THE following editorial in the Atlanta Constitution of Jan. 4, on the subject of men and books, is worthy of consideration:—
Some time ago a western newspaper instructed its Washington correspondent to put a number of questions to certain congressmen, and report their off-hand answers. Some of the replies apparently indicated an astonishing degree of ignorance and misinformation, and the enterprising newspaper made a list with its special article on the subject.
The matter was thought worthy of editorial comment by the New York World, and some of its points deserve to be summarized.
A memory loaded with facts and figures does not necessarily make its possessor intellectually bright and capable. Some men might as well have their information looked up in their libraries. They have it in their heads in a congested muddle. They memorize a mass of details, and draw from them no general rules or principles. Most men with heads for statistics have heads for nothing else. On the other hand, many of the most successful workers in intellectual fields are singularly indifferent to details, but their general grasp of the matters likely to engage their attention is so comprehensive that they know just where to find the precise information needed when the occasion arises. It has long been a common saying that the best lawyer is not the one who knows the law, but the one who knows where to find the law. So it is with our statesmen. The ablest men among them, from a practical point of view, are not the book-worms ready with an answer for every text-book question, but the keen-witted, quick men of affairs who know exactly where to look for the facts and figures relating to the business that comes before them.
This view is, of course, equivalent to saying that our civil service examinations do not amount to a row of pins. Such is the fact, and there is no use in concealing it. Many a young man who is unable to give the hight of the pyramids, and who does not remember the year of Jacob Cade’s death, would make a better government clerk than a spectacled student who answered every question in a civil service examination.
The fact is, the occupations requiring intellect and knowledge are best served when their workers know how to use books, as skillful workmen know how to select and use their tools. But when men give themselves up to book worship, and are dominated by it, they fall into the ruts of culture, or become walking cyclopedias, or anything else except wide-awake fellows with the ability to adapt themselves to the varying conditions of every-day life and progress.
In this rushing age the successful man must be something more than a book on two sticks. He must be the master, and not the slave of his book.
A. O. T.