BY ELDER R. F. COTTRELL.
(Ridgeway, N. Y.)
The little tract on the Sabbath, by Rev. B. T. Roberts, I have carried in my pocket for years. Now and then I would take it out and read till sufficiently disgusted with its bold assertions, and then put it back. Sometimes I thought of reviewing some of its points, but since another has done so in REVIEW of Sept. 15, I am glad I did not; because he has done it in a more methodical and logical way than I should have done it.
Mr. Roberts asserts that our view of the seventh-day Sabbath has “neither reason nor scripture for its support.” From this it is logical to concludep. 724 that as he views it, the true Sabbath must be supported by both reason and scripture. Now let us try this upon his first-day Sabbath: 1. The fact of Christ’s resurrection alone furnishes no reason why the day on which he arose should ever after be the Sabbath; 2. The way that the day was spent by him and his disciples—the women hurrying to the sepulcher at early dawn, carrying the spices they had prepared; Peter and John running thither to see what had happened to give rise to what they esteemed an incredible report; the two disciples traveling to Emmaus and back, accompanied by Jesus on their outward journey—furnishes no reason why that day should ever after be a rest day.
And as for the Scriptures, they afford absolutely no evidence at all in favor of the first-day Sabbath. Therefore, weighed in the balances of reason and scripture, example and precept, the Sunday Sabbath is found to be utterly wanting.