AdventAI

THANKSGIVING

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 46., November 24, 1891

The annual day of “thanksgiving and prayer” which will be this week observed in all parts of the land, is a familiar example of the force which springs from the sanction of custom. Originating at a time when special circumstances suggested the propriety of observing a day in this manner, the observance has continued, with governmental sanction, down to our own time, without reference to the existence or non-existence of special favoring circumstances,p. 729 and despite the fact that the recognized relation of the State to religious observances stamps with impropriety any governmental action of this kind.

Let it not, however, be understood that to the mere practice of thus celebrating a day in each year, apart from governmental proclamations to that end, we put forth any objection. That the Christian people of this land should recognize, at least once a year, the favoring hand of God in the inestimable blessings which have surrounded them, is no doubt eminently proper, but let the observance be spontaneous and unofficial, like that of Christmas day or the fourth of July. When the government, national or State, issues a Thanksgiving day proclamation, it stoops from its proper place to assume an attitude at once anomalous and bordering upon the ridiculous; for since governmental authority, when legitimately exercised, always means compulsion to the citizen so far as it concerns him, a governmental proclamation to which no force or compulsion pertains, becomes simply an impotent act, without either reason or excuse, and which all men, if they so choose, may laugh at and disregard with impunity. Such impotent utterances come with more propriety from the bull-fulminating power at the Vatican, than from the executive head of a great and powerful nation.

But aside from this, as concerning the observance itself, the fact may be noted that the present year has surrounded us with circumstances of exceptional favor. The truth becomes more apparent as we contemplate the situation elsewhere. In Russia, millions are dying of starvation, and the country is swept by the awful horrors of famine. In parts of India and China great destitution prevails. In Japan large districts have been defaced, and thousands of lives lost by terrible earthquakes. In South America the horrors of civil war are yet fresh upon the face of the land and in the hearts of sorrowing thousands. Unstability of government continually menaces the security of life and property. To all this add the ever-growing distress and perplexity in which all other great nations are involved, in the effort to maintain their enormous military equipments, and the contrast with our own land, with its abundant harvests and general peace and prosperity, becomes sufficiently apparent. We contemplate these facts from a distance, which robs the comparison of its essential force. Could we be bodily placed, for a short time, in some of these other lands upon which misfortune has descended so heavily, we would doubtless be prepared to observe the day with something like a due sense of the propriety of thanksgiving.

But having considered the subject theoretically, we are left to face it in its practical aspect, the principal fact of which is that so thoroughly impregnated is the custom with the spiritual degeneracy of the times, that it may be doubted whether the “exercises” of the day are not, on the whole, productive of more harm than good. L. A. S.