CONTRADICTORY DECISIONS OF THE CHURCH OF ROME

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 13, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 40.

Read the full edition

CONTRADICTORY DECISIONS OF THE CHURCH OF ROME.

The following question and answer from the St. Louis Globe Democrat of July 24, 1891, will show some of the contradictory decisions of the Church of Rome. Although the papal church boasts that its doctrine is a unit, that Rome never changes, it can be learned by reading its history, that there is much disagreement in doctrine. The boast that she never changes, is false, as it is a fact that she does change for the worse instead of the better; and the only reason why she does not persecute and run the Inquisition now as in the time of the papal supremacy, is that she lacks the power. If she would change for the better, she should hold another council, and repeal the doctrine of papal infallibility, which was proclaimed in the council of 1870.
Have the leading councils of the church always been harmonious in their decisions one with another?
The decisions of the councils have often been contradictory. For instance, the teaching of Athanasius was condemned by the councils of Arles, Tyre, and Milan, and approved by the councils of Nice and Sardica. The Council of Nice, which approved Athanasius, condemned Arius as a heretic, but three councils of Constantinople declared in favor of Arianism, and a council held at Sardica was so divided on the subject that each party excommunicated the other. The Council of Sardica, in 360, excluded the Apocrypha from the Canon, but in 397 the Council of Carthage declared it of equal authority with any other portion of Scripture. In 638 a council of Constantinople confirmed the doctrines of the Monothelites, but in 680 another council, also in Constantinople, declared it to be heresy, this decision being afterward condemned by four other councils. In 730 a council of Constantinople approved Iconoclasm, in 814 it was condemned, in 815 approved, and by four subsequent councils condemned. In 754 a Constantinople council condemned the worship of images; in 766 a Jerusalem council favored the practice; in 829 it was condemned; in 842 it was again approved. The above contradictory decisions are but samples of what may be ascertained by an examination of the acts of the councils.
W. PENNIMAN.