AdventAI

Civil Government and Moral Accountability.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 2., January 12, 1892

The familiar saying that “a little knowledge is a dangerous thing,” is nowhere better illustrated at the present time than in the demand for governmental interference to protect and enforce the observance of a weekly day of rest. The majority of religious people in this country have just enough knowledge on this subject to know that Sabbath-breaking is a sin, that disregard for any Sabbath has become alarmingly prevalent, that it is an indication of moral degeneracy, and that it is for the good of all men that they pay heed to the command,p. 25 “Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy,” and having no true conception of the bearing of these facts upon the propriety of a legalized Sabbath, this knowledge is a dangerous weapon for evil in the hands of those who are fired and blinded by fanatical zeal.

To this class belongs a writer in a recent issue of the Episcopal Recorder, who signs himself “N. W.,” and concludes his article by saying, “Why not rise en masse?” This question he addresses to the Christian people of this country, on the subject of their duty in view of the prospective running of the Chicago World’s Fair on Sunday. In the spirit of many others who have essayed to speak upon this subject, he exclaims, “Shall $20,000,000 be expended under State and national auspices in the propagation of materialism and antichristianity, or shall America teach the nations of the earth that this nation, at least, is resolved to maintain the ‘sign’ between God and themselves, if it has to wreck a thousand expositions in doing so?” It is the spirit which prompts one portion of our citizens to say, “We are the people, and what we say must be done,” regardless of the existence of other citizens who, in the matter of rights and the privilege of dictating to the government, stand on an equality with themselves. Nor is it by any means the larger portion of the community which assumes to do this. Viewed from a numerical standpoint, the attempt of church-members to run the Government in the matter of Sunday rest, appears as an effort of the tail to wag the body. Yet under the influence of great zeal combined with a little knowledge, they become blind alike to justice and the American principle of government that the majority must rule. And they will not, as this writer says, hesitate to “wreck a thousand expositions” if their demands cannot otherwise be carried out.

The chief foundation upon which the demands of this class are based, is the assumption that governments, like individuals, are morally accountable before God. This assumption, as Lord Macaulay has so conclusively shown in his famous critique upon Gladstone’s early views of the relation of Church and State, is pure fiction; yet the idea is so deeply rooted in the minds of many, especially where it can find some intolerance and bigotry to grow upon, that its truth is by many people taken for granted, when a very small amount of logical thought upon the subject would convince any candid one among them to the contrary. The moral accountability of a nation pertains to the citizens composing it, as individuals, and not to the nation as a government.

The United States as a government, is represented solely by the officers of the three departments which compose it, and any act of these officers, done in their official capacity, is a national act. This is the only way in which a government can act. Now suppose that all the people of the United States were, as they should be, God-fearing Christians, including those who fill the offices of government. Every one would then act in harmony with the divine will, according to the light which he had, and this nation would be truly, what some people now falsely claim it to be, a Christian nation. There would then be no clamor and agitation for a national Sabbath law; for all would be keeping the Sabbath strictly. There would be no occasion whatever for any governmental action to compel the people to do what each one was, of his own free will, already doing; and consequently there would be no legislation necessary in the interests of religion, no occasion for the Government to concern itself in any way in religious matters. We should thus have a nation which would be both Christian and non-Christian, according as the word had reference to the people of the nation, or to the Government. On the theory that a nation, in its governmental capacity, is like an individual morally accountable to God, we should have a nation of Christian people represented by a godless Government (since it took no account of religion), and therefore at the final separation of the righteous from the wicked, supposing the same conditions to exist, all the people of the nation would be saved in the kingdom of God, and the Government cast into hell fire!

We can hardly see how this could be done, unless by consigning to the flames of that place the national Constitution and the various documents which constitute the public records of our governmental acts.

On the other hand, let it be supposed that none of the people of this country were true, God-fearing Christians,—not even the politicians who are chosen to public office,—though there might be many among them who would pretend to be Christians because it was a popular thing to do, just as there will be when Christianity, or a profession of it, is made a qualification for public office. Let it be supposed that the Government, through its hypocritical officers, carefully complied to the best of its knowledge with the divine will, as an individual Christian would do. We should then have, on the theory under consideration, a Christian Government run by non-Christian people. These therefore at the final judgment would be cast into hell, while the Government, being Christian, upon the hypothesis of its being a moral person, would be translated to heaven!

In the light of this remarkable theory, we may also draw from the foregoing two remarkable conclusions:—

1. The more Christians you have in a nation, the more un-Christian will be its government (since it will have less to do with matters of religion)!

2. Conversely, the fewer Christians there are in a nation, the more intensely Christian will be its government (since it will have to pass many laws and give much attention to matters of religion, to keep the Christianity of the country from being lost)!

And therefore, let those who are working to make this a Christian Government, or nation, immediately set to work to un-Christianize its people, as the quickest means of accomplishing their object.

A theory which leads to such absurdities, ought not to engage the serious attention of an enlightened people, and would not if they would but take the trouble candidly to test its correctness by a few simple steps of reasoning. It ought to be apparent, on a moment’s thought, to any sensible mind, that there can be no such thing as a nation’s accountability to God, separate and apart from that of the individuals composing it; and that when individual accountability has been taken out of the question of a nation’s relation to God, there is no other accountability left. In other words, the moral accountability of a nation is wholly included in the accountability of its individual constituents, and when these have performed their duty to God as individuals, there is nothing left to be performed toward God by the Government. God deals with this world only as individuals. The world is made up of individual intelligences, individual souls. There is a divine law to which each one of these is amenable, and with reference to which one cannot act for another. The obedience of one soul is not accepted for that of another, nor is the transgression of one imputed to another. No one can stand before God on the merits of any other, save that other is the Lord Jesus Christ. There is no such thing as a national soul, no such thing as governmental allegiance to God, or governmental salvation in the kingdom of God. In civil matters the people act through the officers of the government, but in this there is no such thing as vicarious obedience to God’s law, through any human agency, no such thing as vicarious accountability, or vicarious salvation. Religion is wholly a matter between God and the individual conscience.

It is, therefore, wholly out of place to call upon the Government to take action toward closing the World’s Fair on Sunday, or to call upon the Christian people of the country to “rise en masse” and either close the doors of the Exposition on Sunday, or “wreck” it. Neither this Government nor any other has any right to meddle in religious matters. Its province is altogether separate from religion. Men’s rights are protected by civil government, but they are converted only by the Spirit of God through the gospel. Therefore if Sabbath-breaking is on the increase, if moral degeneracy is becoming fearfully prevalent, if “evil men and seducers” are waxing worse and worse, as is no doubt the case, they must be reached and made better by the gospel, and not by the arm of the law. The gospel is God’s only remedy for sin.

We do not wish to be understood as saying that the World’s Fair at Chicago ought to remain open on Sunday. There may be good reasons why it should not be open; but it is not the business of the Government or of any legislating body to close it, or of the people to rise en masse and close it. The decision of the question of Sunday opening or closing rests, apparently, with the local commission. We hope this commission is composed of Christian men,—men who possess a conscience and are guided by the same in the walks of their public and private life. Let them decide the question, if it be theirs to decide, as they see fit.

L. A. S.