ONE OR THE OTHER—WHICH?

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 30, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 26.

Read the full edition

ONE OR THE OTHER—WHICH?

BY ELDER C. H. BLISS.
(Spring Valley, Minn.)
That theological thinkers who have hitherto defended the natural immortality of man are in a dilemma, is evident from confessions which occasionally come to light. The following from Dr. Lyman Abbott, at the time he was installed pastor of Plymouth church, has been published. Speaking of future probation, he says:—
The hypothesis that Christ will be presented in another life to all who have not known him here, I do not accept for lack of evidence to support it.
This would seem to indicate that Mr. Abbott would henceforth repudiate any hope of future probation. What, then, becomes of those who failed to accept offered mercies before death? After speaking further of the uncertainty of the future state, and referring to the fact that the time will come when the song of rejoicing will rise from every creature in heaven, and on the earth, and under the earth, he says:—
If there are then any voices not joining in that choral of redeeming love, I believe it will be because they are silent in that second death, from which there is no resurrection.
He further says, speaking of endless conscious sin:—
It has grown to me unthinkable; I believe it is unscriptural.
It is evident that Mr. Abbott is either a Universalist or an annihilationist. It is doubtful if he is fully settled in either view. But his words show the drift of his mind. Indeed, we have come to a time when no intelligent, thoughtful student of the Bible, imbued with love to Christ, can believe for a moment in the eternal torture of the wicked. But what becomes of them? The choice is between Universalism and annihilationism.
If such men could let go the dogma of the natural immortality of the soul, how easy it would be to accept the plain statement of the Bible, that “the wages of sin is death” (the second death), and that immortality, or eternal life, is a gift of God through Christ. While it is to be regretted that many who know the truth on this subject will not openly avow it, yet it is a matter of some encouragement to know that the precious seeds of truth are germinating and growing. The truth, like the leaven in the meal, is at work, and “it will triumph by and by.”