AdventAI

“HAD A BATTLE ROYAL.”

By W. A. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 43., November 3, 1891

The subject of the closing of the World’s Fair appears to be attracting constantly increasing attention. The following is a reporter’s introduction to an account of a discussion of the question before the Sunset Club, in Chicago recently, as given in the Chicago Herald of Oct. 23, 1891:—

“From the day the Sunset Club started, it never had such a jolly meeting as that which filled one of the big dining-rooms at the Grand Pacific Hotel, with screaming shot and bursting shell of argument last night. It was the opening meeting of the fourth year of the famous organization, and the cause of war was this innocent question, ‘Shall the World’s Fair be closed on Sunday?’” The beginning of hostilities found the staunch Presbyterian doctor, Rev. Herrick Johnson, firmly intrenched behind the battlements of Sunday closing, with Judge McConnell before the wall, ready to apply the match to a long and particularly wicked-looking cannon. The shot was fired, and presently from the smoke the white head of the Doctor emerged as defiant as ever. Then from this tower issued a shower of large and small shot that tore up the brush, and kept his besiegers for a while hopping about nimbly and dodging behind stumps and hay-stacks. But when they were rallied, they poured in a fire of all sorts of missiles. Everything known to warfare, from chain shot to Hotchkiss shells, was hurled at the man in the fortress, and presently re-enforcements had to be rushed in. Between them and the besieging party, the fight was a smashing one, and it continued till both sides were ready to suspend hostilities and sleep on their arms.

“As any one can imagine, the debate was a mighty hot one. It was pursued by some of the debaters with reckless disregard of whose head might be hit, and it reached as near actual personalities as any after-dinner debate could reach.”

Judge McCormick touched the real point at issue, when in the course of his remarks, he said:—

“Is it not the old fight waged so long in the world—the fight to make one set of men think, or at least do, as another set of men think they ought to think or do? Is there any room in the world for a question of that sort? Have we not grown so much, that it seems strange that such a question should even be debatable? Is not the controversy mainly a religious one, and might we not as well be discussing whether some of us should be made to go to some particular church, as to be discussing whether some of us should be prevented from doing on Sunday something that others think we ought not to do? It is surely a religious question, and I think that we are through for awhile with coercive measures in making conversions to our religious beliefs, or even enforcing observance of matters which are part of our religious beliefs.”

Rev. Herrick Johnson, in his remarks, very clearly revealed the fact that this demand for Sunday closing is made with a distinctive end in view, making use of that argument which is resorted to when all others fail—the plea for custom and tradition. He said:—

“This is a Christian nation. We do not, like the materialist, worship a blind, impersonal force, nor, like the theosophic Spencerians, bow before the ‘transcendental unknowable.’ We are Christians, recognizing and invoking the God of the Scriptures. Christianity exists in our national usages and laws. We open our legislatures with prayer, and appoint chaplains for our army and navy. What a shock it would be to the nation, what a twist out of our historic life, if any other god than the God of the Bible and the Sabbath, were to be appealed to: The opening of the World’s Fair on Sunday would be going counter to the best memories and traditions and usages of our national life.”

Upon the plea for custom and tradition, Mr. Thomas Morgan, another speaker, said: “The road to progress is strewn with broken precedents and tradition.” And a Mr. Darrows gave a center shot to the whole business, when, in a vein of sarcasm, he said: “The system of protection is at the base of the whole argument. Wool and hens’ eggs are protected. Why not protect the saloon and the church! Why keep open the Fair and draw from these infant industries!” This is the secret of the whole matter. The system of protection is at the bottom of the whole clamor for closing. And it is not the people that the clamorers want protected either, but the churches and the Sunday. But on the whole this meeting seemed to be quite a disappointing affair to those who are seeking for a national precedent for religious legislation.

W. A. C.