AdventAI

In the REVIEW of Sept. 1, in answering a question in regard to Easter, I notice that you speak as follows of Christmas: “An old pagan festival on the 25th of December was taken and made a festival of the birth of Christ, and called ‘Christmas.’” What is the authority for this statement?

E. B. T.

Ans.—Authority for the statement can be drawn from many sources; but an article on this subject in the Manifold Encyclopedia contains some statements perhaps as direct as any, which we copy as follows: “Christmas: the day on which the nativity of the Saviour is observed—assigned to Dec. 25. . . . It does not appear, however, that there was any uniformity in the period of observing the nativity among the early churches; some held the festival in May or April, others in January. There is no reason to suppose that Dec. 25 was the day of Christ’s nativity; indeed it is not evident that it could have been; for it is then the hight of the rainy season in Judea, when shepherds could hardly have been watching their flocks by night in the plains. . . . Not casually or arbitrarily was the festival of the nativity celebrated on Dec. 25. Among the causes that co-operated in fixing this period as the proper one, perhaps the most powerful was, that almost all the heathen nations regarded the winter-solstice which occurs at about this time, as a most important point of the year, as the beginning of the renewed life and activity of the powers of nature, and of the gods, who were originally merely the symbolical personifications of these powers. In more northerly countries this fact must have made itself peculiarly palpable—hence the Celts and Germans, from the oldest times, celebrated the season with the greatest festivities. At the winter-solstice the Germans held their great Yule feast, in commemoration of the return of the fiery sun-wheel, and believed that during the twelve nights from Dec. 25 to Jan. 6, they could trace the personal movements and interferences on earth ofp. 633 their great deities, Odin, Berchta, etc. Many of the beliefs and usages of the old Germans, and of the Romans, relating to this matter, passed over from heathenism into Christianity, and have partly survived to the present day. . . . The Presbyterian churches in Scotland, and large portions of the English dissenters, reject it [Christmas], in its religious aspect, as a ‘human invention,’ and as ‘savoring of papistical will-worship,’ although, in England, dissenters as well as churchmen use it as a social holiday, on which there is a cessation from all business.”

McClintock and Strong say, “The observance of Christmas is not of divine appointment, nor is it of New Testament origin.” Then endeavoring to account for its origin by saying that it was the taste of the age to multiply festivals, they add: “At the same time the heathen winter holidays (Saturnalia, Juvenalia, Brumalia) were undoubtedly transformed, and, so to speak, sanctified by the establishment of the Christmas cycle of holidays; and the heathen customs, so far as they were harmless (e. g., the giving of presents, lighting tapers, etc.), were brought over into Christian use.”