Massachusetts
Brockton.—Since my last report we have had some changes in our work here. Soon after my writing, the ministers throughout the city warned their people against us, and did everything possible to keep them away, even to having lawn parties. These warnings and the many things they said had great weight with the people, so that but few came out to the meetings, and we felt that our work would be almost a failure; but in the meantime several of the first-day Adventists became interested, and their minister became alarmed. He at once sent for one of their elders, a Mr. Sweet, who came, but with the intention of having a meeting just for the benefit of their own people. However, one of their own people came and told us about it the night before the meeting, and our meeting was dismissed, and the people advised to go and hear the other side of the question. It was quite a surprise to the Adventists to find us all present at the opening of their meeting. Mr. Sweet tried very hard to show his hearers that the Sabbath was done away at the cross, that it was a part of the old covenant, and a memorial of the deliverance of Israel from Egyptian bondage, etc., but to no effect only to those who desired to have it so; the greater part of the congregation said he had proved nothing. Elder Fifield reviewed the discourse the next evening. A few days later, Elders Phelps and Sweet came to our tent, and challenged Elder Fifield to debate the question with Elder Miles Grant, which challenge was accepted, and arrangements made, giving Elder Grant all the advantages of debate, putting Elder Fifield on the affirmative side of the question throughout the discussion.
The debate began Aug. 4, and continued four nights, two hours’ session each night, and twenty minutes’ speeches each. The report of the first one is given below in the Brockton Daily Enterprise of Aug. 5, under the heading, “The Seventh Day. Opening of the Gospel Tent Debate on the Christian Sabbath :”—
“The gospel tent that for some little time has been stationed on the old Carnival Park grounds, was the scene of an occasion of much interest last evening, and one of quite unusual occurrence. Long before the hour announced for opening, people began to flock into the tent, until at 8 o’clock almost the entire seating capacity had been taxed, quite a number standing during the entire evening. The occasion was a debate between Elders Miles Grant and G. E. Fifield, on the following question :—
“Resolved, That the seventh day is the Christian Sabbath, instituted at creation, unchanged by Christ and the apostles, and binding upon all men in all time.
“The debate opened quite promptly. Elder Fifield opening on the affirmative side of the question, which was conspicuously written on a large bulletin placed upon the platform, the negative being maintained by Elder Grant. The session lasted two hours, each debater being allowed three twenty-minutes’ speeches alternately during that time. Mr. John Barbour presided and held the watch. As it stopped at about 8:50, he had to guess at it after that hour, but both sides were given an even show, and no objection was raised. Quite a number of local clergymen were noticed in the audience.”
“On the affirmative side Elder Fifield showed by Bible testimony that, with reason and history having been agreed upon as authority, the seventh day was set apart as the Sabbath at creation. Set apart and created at that time, 2,500 years before the existence of the Jews, it could not be regarded as a Jewish institution. Neither, he averred, can it be regarded as ceremonial, because of its creation in Eden before there was a Saviour, and before there was a need of ordinances or ceremonials pointing to a Saviour. The day is Christian, he said, for Christ was the one who created, blessed, and sanctified it. He was in the world, and the world was made by him, and knew him not. The seventh day as the Sabbath was given to man and made for him, according to the words of Christ recorded in St. Mark. He maintained his position very firmly throughout the debate, and was not in the least routed by Elder Grant, who in an able manner contested that the laws and Sabbath were to and of the Jews, and died with them. He made the assertion that not one Sabbath had been observed since the year A. D. 70. Both gentlemen quoted the Scriptures profusely to back their arguments, and the result was an animated and highly interesting debate.”
“No conclusion was attempted, and the debate is to be continued similarly until Friday evening, when the contestants will have consumed their arguments and made an attempt to get together. Not to see how widely they differ, but to see how near they can come together, is the object of the debate. Rev. Mr. Phelps pronounced the benediction. This evening the debate will open at 8 o’clock sharp, or perhaps earlier.”
Elder Grant’s arguments were very much the same as those used in his discussion with Elder Cornell some years ago. In the second night’s debate, when he found that he had no argument by which to convince the people, he resorted to an ecstasy of joy, saying that if Sunday was the mark of the beast, he had it, and all others who did not keep the Sabbath had it; but, oh! it made him so happy. He said he knew all about it, he had studied the question for years; but, oh! it made him so happy. He was very confident that the Lord accepted him, which could not be if he was breaking the Sabbath. This seemed to take with some of the people, but when this was shown to be no argument, he resorted to slander and a misrepresentation of sister White’s writings, stating that she taught that the door of mercy was shut in 1844; but as the people knew nothing about her, and what he said had nothing to do with the question in hand, it lowered him in the estimation of the people. Below is a report of the discussion as given in the Brockton Daily Dispatch of Aug. 8:—
“While walking down Main Street the other evening, I came to a tent on Carnival Park. Wondering what sort of a meeting was going on, I went in. I should judge the place would seat about 400 people, and every seat was full. The assemblage was not the class I expected to find, either. It was an orderly, well-dressed, and decidedly respectable gathering. Some of Brockton’s most honored residents were listening to words from a Mr. Grant of Boston.
“He was trying to impress upon their minds that the Sabbath we observe is the Sabbath of the Lord, but to my mind his audience didn’t seem to accept his arguments as conclusive. He quoted the Bible and other authorities, but could make no headway. I was puzzled why the feeling existed, until he finished and Mr. Fifield took a hand in the argument. Then I felt as the rest did.
“The arguments of this gentleman were clear and forcible. He attacked the previous speaker with an overwhelming array of facts. Mr. Grant’s points were assailed and torn apart, piece by piece. Then he assumed the defensive, and argued that our Sunday is not the real Sunday, except as custom has made it recognized as such. Mr. Fifield is not on the popular side of the question, but a large majority of his hearers are with him. He believes he is on the right side, and is very courageous regarding his convictions.
“Mr. Grant is an able and well-known debater, but he has met his match in Rev. Mr. Fifield.”
We feel sure that the discussion resulted in a victory for the truth, as it brought out large congregations of people who heard the truth, thatp. 538 otherwise would not have known anything about it only what others told them, and perhaps that would have been false. We have many friends, and we hope that several will yet take hold of the truth. Our congregations are somewhat small, but we know that those who come are interested. We desire the prayers of all our people, that a goodly number may be saved as the result of our work here.
Aug. 11. H. J. FARMAN.