DISCUSSION AT DAVIS CITY, IOWA

1%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 27, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 42.

Read the full edition

DISCUSSION AT DAVIS CITY, IOWA.

BETWEEN CLARK BRADEN AND MATTHEW LARSON.

According to previous arrangements, the discussion, upon the following propositions, between Elder Clark Braden and myself at the above-named place, was begun April 21:—
1. Do the Scriptures teach that the ten commandments, recorded in Exodus 20, are now binding, the fourth precept of which enjoins the observance of the seventh day as the Sabbath, or Lord’s day, as taught and practiced by the Seventh-day Adventist Church? (Matthew Larson affirms; Clark Braden denies.)
2. Do the Scriptures teach that the day designated in Rev. 1: 10 is the first day of the week, and should be observed as taught and practiced by the Disciple Church. (Clark Braden affirms; Matthew Larson denies.)
This discussion was subject to the following conditions:—
1. Five sessions of two hours each shall be devoted to the consideration of each proposition, each speaker occupying half an hour alternately.
2. The time may be extended on either proposition by either party, not to exceed two sessions, provided such extension of time be demanded during the fourth session on either proposition.
3. It shall be the privilege of either speaker to devote such a portion of his time in each speech to asking his opponent such questions as he may see fit, said questions to be so constructed as to admit of a direct answer, and shall be answered frankly without evasion, provided the party can answer.
4. No rulings of the moderators shall debar either disputant from using such lexicons, commentaries, or other authorities as he may see fit.
For the benefit of those not familiar with the circumstances by which the discussion was brought about, and which seemed to make it necessary, we offer the following explanation and statement of facts:—
It has been evident for some time in the past, that quite a number of the citizens of this place, members of the different denominations, have been considerably exercised, and their conscience not a little disturbed over the teachings of the Bible on the claims of the Lord’s Sabbath, and hence have greatly felt the need of some one to come and give them, if possible, relief, by fixing it up in some way.
An opportunity was at length presented. Last December Mr. Clark Braden, the well-known lecturer and writer, and noted debater of the Disciple Church, chanced this way. The opportunity was eagerly improved by employing him to deliver a course of lectures on the Adventists, during which the pugnacious boaster, like Goliath of old, took occasion to defy and “challenge the entire Seventh-day Adventist fraternity of the world, for a joint discussion at Davis City, Iowa,” declaring he had “backed them all out” from Maine to California, and that no one could stand before him. The clamor for debate at length reached fever heat; nothing else would do but a debate. It was, however, supposed that when the excitement had had time to subside, and Mr. Braden’s impolite and unchristian course could be seen in the proper light, they would conclude he was not the proper man to represent them, even though truth might lie on their side.
But no. They had settled on him, it mattered not if he did not act like a Christian gentleman. What they wanted was some one to down the Adventists. The citizens of Davis City had voted to accept him, and a committee had been appointed by them to correspond with the chairman of the Iowa Conference in regard to the matter. Finding that nothing else would satisfy them, and that the cause of truth was likely to suffer, rather than receive benefit by a refusal to defend our positions against him, it was at last decided best to meet him, as one of that class mentioned by Paul to Titus (Titus 1:11): “whose mouths must be stopped, who subvert whole houses, teaching things which they ought not, for filthy lucre’s sake.”
With but few exceptions, his arguments were the same old thread-worn arguments of antinomianism. He seemed to possess no conscientious scruples, either in regard to his behavior, or to taking absurd and contradictory positions, admitting in one speech what he would squarely contradict in another, and so on throughout the entire debate.
We here give a few examples of some positions which seemed peculiar to himself. He asserted that there was not a single text or intimation in the Old Testament to the effect that the Sabbath was ever set apart to be observed as a day for religious worship, or that any persons were ever to meet outside their own tents or houses; that its observance consisted in staying at home, and simply doing nothing. In reply to which we referred him to Eze. 46:1–3; Isa. 66:23; Lev. 23:3. He also asserted that the Sabbath had no preparation day. We referred him to Luke 23:54–56; Mark 15:42; Ex. 16:23.
His main effort was to lead off on some side issue, throw dust, and bulldoze; but as the discussion advanced, his weakness and inconsistency became more and more apparent to the minds of all the unprejudiced,—the sensible and thinking class of the community. He not only did not hesitate to renounce and denounce the standard writers and teachings of his own church, but likewise when an appeal was made to the standard authorities, dictionaries, and Greek and Hebrew lexicons on the meaning or definition of certain words, if it did not suit his notions, he would set them to one side by a—“What do I care for what Donnegan or Gesenius say?”
With this happy faculty of twisting and turning things to suit his own purpose, and covering up an argument by simply denying and throwing dust, his prejudiced partisans tried to ease their consciences by making themselves believe that he was doing very well, in his effort to overthrow the law, and to establish in its stead his licentious and lascivious gospel of no-law-ism, with its glorious (?) liberty from the “Thou shalts” and the “Thou shalt nots.” But we showed this to be an entirely different gospel from the one preached by the apostles and the good of all ages. (See Matt. 1:21; Rom. 13:9; James 2:10–12.)
It soon began to be quite evident that Mr. Braden himself was getting uneasy and beginning to tremble for the outcome, when it should fall to him to take the affirmative, and hints to the effect that he would pull off before his time was up, were soon confirmed by the following note from his own pen:—
Davis City, Iowa, April 27, 1891.
Matthew Larson.
Dear Sir: Next Tuesday night, May 5, I begin a debate in Lamoni, to continue ten or twelve nights. In it, there will be much appeal to history, documents, Book of Mormon, and Mormon books. It will require much reading, searching books and authorities, and much annotation and writing. As I have been traveling and am not in one place more than a week, I could not have my books sent to me,—could not carry them around,—and have not been able to make the preparation needed for the Lamoni debate. If this debate continues five nights, I will have only one day to look up matters. I will have no rest, and will be compelled to enter that debate unprepared. I will affirm three nights, and close the debate Thursday night. Arrange your matters accordingly. This is positive. I will control my own affirmative in regard to time, as you did yours.
Yours, CLARK BRADEN.
To which I replied as follows:—
Davis City, Iowa, April 28, 1891.
Mr. Clark Braden.
Dear Sir: I have the honor of acknowledging your letter of the 27th inst., sent me by the hand of Mr. Harrison this morning (the 28th). The contents have been noted, and I will hasten to reply. I must confess that this peremptory manner in which you now propose to close this discussion, affords me no little surprise, and is contrary to all rules of honorable debate, and I cannot, therefore, consent to it. If you close this discussion as you now intend, you will understand that it will not be with my consent, but I shall hold you responsible for a failure to come up to your agreement. The excuses which you present, as a justification for the course you are about to pursue, should have been thought of before you accepted those rules and entered the discussion. It is now rather late in the day to shield yourself behind such a flimsy refuge. When I agreed to meet you, it was with the express understanding that the terms agreed upon should be lived up to, and on no other conditions would I have consented. You say that you will control your affirmative the same as I do mine. Very well. Did I not comply with everything agreed to? Did I cut the time short of the agreement? You know I did not. Now, sir, if you will control your affirmative as I did mine, we will debate this question for seven sessions (for which I have prepared), or at least, not less than five. I shall not arrange to do otherwise. I shall insist on your living up to your agreement as I have to mine.
Respectfully Yours, MATTHEW LARSON.
We tried our best to hold him to his agreement, but it was of no avail. He replied as follows:—
Davis City, Iowa, April 28, 1891.
Mr. Larson: I have stated reasons for shortening the debate which a gentleman would deem to be sufficient. I have given you warning in time. I now tell you positively and peremptorily, that the debate will close Thursday night. That is final, and an end to all correspondence in regard to the matter.
Yours, CLARK BRADEN.
The above impolite and uncourteous note is but a faint sample of his style throughout the entire debate. In the opening of his second speech, on the third night of his affirmative, he coolly announced to the congregation that this would be his closing speech; although he had expressly agreed to affirm not less than five sessions, and longer at the option of either party. He said he was tired, and needed rest and time to prepare for his debate at Lamoni, to be given May 5.
But that the reader may see the flimsy transparency of this subterfuge behind which he thus sought to excuse himself, we present the following facts:—
1. His arrangements for the Lamoni debate had been made nearly three months before this, hence giving him all the time needed to prepare for it, before he entered this one. Besides, the time did not come in conflict in any way.
2. Mr. Braden had registered to preach in the Union church, at Davis City, said register was made the same day he wrote me his note containing the above excuses for shortening the debate, to which the following will testify:—
I hereby certify that Mr. Braden had an appointment registered for Friday and Saturday nights, May 1, 2, 1891, at the Union church, said register was made April 27, 1891. S. B. Bullock, Sexton.
3. Mr. B. remained and filled his appointment, as above registered. In fact, he stayed at Davis City until Monday, May 4. Thus it will be seen that his excuses were no excuses at all.
His arguments in defense of Sunday were a complete failure. It is reported that even his most prejudiced friends concede that he gave his case completely away, making an entire failure. But he did as well as could be done. He spent almost his entire time in his first session, trying to review his arguments on the first proposition, thereby confessing that he did not feel at all satisfied with his efforts on it.
He next undertook to prove that the adjective “kuriakee” (Rev. 1:10), derived from the noun “kurios,” being a new title, must be used to designate a new institution, but this flimsy deduction we had completely demolished by showing that new titles were frequently introduced to designate old institutions; for example, Pentecost (Acts 2:1) and circumcision. Phil. 3:2. He also claimed that kuriakee was never used with reference to any one but Christ. We showed him that even though this assertion were true, it would afford him no relief, since Christ had never commanded the observance of the first day, never blessed or sanctified it, never blessed any one for keeping it, nor condemned them for not; in fact, he had never mentioned the day in any way, so far as the Bible was concerned. On the other hand, we proved that Christ created all things. Col. 1:16. Hence he it was who rested on the seventh day at creation, and since the same person who rested, blessed and sanctified the day, he it was who had blessed and sanctified it. “All things were made by him.” John 1:3. “The Sabbath was made” (Mark 2:27), hence Christ made the Sabbath. He kept it (Luke 4:16), taught others how it should be kept (Matt. 12:8–12), enjoined its sacredness to be observed as late as A. D. 70. Matt. 24:20; 5:17–19. How proper, then, to call this day the Lord’s day, “Lordean,” or “Lordic day.”
We then proceeded to call attention to the fact that since the noun “kurios,” from which the adjective “kuriakee” is derived, is used interchangeably in the New Testament to designate both God and Christ (Luke 2:22, 26; Acts 2:34; Rev. 11:15), the only way we could determine definitely to whom it is applied in any certain case, would be by the context.
We then read Rev. 1:8 in connection with verse 10, thus showing that in the text under consideration, the Lord (kurios) just spoken of, was the Lord God Almighty. Hence the only natural conclusion would be that this text (Rev. 1:10) referred directly to him, instead of to Christ. The Sabbath belongs to him also as well as to Christ. (See Isa. 58:13; Ex. 20:8–11.) “I and my Father are one,” said Christ. John 10:30. They are in partnership; hence what belongs to God belongs to Christ. Thus it is Christ’s day, and it is the Lord Jehovah’s day also. It was observed by the early Christians, Luke 23:56. It was the “manner,” or custom, of the disciples to devote this day to preaching, or religious worship, to both Jews and Gentiles. Acts 13:42–44; 16:13; 17:2; 18:1–4.
I called upon the Elder over and over again, to produce one single instance, or text, of the kind, for Sunday-keeping, declaring it to have been their custom, or manner, so to devote the first day, and we would surrender the whole question. But he failed to find even the faintest shadow or hint of the kind.
We also asked him the following questions, to which he answered as indicated:—
1. Does this text in Rev. 1:10 state that this is the first day of the week here referred to? Ans.—No.
2. Well, then, this text does not prove the first day to be the Lord’s day (Lordean day), does it? Ans.—No, sir.
3. Do the Scriptures anywhere else say the first day is the Lord’s day, or Lordean day? Ans.—No, sir.
4. Do the Scriptures anywhere say it is the Sabbath? Ans.—No, sir.
Here we reminded him that he had surrendered his whole proposition; for if this text did not say this was the first day referred to; did not prove the first day to be the Lord’s day, or Lordean day, and the Scriptures nowhere else declared it to be, his case was hopelessly gone.
5. Have we any record in the Bible where Christ ever commanded any one to keep it? Ans.—No. Paul says, “Where no law is, there is no transgression.” Rom. 4:15.
6. Have we any record where Christ ever claimed the day as his? Ans.—No, sir.
7. Can we find an instance where he ever blessed the day or sanctified it? Ans.—No.
8. Have we a text showing that he blessed any one for keeping it, or condemned them for not keeping it? Ans.—No.
9. Can we find a text where it is said to be holy or sacred? Ans.—No.
10. Have we a text in all the Bible where Christ is said ever to have mentioned the day in any way? Ans.—No.
11. Have we a single text where the disciples ever commanded any one to keep it? Ans.—No.
12. Is there a text given, showing where any one was ever told to keep it in honor of the resurrection? Ans.—No.
13. Do we read anywhere in the Bible that they were told to meet on that day to “break bread”? Ans.—No.
14. Have we any text to show that they ever met on but one first day to “break bread”? Ans.—No.
15. Have we any texts stating that they were to have any regular time, or stated day, for the “breaking of bread”? Ans.—No.
16. Have we any text stating that they ever met on but one first day for religious worship? Ans.—No.
17. Is not the Greek word “kuriakee,” derived from the Greek word “kurios”? Ans.—Yes.
18. Is not the Greek word “kurios” applied to both God and Christ, in the New Testament interchangeably? Ans.—Yes.
19. Does not the word “Lord,” “kurios,” from which the adjective Lord’s “kuriakee” (Rev. 1:10) is derived, refer in Rev. 1:8, to the Lord God Almighty? Ans.—Yes.
20. Do you claim that Sunday observance originated before the day of Pentecost? Ans.—No, sir.
Well, then according to your own admission, Sunday observance is an interloper, a counterfeit, a forgery, being at least fifty days too late to come in lawfully into the New Testament, or covenant. (See Gal. 3:15.) The New Testament was confirmed on the day of Christ’s crucifixion. Matt. 26:26. Everything belonging to it must be put in or made known before the death of the testator. Heb. 9:17, 18.
Here was a Gibraltar, which defied his every effort. According to his own position, Sunday-keeping was an innovation, a forgery, upon the last will and testament of our dear Lord and Saviour.
It will be seen from the above questions and answers that he had given his case completely away; from this he could not recover. He admitted on Acts 20:7, that it was only a night meeting, held on the night corresponding to our Saturday night, the Bible reckoning of time, from sunset to sunset, being used, and that Paul and his companions put in the light part of Sunday in traveling, Paul over twenty miles on foot and his companions over forty-five miles by water. This, the only instance to which he appealed to prove they observed Sunday, was shown to be observing it with a vengeance, the text and the admission both being fatal to any such idea.
Here he flew the track; forsook the Bible, and landed in the Catholic Church Fathers; but as we had a full supply of these on hand, we were prepared to follow him, and see that they should have justice. We proved that on points of doctrine, faith, or practice, their authority amounted simply to nothing, as Adam Clarke very truthfully says, “They blow hot, and they blow cold;” that there is not an abomination in the Catholic Church or mummery in her monkish traditions that cannot be abundantly proved from them as well.
The Lord gave us good freedom in defending the truth, and the brethren all express themselves as greatly strengthened. To the Lord be all the praise.
MATTHEW LARSON.