BY order of the Executive Committee of the National Religious Liberty Association, I attended the Illinois Sabbath Union convention at Springfield, Ill., Dec. 28, 29, 1891. It is the oldest organization of its kind, being organized at Elgin in 1888, one year before the American Sabbath Union was organized. There were about five persons present from points outside the city, and from twenty to seventy from the city. Most of the city ministers were present at the first session, but few at the last. Among the questions discussed were, “Sunday Newspapers,” “Domestic Sabbath-keeping,” “Railroad and Street-car Travel,” and “Sunday Closing for the Columbian Exposition.” One noticeable difference between this and other conventions was the time and importance given to an attempt to persuade the ministers present to keep Sunday properly and to enlist them in doing missionary work in the same line for their respective congregations. It was repeatedly stated that the laxness with which Sunday was observed was due to the unfaithfulness of Christians themselves. So much was there said on this point, that Mr. McLean (Chicago Secretary of the American Sabbath Union, and Secretary of the Columbian Sunday Association, whose voice has been heard in Chicago every Sunday night for the last six months, denouncing in severest terms, street-car corporations for “enslaving” their employees by exacting Sunday labor) finally became convicted, and confessed that he had been “riding to his appointments on the street-cars, and did not see how he could do otherwise.”
Following this there was a “coldness came over the meeting,” and it was evident from the profound silence of some, and the defending of Mr. McLean’s course by others, that President Blanchard was the only one present who was not guilty on this point. It appeared ridiculous, to say the least, to hear these same men later on, pleading for civil law to stop all Sunday work, including the running of railroad trains and street-cars, asking the State to compel them to do what their consciences were not quick enough to do for themselves, nor their preaching powerful enough to do for their church-members.
Another noticeable feature of the convention, which contrasts it with others, was its willingness to hear a representative of the opposition. When the writer arose and frankly stated that he represented the opposition to their movement, he was cordially invited to take the platform, and was listened to with respectful attention. In answer to a statement that the opposition were “over anxious regarding the preservation of their liberties,” the writer narrated the persecutions of Seventh-day Adventists in Arkansas, Tennessee, and other States, and charged that these persecutions had not received a word of condemnation from any American Sabbath Union representative. It is needless to add that the statement went unchallenged. He asked if this people were without a cause for apprehension when such persecutions were openly defended or tacitly indorsed. He referred to letters received from one of the leading “Sabbath Union” representatives (and he sat within reach of the speaker at the time) which declared in substance, with cold, cruel indifference, “Tennessee has a Sunday law, and King has violated that law.”
Attention was next called to the repeated statements made in the convention, that the responsibility for the present laxity in Sunday observance lay at the door of the church, whose members not only ignored Sunday observance by Sunday travel, but held stock in these Sunday-breaking corporations? They were asked why they did not quicken the consciences of their people instead of asking the State to compel the members of their churches to do something which they were unable to do by the power of preaching. It was stated, in answer to the plea that laboring men were compelled to work on Sunday or starve, that there were forty thousand Seventh-day Adventists, many of whom had given up their positions rather than disobey the dictates of conscience, and that not only did none of them starve, but that they had sufficient means to support their families, their church, and not a little to oppose the Sabbath Union movement. When the speaker finished, President Blanchard asked the following questions, which were responded to by the answers that follow:—
“Do you think that the working man has a right to one day in seven to rest?
“I do.
“Do you believe it is a sin for a man to work seven days in the week?
“I do.
“Are you not then in favor of a law which will compel the employer to give to his employee one day’s rest in seven?
“I am not. Educate the conscience of the employee, and he will find no difficulty in securing his rest.”
President Blanchard replied that “we must part company here. The individual is so weak (referring probably to some ministers present), and the corporations are so strong that a law is necessary to help the individual.”
This was the only attempt to answer any point made.
Rev. Cobb of the Christian Church, next took the platform, and among other things said:—
“I told brother Blanchard when he asked me to participate in this meeting, that if he based his movement on the fourth commandment, he would get into trouble; for that would involve the question of Church and State union.”
President Blanchard attempted to convince him that it did not, and a lively discussion followed, in which the President was worsted. The next speaker on the program was called, but he replied: “The longer we talk, the more befogged we get,” and the meeting was dismissed.
An Inter Ocean reporter, favorable to the work of the convention, but ignorant of the vital point at issue between President Blanchard and the Association representative, as appears from the questions and answers given, telegraphed his paper that “he, (the Association representative) was hardly ‘onto his job,’ and when cross-questioned by Prof. Blanchard, it transpired that the only difference was that the Sabbath Union believes in legislation that will prevent an employer from forcing employees to work on Sunday, and Mr. Ballenger does not.” The Chicago Evening Journal saw the point at issue even in the published report, and referring to it editorially the next day, said:—
“That Sunday should be observed as a day of rest, as far as possible, most intelligent people will agree, but coercive Sunday rest is a lost cause. Six days are enough for any man to work, but the State is not the paternal guardian of the judgment or the conscience of the citizen. Let the church prevent Sabbath-breaking by all the sanctions it can command, but if through any narrow policy it has lost its ascendancy over large bodies of men, let it not on that account appeal to the State to take upp. 43 the work which it fails to accomplish. No man is compelled to enter service of an employer who exacts Sunday labor.”
It is but fair to commend the cordiality with which we were welcomed to the platform of the convention, and the freedom granted us in presenting the opposition, and it is needless to say that we expressed our appreciation of the kindly treatment received, and parted as friends.
A. F. BALLENGER.