133.—INTERPOLATION IN 1 JOHN 5:7.
Respecting an answer in the Question Chair, in the REVIEW of Nov. 10, 1891, that the reference to the word “Spirit,” in 1 John 5:7, is an interpolation, a correspondent, E. K., writes: “Please tell me in what way and by whom 1 John 5:7 was found out to be an ‘interpolation.’ I have thought the Seventh-day Adventists were very emphatic in teaching that we must ‘believe every word of the Bible from the first word of the first chapter of Genesis to the last word of the last chapter of Revelation.’ Now how is it? When I am reading the Bible, how am I to know when I am reading the truly inspired word, and when I am reading interpolations? And what am I to say to those who insist that it is all the work of men? If I begin to throw out, how am I to know where to quit?”
Answer.—That depends on the ground on which one is disposed to discard or change a word of Scripture. If we start in to throw out texts at our own will, on our own authority, prompted to the act by our own feelings, because we do not like the text, or think it could be bettered, or for any reason of that kind, then we would not know where to stop; for thus placing our authority above the Bible, that book would be reduced to a nullity. But the criticism referred to does not rest on any such ground. The testimony on this point is well presented by Dr. A. Clarke in his comments on this passage. He says:—
“But while accepting the doctrine here implied, it must still be conceded that, beyond all question this verse is not genuine. To make the whole more clear, and that every reader may see what has been added, I shall set down these verses with the inserted words in brackets. ‘6. And it is the Spirit that beareth witness because the Spirit is truth. For there are three that bear record [in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost, and these three are one. 8. And there are three that bear witness in earth], the Spirit and the water and the blood, and these three agree in one.’ Any man may see on examining the words, that if those included in brackets, which are wanting in the manuscripts and Versions, be omitted, there is no want of connection; and as to the sense, it is complete and perfect without them; and indeed much more so than with them.”
In an “Additional Note,” at the close of the chapter (1 John 5) in Clarke’s Commentary, further reasons for rejecting the words inclosed above in brackets, are given, from which we quote the following:—
“The question respecting the genuineness of the passage concerning the ‘three heavenly witnesses’ (1 John 5:7) is no longer an open one, there being nothing of any real value to plead in its favor. It is not found in any Greek manuscript written before the invention of printing, with a single unimportant exception. It is not found in any of the older Versions except the Vulgate, and even the older copies of that (before the eighth century) do not contain it; and it is never quoted or referred to by the Greek Fathers, and not certainly by any of the Latins. During the celebrated Arian controversy, which engaged all the learning of its age, and was extended over a long period of time, no writer refers to it, as would certainly have been the case had it been in existence.”
“As a question of criticism, this subject is briefly disposed of by Huther in terms that will receive the assent of all who will examine the evidence in the case: ‘The weight of the evidence against the genuineness of the disputed words is so strong that it is opposed to the fundamental principles of a sound and unprejudiced criticism to regard them as genuine.’”
The way in which the words, under these circumstances, have crept into the common version of our English Bible, is stated as follows:—
“The words, as a part of the text, began to appear in the Latin MSS. (of the Vulgate) in the eighth or ninth century. In the sixteenth century they were found in most copies of the Vulgate, and of course they appear in the translations made from that Version. It is first found in Greek in the famous Complutensian Polyglot, prepared under the auspices of Cardinal Ximenes (A. D. 1504–1514). The Greek MSS. used in constructing this work were of recent date and of but little authority, and the compilers in not a few cases, corrected the Greek text from the Vulgate, and by that means the text in question was carried over from the Latin of the Vulgate to the Greek of the Polyglot. Erasmus in his earlier editions rejectedp. 89 them, and so also did Aldus Manutius in the Venetian edition of 1522. . . . Luther never admitted the words to any of his translations; but they appear in the German Bible printed in Zurich in 1529, mutilated in part and in small print. . . . The text came into our English Bibles from the Vulgate, which was the authority almost explicitly followed by the earliest translators; and their Versions have been followed in all other generally accepted Versions, though the best English scholars of the century have been agreed in rejecting them, as not sustained by any competent authority.”
On such evidence as this but one conclusion can be formed; namely, that the words in question were inserted into copies of the Vulgate (a Latin translation of the Scriptures prepared by Jerome about the close of the fourth century), the earlier copies of which did not contain them, by some ignorant or interested party this side the eighth century, and should consequently be discarded. But this throws no doubt or uncertainty over any other parts of the Scriptures. Indeed it assures us of their genuineness; for the same rigid scrutiny and close criticism which have resulted in discovering this interpolation, have been brought to bear upon all the Scriptures, and no such evidence of interpolation appears with reference to any other text; therefore we are safe in accepting them as genuine. To the question then where we shall stop if we throw out the words indicated in 1 John 5:7, the answer is, Stop where the facts stop; stop where the evidence and criticism stop; and they stop with that text; and if any such facts exist with reference to any other text, with all the centuries of research that has been bestowed upon the subject, the discovery of ancient manuscripts, and the comparison of the different Versions, they would surely have been detected; but they are not found. And thus we can rest down upon the Scriptures, not as the word of men, but as they are in truth the living word of the Lord.