AdventAI

THE SOUL VS. THE BODY.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 47., December 1, 1891

Probably no false doctrine of religious faith has been the source of greater evil to mankind than has the doctrine of the natural immortality of the soul. Harmless and even elevating as it may appear at first glance, it has prepared the mind for the reception of numerous other false doctrines, and has been one of the most direct avenues through which mankind's great enemy has exerted his baleful influence upon the race. The reader is probably familiar with the numerous and flourishing spiritual errors which have sprung up from this evil root. He may not, however, have noted the fact that a vast amount of the physical evil from which mankind has suffered, may be attributed to the same source.

It was during the progress of a recent lecture to which the writer was privileged to listen, that this fact was brought particularly to his notice. There is something about a belief in a distinct, conscious, immortal entity existing within the body, and which at death finds itself released from various restrictions incident to its connection with the body, which seems naturally to militate against the idea of bestowing upon the latter a great amount of care and attention. The natural effect of the doctrine is to disparage the body. Traces of this effect are exceedingly numerous in Christian theological literature and hymn-book lore, where the body is referred to as a burdensome tenement for the soul, a mere shell, a worthless clod to be gratefully cast aside by the immortal soul when the moment comes for it to soar away to the realms of eternal felicity. Even the flood of light which the nineteenth century has poured upon the close relation of the physical to the mental and moral parts of man's being, has not sufficed in many minds to invest the body with its due degree of importance. It can readily be imagined, then, that it was rated very much lower during the midnight of the Dark Ages.

Upon this point medieval history does not leave us in the slightest doubt. The ecclesiastical records of that long period furnish, indeed, curious and instructive reading for the modern student of physiology and hygiene. The church hugged closely the dogma of the immortal soul, and in proportion as this was held up and invested with importance in the popular mind by Romish theology, aided by the deep superstition of the times, respect for the body—the poor clay tenement of the soul—steadily dwindled away. The physical condition of mankind was about in keeping with their mental and moral state. Men were taught that by neglecting the body and inflicting upon it certain pains and penalties, they might accomplish much good for the soul. They had never heard the sentiment that “cleanliness is next to godliness.” With many, indeed, the contrary idea prevailed, and the opinion came to be held that the purest souls were to be found in the dirtiest and most neglected bodies. It was even sometimes enumerated among the virtues of some deceased “saint,” that for a certain period of months or years he had not combed his hair, or had abstained from some other common practice incident to cleanliness and a respectable appearance. It was nothing that the body should be worn out in penances, if the soul might thereby be purified. In short, the body and the soul were antagonized, and the former made wholly subservient to the interests of the superior, immortal entity within it. In all this uncivilized and unelevating state of things we can trace the influence and responsibility of this dogma of natural immortality.

It is hardly surprising, therefore, that in the present state of things, which is but an outgrowth of the former state, the doctrine that man has no such separate, conscious, immortal entity existing within him, should be received with disfavor, and undisguised hostility. Take that away, and there is left only the poor, mortal body of clay, which men have been so long taught to regard as the part of least importance in man's make-up—the cumbersome tenement of the spiritual part, the mere earthy shell in which the soul is incased during its sojourn upon the earth. The human mind will not willingly nor readily make this change in its conceptions. Some work must be done to aid it, and this the speaker suggested should be to teach the multitude that the body is really a most essential, important part of man's being, by instructing them in the principles essential to its proper care and preservation.

The word of God affords no sanction of the medieval conception of man's physical entity, or of modern conceptions of the body which have been the outgrowth of it. “What! know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you, which ye have of God, and ye are not your own? For ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God's.” The body, as well as the spirit, is to be used to the glory of God; it is the temple of God,—not a worthless clod to be cast aside with a sense of relief by the imprisoned spirit within it,—and as such it cannot properly be made the object of our contempt or neglect. We are bound, on the contrary, to preserve this temple with the utmost care. The satanic hand is plainly apparent in every theory or scheme opposed to this; for the arch-enemy of mankind well knows the utility of man's physical nature as a means through which he canp. 745 reach and influence his moral faculties. The body and the spirit stand together in sanctification or in dishonor. To neglect and injure his physical nature, is to bring injury into the spheres of his mental and moral usefulness. None of these three parts of his being is unessential, or antagonistic to the others. The true Christian is he who bestows upon each and all their proper degree of attention. The purest soul, other things being equal, is to be found in the purest body, the best cared-for and best fitted as a human temple for the residence of the Holy Spirit.

L. A. S.