ITALY AND THE POPE

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 1, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 47.

Read the full edition

ITALY AND THE POPE.

In the North American Review (New York) of November, 1891, ex-Prime Minister Crispi of Italy, thus discusses the question of Italy and the pope:—
Italy has the privilege of possessing in her capital city the head of the Catholic Church. This means, not that we have with us a minister of God, who exercises peacefully his spiritual power, but a pretender to the throne, who conspires against the unity and liberty of the country.
If the pope, after the fall of temporal power, had showed the Christian virtue of obedience to the laws of Providence, and resumed the functions of his sovereign pontificate under the conditions in which it existed in the first years of the institution, he would have been in the peninsula an element of order and love; but in his actual attitude he is the cause of suspicion and distrust, and regarded as an enemy to be guarded against, because at any moment he may disturb the public peace. It is desirable to inquire into the wisdom of the action of the Italian parliament in conceding special privileges to one of the religions of the State at the peril of its own existence.
On Oct. 2, 1870, the citizens of the Roman provinces voted by universal suffrage their annexation to Italy. With that plebiscitum, the nation completed politically its unity. The work of preparation was long and tempestuous; but the work of redemption was rapidly completed at last, since, in the course of twelve years, Italy was brought together and accomplished her unity. This work began in 1859. When Napoleon closed the war at Villafranca, he wished to establish a confederation of princes, but events were too strong for him. Emilia and Tuscany rose in arms, and the little dukes and the pontifical legates took flight. The echo of this popular triumph came from the dominions of the Bourbon king. Palermo rose in arms, and on the 5th of May, 1860, Garibaldi appeared in Sicily with his thousand men, fought, conquered, and within six months 9,000,000 Italians were freed from tyranny and united themselves to the nation. A people of 25,000,000 was gathered together, and on the 17th of March, 1861, the Italian parliament was enabled to proclaim the constitution of the kingdom of Italy. The powers recognized the new kingdom; the war of 1866, fought on both sides of the Alps, gave us Venice; and in 1870, the French troops—the only obstacle—being withdrawn, Rome came to Italy.
Before 1870, in a period of years which we may call our own, the temporal power of the popes has been thrice abolished: in 1798 by the people assembled at the capital after the entrance into Rome of the French troops under General Berthier; on the 17th of May, 1809, by a decree of Napoleon I; and on the 9th of Feb., 1849, by a law of the Roman Republic. The decrees of the 9th of Oct. 1870, and the law of Dec. 31, following, were not, therefore, an innovation. We can only praise the exceptional mildness of the Italian government and parliament shown in an act of such importance. The pope for twenty years has been living in the Vatican, surrounded by the cardinals, by the functionaries of the church, inviolable and inviolate, a constant and incorrigible conspirator.
Rome under the pope was a gangrene spot which must have poisoned the whole body of the nation. From 1860 onward it had become the asylum of all the fallen dynasties, a cave of brigands who infested the southern provinces of the peninsula. The redemption of the eternal city was not only a logical sequence of the restoration of Italian right; it was necessary to the pacification of the country.
The right of a people to exist in freedom and independence long antedates any reason of princes or any international treaty. Conquest, usurpation, the insidious good luck of a despot, may suspend the exercise of this right, but do not diminish it; much less can they extinguish it. Eternal, imprescriptible, within its natural limits, the nation resumes its own autonomy almost as soon as it has freed itself from the grasp of sacerdotal and civil tyranny.
The question of the temporal power of the pope has troubled for many years the minds of all Italian statesmen. It has been most difficult for us to deal with in consequence of the character of universality, which the head of the church possesses in virtue of his mission. Cavour, determining that the temporal power must end, through pacific means and by an agreement with the Catholic world, was the first in our time to undertake seriously the study of means to achieve this end. He died too soon to witness the failure of his policy. Garibaldi was prevented from cutting the Gordian knot; but without the cannon the Porta Pia would never have been opened to the nation to take possession of its capital.
As early as 1860 the great minister had attempted to open negotiations with the Holy See. Dr. Diomed Pantaleoni, whom he describes in a letter as the most faithful and most distinguished expression of the Liberal Moderate party, was his confident; and, later on, Passaglia, and Bertilli, general of the Rosminians, became associated with Dr. Pantaleoni. In the Holy College, Cardinals Santucci and d’Andrea were favorable to an understanding between the Holy See and Italy. The suppression of temporal power was to be made in a sort of feudal form. The pope, reserving eminent domain, was to cede in perpetuity to Victor Emmanuel and his successors the vicarate and civil government of the patrimony of St. Peter. The pope was to be guaranteed all the prerogatives of sovereignty, personal inviolability and immunity within his palaces; inviolability of the conclave and of the camerlengo during a vacancy of the Holy See; to have the right to send nuncios and to receive legates from foreign governments, and to enjoy in respect to them all, personal and territorial immunity; to receive for the maintenance of his court property sufficient to maintain the dignity of the Holy See. More were asked for, and would probably have been acceded to by Cavour, who was very liberal in his concessions to the Vatican. These were excessive, and we ought to thank God that they were not accepted.