The attention being attracted by the case of brother King becomes more remarkable every week. The papers in all sections of the country are commenting upon it, and very much is being done in this way to call attention to the truth by circulating a knowledge of our people and work. The Central Law Journal in its issue of Oct. 30, has the following editorial in regard to this case:—
“The opinion of United States Judge Hammond, in the case of In re [in the matter of] King, recently rendered at Memphis, involves a constitutional question of more than ordinary interest, the principal point involved being the interpretation of the phrase ‘due process of law,’ in the fourteenth amendment to the federal constitution. As is well known, this phrase, and the equivalent expression, ‘the law of the land,’ got into our constitutions owing to a popular misconception of their importance, but they have not been disregarded, although their interpretation has greatly perplexed the courts. The case decided by Judge Hammond was that of a Seventh-day Adventist who was found guilty of committing a nuisance at common law by plowing on Sunday. He sued out a writ of habeas corpus upon the ground that there was no law in Tennessee to justify his conviction, and that therefore he was deprived of his liberty without due process of law. In some very interesting obiter dicta [passing comments], Judge Hammond expresses the opinion that the prisoner was wrongfully convicted, reviewing Sunday legislation and the question of religious liberty at length; but he finds that the courts of the United States have no power to interfere in the matter. These courts, he says, are not tribunals that can review and reverse convictions in the State courts, ‘that may be illegal in the sense that they are founded on an erroneous judgment as to what the statute or the common law of the State may be. If so, every conviction in the State courts would be reversible in the federal courts where errors of law could be assigned.’ The principal ground, however, upon which Judge Hammond bases his decision is, that the judges of a State are the depositaries of the common law of the State, just as the statute book is the depository of the statute law; ‘and when they speak, the law is established and none can gainsay it.’ In this case, the verdict of the jury and the judgment of the court established by ‘due process of law’ two things: one, that to work on Sunday was a nuisance, according to the common law of Tennessee; the other, that the prisoner had worked on Sunday. The prisoner was therefore remanded, although Judge Hammond is entirely satisfied that there is no such common law as the Tennessee court declared. Without desiring to challenge the correctness of the opinion, which is exceedingly well considered, we are inclined to join with the New York Nation in the regret that Judge Hammond did not state just what rights are secured by the fourteenth amendment, if it does not protect a citizen against being punished for violating a law which has no existence.”
The Journal is a leading paper among lawyers, and is taken by many men of that profession, in various parts of the country. A class of readers is in this way made acquainted with our work, who would give it but little attention if it came to them from some other source. And while men are seeking to hinder the progress of the cause, we can see clearly how that they “can do nothing against the truth, but for the truth.”
In concluding an editorial on the same case, the Nation of New York, a literary and political journal of wide influence, says:—
“As the case will be taken to the Supreme Court by the Seventh-day Adventists, it is unnecessary to comment on it further at present, but the decision there will be awaited with much interest.”
By the consideration given to the decision in this case, our work is being kept before the public, and we hope so to relate ourselves to the question that much good may be the result.