AdventAI

HAS IT COME TO THIS?

By A. F. Ballenger

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 49., December 15, 1891

MUST the editors of great secular dailies, who are classed by theologians as “publicans and sinners,” come to the rescue of the integrity of the Holy Scriptures as against the assaults of the leading divines of the country? This is the situation as it appears from the following editorial in the Chicago Evening Journal of Nov. 16:—

Dr. Strong has just written an elaborate assault on the inerrancy of the Bible, and it has been published approvingly by the Examiner of New York and the Standard of Chicago.

All the same, however, Dr. Strong’s theory concerning the alleged errors in the Bible is singularly shallow and confused. He says:—

“The anxiety of many Christians to maintain the historical and scientific inerrancy of the Scriptures is mainly the result of their fear that the possibility of mistake in such minor matters may carry with it the possibility of mistake in the greater matters of faith and doctrine. But the fallibility of the record in one case does not involve its fallibility in the other. What we need in the Scripture is an absolute authority in matters pertaining to salvation. In its chosen sphere it is infallible; and its chosen sphere is the revelation of moral and religious truth.”

No one but a theologian would ever ask people to believe a witness on one subject who was unreliable on every other. But aside from this weakness, Dr. Strong’s statement labors under this insuperable difficulty, that the entire system of Christian theology is based on history, and is attacked by unbelievers on scientific grounds. Not to go outside of the doctrine of Christ, it is sufficient to say that Christ’s lineage, the portents that accredited him, his miraculous birth, his sinlessness, his crucifixion, his resurrection, and his ascension, are all matters of history and science. Therefore, when Dr. Strong admits that the history and science of the Bible are fallible, he admits that its “moral and religious truth,” “its faith and doctrine,” and its “matters that pertain to salvation,” are fallible also. To a layman, at least, this appears very plain.

It is possible that by the history and science of the Bible, Dr. Strong may mean those passages which are historical and scientific without any admixture of religious teaching; and if so, it becomes a matter of the greatest importance to determine which passages are of this character. Do they include such matters as the creation of the world, the campaigns and miracles of Moses and Joshua, the adventures of Jonah, Samson, and Daniel, and the travels of Christ and the apostles, and all similar passages? If so, nine tenths of the Bible is uninspired. Moreover, if no one can separate the fallible from the infallible passages, they might as well all be fallible; and if they can be separated, the first duty of Dr. Harper and Dr. Strong to the denomination is to publish an edition of the Bible in which the fallible portions are clearly marked for the use of plain people.

Of course this doctrine of the fallibility of some portions of the Bible contradicts all existing Baptist symbols. Of the two leading creeds in use by the Baptist churches of Chicago, one begins with the words: “All scripture is given by inspiration,” and the other declares that the Bible has “truth without any admixture of error for its matter.” That the denomination should so suddenly change from on such an important matter is a singular tribute to the learning of Dr. Harper, backed, however, by the wealth of Mr. Rockefeller.

A. F. BALLENGER.