UNDER the above heading, the Christian at Work of June 11 says:—
“The theological world is in a ferment. Two great churches are in trouble over the teachings of their own seminaries. Andover Seminary is before the courts for the heresy of proclaiming probation after death, and the Presbyterian General Assembly has just refused its consent to the election of its professor of Biblical Theology, because of his views, which in its opinion disqualifies him for the office of theological instructor in Union Seminary. Awhile ago Bishop Cummings left the Protestant Episcopal Church for the larger liberty of the Reformed Episcopal Church, which he and others founded. Dr. Dowling leaves the Baptist denomination because he could not stand the narrowness of close communion, and finds greater freedom among the Reformed (Dutch) brethren. Dr. Bridgman also withdraws from the Baptists because editors and theological professors criticise his position on eternal punishment; and so he seeks a new expansion for his beliefs in the Protestant Episcopal Church. The standing committees of Episcopal dioceses all through the land are exceptionally agitated over the question whether to grant or to refuse their consent to the confirmation of Dr. Phillips Brooks as Bishop. Rev. Heber Newton is arraigned for preaching false and injurious doctrines on the resurrection of Christ, and other points.”
It is evident that the conflict between established religious forms and ideas, and that which is termed advanced theology, is becoming more and more extended, until it seems that the whole system of that which has been considered Christian orthodoxy is threatened with disruption. On all sides there is seen the movement of denominations or their prominent representatives leaving the limits of their once accepted creeds, and passing over to whatever positions they may be led in obedience to the demands of “progressive” and “liberal” thought. In some instances, doubtless, this apparently forward movement is a real advance toward a more perfect Christian faith, and one to be fostered and encouraged. The orthodox creeds of the present are by no means so nearly perfect as to admit of no improvement. But the evidence shows that more often the progress is in another direction. A perfect Christian faith is one which is in perfect accord with revelation, rather than one which may be dictated by any conclusions of human reason, even the most enlightened. And therein is the real value of revelation. It gives us a knowledge of man’s relations to God which could never be obtained by any exercise of which the human faculties are capable. But in many of the ideas which are now being advanced as an improvement on those hitherto held by the majority of the Christian world, it is evident that no great effort has been made to conform more closely to the statements of inspiration as the foundation of all true religious belief. So far as Scripture is noticed, the effort seems to be rather to find interpretations therefor which will harmonize it with these ideas, which have been first drawn from the resources of the human mind. Reason, in short, has been exalted above revelation, and as a result, the Christian world seems to be fairly started on a course of theological wandering to which there is no limit. The declarations of Scripture are fixed and unchangeable, and the only progress which is to be sought for in theology is in the direction of a more perfect understanding of these declarations of God’s word. If we are not to rely upon these, then, as stated, we are left to a course of endless speculation; for it is not to be expected that the ideas of to-day, so far as they are of human origin, will not be outgrown by those of the future, as have been many times over those of the past. The same experience, on a smaller scale, forms ap. 407 part of the religious life of almost every individual, and is attended by the same danger to his spiritual welfare. His early religious ideas, gathered from various sources and fashioned by the imperfect powers of childhood, give place to the better knowledge of maturer years; and unless the relation between his knowledge and his religion is one of harmony and union,—if, in other words, he continues to hold to religious ideas which his better sense and reason tell him to be false,—the result will be most disastrous; for his religion will only become a dry husk, disconnected from his active life, and altogether valueless. In the progress of thought which comes from the development of his intellect, his theology must not be left behind. But on the other hand, he must not become so progressive as to cut loose from that which God has revealed in his word, and construct a theology out of the resources of his own mind. A very large portion of the Christian world have outgrown in their belief some of the plainest and simplest Scripture statements, such as those found in the first chapter of Genesis, those descriptive of the miracles of Bible times, and various other portions. This is a kind of growth which no Christian can afford to experience. For him, there is no source of knowledge which can take precedence of a plain “thus saith the Lord.” The moment this ceases to be the case, at that moment he virtually throws aside all that revelation has said, and becomes his own guide to that celestial realm which he expects finally to reach.
Though the theological world is thus disquieted, and men are everywhere seen abandoning vital points of the faith once delivered to the saints, the fact remains that this grand faith itself is imperishable and unchangeable. “The foundation of God standeth sure.” Let every spirit which speaks new things be tried and tested. “To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.”
L. A. S.