Catholic Church in France Shifts Stance Toward Republic

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 19, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 3.

Read the full edition

Catholic Church in France Shifts Stance Toward Republic

The changed attitude of the Catholic Church in France toward the government, is so remarkable and is attracting so much attention that the Catholic Church organs find the duty is imperative to explain this new change of church policy.
It is a well-known fact that ever since the present republic in France was proclaimed, its most constant and implacable foe has been the clerical party. As the Catholic Church is a mighty force in France, and all this force has been used to antagonize the government, statesmen have had grave doubts of the stability of the republic. That it exists at the present time is nothing to the credit of the “Church.”
The republic was proclaimed under the influence of the revulsion of feeling against Louis Napoleon for his hasty and unsuccessful war against Germany. This was the high tide upon which the new ship of state was first launched. But the shrewd prelates of Rome well knew that the monarchical idea was deeply rooted in the minds of the French people, and they thought that without their support the republic would soon go down.
The action of the government in licensing public schools and suppressing religious orders, had also greatly incensed them, and so they threw the whole combined force of the Church against the government. While a body of liberal-minded men, with a following chiefly drawn from the large cities, which are the centers of intellectual life in France, and which have a greater influence to control public affairs than do cities in this country, have struggled to sustain the republic, a large party composed principally of the ignorant peasantry, with the priests to lead them, have constantly endeavored to hamper the republic and to overturn it if possible.
As a Catholic writer in a late number of the Mirror, says:—
An overwhelming majority of the priesthood refused to rally to the republic. The pulpits rang with denunciations of Republicanism; and in the legislative elections the entire weight of the Ecclesiastical party was thrown into the scales on behalf of the monarchical candidates.
Now, however, that some of the pretenders to the throne of France have died, and others manifested that they are unfit for any public place whatever, and the republic, avoiding the rocks upon which its predecessors in France went down, has become a settled government, so strong that the church cannot hope to overthrow it, the church has become alarmed lest in the coming days she may be left out in the cold, gain no public offices, and entirely lose her power in State affairs, and therefore she has suddenly changed front, and is, or professes to be, very loyal!
The church has held to the old exploded idea of the “divine right of kings,” or as the Mirror very mildly puts it:—
It had somehow or another become a tradition [in France] that the throne was synonymous with the altar, and that kingship and the Catholic Church were inseparably bound up in each other.
To shift the responsibility for this blind attachment to kings, fostered by the priests who received their cue from the bishop, who got his directions from Rome, upon an indefinite “somehow or another,” is highly amusing, to say the least.
The position of the clerical party in France upon the “divine right of kings” was based upon the partnership business which has always characterized the Roman Church. If the king would maintain by law the ecclesiastical power of the pope and the church, the church would proclaim in her pulpits the divine right of the king. Reduced to a quaint Yankee saying, the bargain between the church and the king was this: “You scratch my back, and I will scratch yours.”
But while the Catholic Church has strenuously maintained the divine right of kings to live in luxury and idleness; while the poor peasantry often suffered the untold horrors of want in every form, this proud, money-and-ease-loving church never thought of the “divine rights of the people.” And when the people of France, maddened by the burden of taxation and war which wasted their blood and treasure, and which was thrust upon them by a representative of this effete system of government, rose in their might, and like the Americans in their struggle for liberty, proclaimed that “resistance to tyrants is obedience to God,” the whole Catholic clergy of France rose en masse and protested against it. It was this disloyalty to the republic which caused the confiscation of the church property in France.
But a great change has come over the church, not of conviction, but of policy. They have come to the conclusion that the republic has come to stay, and this is the cause of the sudden church somersault which the Catholic party in France is just now turning. The neat way in which this was done by Cardinal Lavigerie, who took the initiative of this new movement in France, is very naively told by the Mirror, as follows:—
His Eminence saw at a glance that France was resolved to remain Republican, and that it would be easier to induce the French people to adopt the customs and habits of their forefathers, the Gauls, than it would be to tempt them to return to any monarchical form of government.
What his Eminence would have done for a turn-table, had he not made the discovery that their “forefathers, the Gauls,” had a republic to which they had a right to return if they wished, we cannot tell, but no doubt his ingenuity would in some way have been equal to the occasion.
Nothing but time can determine what the result of this new departure of the church party in France will be. Of two things we may be certain: (1) Those who have maintained the republic against the influences of the church party, will not be liable to welcome them now and give into their hands the public offices which they have thus far held in spite of them; (2) The church party will never be satisfied until they have gained the control of the government. Or to state it in another way, that power which is represented in the Scriptures (Rev. 17: 3) as a woman seated upon a scarlet colored beast, will never be satisfied simply to walk along in company with the beast, but will watch her opportunity to take her former position in the saddle.
For this reason it may be that the government in France is in more danger from the new attitude of the church than they were from the old.
M. E. K.