of things which would exist were this much-idolized form of government to ensue. In the Arena of May, 1891, in the editorial notes, we read:— The tyranny of authority over hostile or unpopular thought has, as a rule, been measured only by its power. But we are gravely informed that what has been unquestionably true of despotisms, whether secular or religious, in the past, will not to-day apply to a social despotism. We are assured that in the hands of the masses there will be no danger of tyranny. Here again, however, history warns us of the fallacy of such an assumption. Wherever the power and authority of a despot are vested, whether with the individual, the Church, or the State, sooner or later tyranny will appear. Monarchs given absolute power have, in rare instances, proved benignant, and not abused their trust, but in due time successors have exhibited all the ferocity of tyrants. Even religions, which are supposed to appeal to the ideal and the lofty in man’s soul, once given power, have manifested the savage cruelty of demons.
Nor do we find the State, under the rule of the masses, any exception to this rule; and because this fact is so serious, I must emphasize it by citing a few illustrations of exhibitions of State tyranny in our midst at the present time,—tyranny which shows that persecutions are only limited by the power vested in the State; tyranny which is blossoming at the present moment from the identical material from which Socialists propose to make their all-powerful government. There is to-day under indictment and fine in Tennessee, a man who sincerely believes that Saturday instead of Sunday should be religiously observed. After worshiping God according to the dictates of his own conscience on Saturday, he performed work on Sunday, as he could ill afford to be idle on the day which he regards in no way sacred. For this work he was arrested, prosecuted, branded a felon, and incarcerated. He had committed no crime. He in no way deserved the shameful imprisonment to which he was subjected; yet the prejudice of the majority sustains the infamous law that makes criminals of the innocent and takes not into consideration the rights of the minority. If in any State the Adventists, the Hebrews, or any other people who believe in observing Saturday instead of Sunday should happen to predominate, and they undertook to throw Christians into dungeons, and, after branding them criminals, should send them to the penitentiary for working on Saturday, indignation would blaze forth throughout all Christendom against the great injustice, the wrong against the liberty of the rights of the citizen. The only difference is, that the man above referred to is in the minority; he is the type of those who always have been and always will be made to suffer when government is strong enough to persecute all who do not accept what is considered truth and right by the majority. Another illustration is found in the prosecution of a lady of Dubuque, Iowa, who, after the orthodox physicians had pronounced two cases in a neighboring town absolutely hopeless, was called to minister to them. In each instance the patient consigned to the grave by the regular physician, recovered under the gentle administrations of this woman. As soon as the cures were assured, she prepared to return to her home, but before she could take the train, she was arrested for a common felon, prosecuted, and fined fifty dollars, because, to use the exact words of the indictment, “she had practiced a cure on Mrs. Geo. B. Freeman, and others, contrary to the law of the State of Iowa.” And this is true. She had violated a most infamous law. She was branded as a criminal though the only crime she had committed was ministering to those supposed to be dying, and calling them back to life. Yet we are gravely informed that there is no danger of tyranny in a republic. I repeat, that the intolerance of a republic is frequently limited only by its power. We have seen the practical working of governmental paternalism in ancient Rome and modern Russia. Previous to the French Revolution, the infatuated Frenchmen were deluded with the promise of a government that would banish poverty and enrich all. Liberty, fraternity, and equality were the magic words of the times. The national convention, in its war against the Christian religion and civil rights of mankind, and the reign of terror that followed, teach us that like causes produce like results. 175 Central Ave., Indianapolis, Ind.