AdventAI

IS MAN IMMORTAL?*

By L. G. Moore

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 42., October 27, 1891

BY ELDER L. G. MOORE.

We will now turn our attention to the question, “Is man immortal?” considering it from a Bible standpoint. Gradually the mind unfolds to the consciousness of existence. Life—what is it? Upon whom and what does it depend? Having commenced, will it always continue? Does death end all? These and kindred thoughts crowd upon the mind. In our perplexity, we turn for instruction to those about us. Can they solve the mystery of our existence? Much to our surprise, we find that they, too, are as unlearned as we. To whom, then, shall we turn for instruction? Who can help us? Then we remember that “vain is the help of man,” and we turn to the Source of all wisdom, to the One who created us. He certainly can solve this problem. But how can we learn of Him whose face has never been seen by man, whose voice none can bear to hear? He, the Creator, the mighty God, the Jehovah, has given us a revelation, and to it we will go for instruction. It certainly must instruct us concerning our nature and destiny.

As a foundation, let us examine the scripture found in Gen. 2 : 7: “And the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.” Here we have a clear account of the creation of man, and that he was formed of the dust of the ground. Further on, in chapter 3 : 19, God tells Adam that he shall return unto the ground; “for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.” We learn, then, that we are of the “earth, earthy.” Thus far, all are in harmony. But what constitutes the life, the soul, of man? Here comes a division. God says that he “breathed” into his (Adam’s) nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.” What would we infer from this but that previous to “God’s breathing” he, the man (Adam), was a lifeless soul? If so, then a “lifeless soul” cannot see, though it has eyes; cannot hear, though furnished with ears; cannot speak, although the organs of speech are present. Eccl. 9 : 5, 6. Why?—Because there is no life in the body, no breath, as James has it. James 2 : 26.

What, then, was it that caused Adam to live? The “breath” that God gave him?—Yes; certainly. Without that he was dead. Why?—Because he, being of the earth, earthy, had no inherent life in himself. If the breath that God gave Adam made him immortal, as is taught, how was it that he died? For to be immortal is to be “exempt from liability to die.” Those who are immortal can never die. And furthermore, if the breath rendered Adam immortal, would it not render the living creatures that God had made, immortal also? The record says, “They all have one breath.” “All are of the dust, and all turn to dust again.” Eccl. 3 : 19, 20.

In the account of the deluge, we read (Gen. 7 : 15): “And they went in unto Noah into the ark, two and two of all flesh, wherein is the breath of life.” Again (verses 21, 22): “And all flesh died, . . . all in whose nostrils was the breath of life [margin, Hebrew, the breath of the spirit of life].” There could not have been at that time any immortal principle residing in the breath of men or animals; for had there been, how could they have died? Wherein, then, does man’s immortality consist? Not in the breath, certainly, and surely not in the dust from which he was formed.

If by reason of the “breath of life” man was rendered immortal, why did God say that if he ate of the forbidden fruit, he should “surely die”? How could he die if immortal? Why, if immortal, must he continue to eat of the “tree of life” to remain so? That his life depended upon continued access to the tree of life, we know; for after he had sinned, God guarded the tree of life, lest he put forth his hand, and eat and live forever. Gen. 3 : 22–24. And as God had told him that if he ate of the forbidden fruit, he should die, he was driven from the source of life, in order that sin be not immortalized. By virtue of the fruit of the “life tree,” Adam’s posterity lived many hundred years, until the life principle became exhausted. In the restoration, we find that the redeemed will have a right to the tree of life which now grows in the paradise of God. (See Rev. 2 : 7; 22 : 2, 14.)

From whence, then, has man his immortality? Why, says one, the Bible declares that man is immortal. But hold! where is the proof? You say that over and over again, it says man is immortal. Does it?—Yes, you assure me. But how many times does it say man has immortality?—Why, hundreds of times. You no doubt think so, but give me fifty places where it declares that man is immortal. Can you not find fifty?—No. Twenty?—No. Ten?—No. Five?—No. One?—No, my dear friends, not even in one place in all the Bible does it say that man is immortal. Neither in any place does it intimate that he is. But it does say (Rom. 6 : 23) that “the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life [immortality] through Jesus Christ our Lord.” Paul, in 2 Tim. 1 : 10, says that Christ “hath brought life and immortality to light through the gospel,” but not through heathen philosophy. And furthermore, Paul, in speaking of God (1 Tim. 6 : 16), says, “Who only hath immortality,” etc. If God only has it, is man yet in possession of it?—No, indeed. God has it, and will give it to those only, who by patient continuance in well-doing, seek for it.

Man is of the “earth, earthy,” and, “if in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable.” Man not having life in himself, death would end all, were it not that Christ has received life in himself from God the Father (John 5 : 26), and has power to confer that life (immortality) upon those who are Christ’s at his coming. 1 Cor. 15 : 19–23. When?—At Christ’s coming. As before stated, if the breath of life proves immortality for man, it must prove the same for every creature to whom it was given. Adam was just as essentially a man before the breath of life was imparted, as after. There was this difference: before, he was a lifeless man, a dead man; afterward, a living man. The bodily organs were there all ready for the vitalizing influence of the breath of life.

An engine is as much an engine before the steam is applied, as afterward. The bolts, bars, shafts, wheels, etc., are all in place, but there is no motion. Apply the steam, the motive power, the breath, if you please, and it becomes a thing of life and power, as it were. So with man previous to his receiving the “breath of life.” He was perfect in every organ, but he lacked life, in fact, he was dead. God supplied what was lacking, and he “became a living soul,” or body. But what is the soul? The thinking, reasoning part in man, you say. Yes; this is the accepted opinion of Christendom. To admit this will not make the soul immortal, however. The thinking, reasoning part dies with the body. For proof of this, let us read Ps. 146 : 3, 4: “Put not your trust in princes, nor in the son of man, in whom there is no help. His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.” (To perish means “to be destroyed, go to destruction, come to nothing, decay,” etc.) There is certainly nothing immortal about such a soul. Job, in speaking of the dead, says, “His sons come to honor, and he knoweth it not.” Chapter 14 : 21. But if the soul be immortal (exempt from death), what would hinderp. 658 him from knowing about the loved ones left behind?

Again: you say that the “soul is the thinking part of man.” But what is thought?—Action of the mind, matter acting upon matter in the brain. Of what is the brain composed?—Of eight-tenths water, a little fat, albumen, sulphur, lime, etc. These are all simple substances, all material, but so arranged in the masterpiece—man—that they can think, reason, love, hate, etc. Must we therefore conclude that they are immortal? If reasoning, thinking, loving, and hating are proofs of immortality, must we not therefore conclude that the lower animals are immortal? Can these simple substances that enter into the composition of the brain, think, reason, love, and hate, separate from the body? No, you say. But why not, if the brain, the thinking part, is the soul, and therefore immortal? Does its immortality depend upon its contact with the body? If immortal, why not reason, love, and hate without the body?

What, then, is the meaning of the term “soul” in the text under consideration? Does it not mean, the man, the person, the body? For proof, let us read a few Scripture texts. “And the king of Sodom said unto Abram, Give me the persons [Hebrew, souls].” Gen. 14 : 2. “And Esau took . . . all the persons [Hebrew, souls].” Gen. 36 : 6. “Whose feet they hurt with fetters: he was laid in iron [Hebrew, his soul came into iron].” Ps. 105 : 18. How can an immortal, immaterial soul be bound in prison with fetters of iron? Joseph, however, was bound in that way (the man Joseph, Hebrew, soul). If Adam was not a soul before, how could he become a “living soul” afterward, simply by the introduction of the “breath of life”? The truth is, he was a lifeless body, or soul, before the breath of life was given, and then, at the “breathing” of God, he became a living man, or soul, a living person, capable of acting, thinking, moving, etc.

That the Hebrews so understood the word, there is abundant proof. Kitto, in his “Religious Encyclopedia,” under the term “Adam,” says: “And Jehovah, God, formed the man [Hebrew, the Adam] of dust from the ground, and blew into his nostrils the breath of life, and man became [passed from a dead state to one of life] a living animal.” And furthermore, he says that there is nothing in the term “living soul” that would warrant the idea of man’s preeminence over the animal creation. He says, “We should be acting unfaithfully if we were to assume its being contained or implied in this passage.” Paul says: “There is a natural body; and there is a spiritual body. And so it is written, the first Adam was made a living soul [a natural body]; the last Adam [Christ] was made a quickening spirit [or spiritual body]. . . . And as we have borne the image of the earthy [or of Adam], we shall also bear the image of the heavenly.” 1 Cor. 15 : 44. “Who shall change our vile [natural] body, that it may be fashioned like unto his glorious [spiritual] body,” which will take place at the resurrection. Phil. 3 : 21. “For this corruptible [the dead] must put on incorruption, and this mortal [not immortal] must put on immortality.” 1 Cor. 15 : 53.

But if we already have immortality, how can we put it on? If immortal, how can we die? For that which is immortal never dies. “It is exempt from death.” The term “living soul” is repeatedly applied to the animals brought into existence at the creation. “And God said, Let the waters bring forth abundantly the moving creature that hath life [margin, Hebrew, soul].” Gen. 1 : 20. “And to every beast of the earth, and to every fowl of the air, and to everything that creepeth upon the earth, wherein there is life [margin, Hebrew, a living soul].” If, therefore, by the term “living soul,” we are to understand some inherent, incorruptible essence or spirit in man that cannot die, we must infer the same for every living creature that God has made. We have scriptural evidence to show that the “living soul” “is not exempt from death.”

Speaking of the terrible destruction under the second plague, Rev. 16 : 3 says that every “living soul died in the sea.”

There is, then, no ground for believing that man is naturally immortal from the account as given in the 2nd chapter of Genesis. Though the Bible speaks to us 873 times of the soul, it never once calls it an “immortal soul,” and though it tells us 827 times of the spirit, it never once tells us of a “deathless spirit.” But notwithstanding the frequent use of these words, they are never once qualified by such expressions as “immortal,” “deathless,” “never-dying,” etc., which so much abound in modern theology. Immortality is the “gift” of God, and if we ever receive it, it will be because we have sought for it through Christ. (See Rom. 2 : 6–11; 6 : 23.)

Notes

  1. *Abstract of a discourse delivered at Good Templar’s Hall, Grand Rapids, Mich. ↩