AdventAI

IS IT LIGHT?

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 5., February 2, 1892

WE are in receipt of a copy of the Baptist Sentinel, published in Dayton, Wash., in which is an article entitled, “More Light Given.” The light is upon the subject of the Sabbath.

By request of a brother in that vicinity, we will notice a few points. As nearly all the ideas in this article are such as our people have heard over and over again, we think it would be unprofitable to mention them all.

The author quotes Rom. 13: 8, 9, and says:—

“Now, Paul was intending to go to Rome to plant the gospel standard there. And, by the way, he sent a letter of advice before him, containing much Scripture knowledge, and in his letter of advice he virtually excludes the fourth commandment, by giving that part of the law that would be binding on them as Christians, and then saying, if there be any other commandment, it is this: Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself.”

According to this, the fact that Paul did not mention the Sabbath in the list of Christian duties laid down in Rom. 13: 8, 9, “virtually excludes the fourth commandment.” Upon what ground does he exclude it?—On the ground that it is not mentioned. Not mentioning, then, is purposely “excluding.” Let us now see what this will exclude.

There is a command which says, “Thou shalt have no other gods before me.” This is the first commandment of that code in which the Sabbath commandment is the fourth. Is it mentioned in Rom. 13: 8, 9 among the duties Paul declares to be obligatory upon Christians?—It is not. What place, then, shall be given to this commandment in Christian theology? Adopting the same process of reasoning that our author applies to the fourth commandment, we reply, “It is excluded.” By what rule, do you ask? By the rule already laid down in regard to the fourth commandment—that it is not mentioned.

There are also two other commandments, one against image worship, and the other against profanity, which are not mentioned in Rom. 13: 8, 9. These with the fourth make four commandments, all of which must be excluded, if the Sabbath is excluded; for they are all parts of the same law, and if Paul’s silence excludes one, the same silence must exclude them all! If it should be claimed that the other commandments are mentioned in other places of the New Testament, this would be an entire surrender of the whole argument; for we can as easily find references to the Sabbath in the New Testament scriptures as we can find those to the worship of idols or profanity.

The fact is that in this connection Paul is not pretending to give the whole body of Christian theology. An examination of the context makes it very apparent that the subject under consideration is the duties we owe our fellow-men. As we have seen, it does not touch those duties we owe to God, and we may add further, it does not include many important Christian duties, such as repentance, faith, baptism, etc. It simply presents the duties we owe all men, irrespective of class or character. Rom. 13: 8, 9, divorced from the other scriptures, only presents such a code of ethics as has been advocated and adopted by many intelligent heathen. To sum up this point: The conclusion of this writer that the Sabbath is not binding, rests upon premises which may also be used to nullify all the first four precepts of the decalogue as well as the ordinances of Christ.

Then again, we have the following statement:—

“A law without a penalty is null and void. Let us look at this seventh-day Sabbath law in Ex. 31: 15: ‘Whosoever doeth any work in the Sabbath day, he shall surely be put to death.’ It is clear that the penalty does not exist, therefore the seventh-day Sabbath law is not binding, as I believe, on any one living, either Jew or Gentile.”

Here the claim is made that because the penalty of death for Sabbath desecration is not now carried out, therefore the Sabbath commandment is no longer of force.

Remember, this argument is based on the ground of no penalty, no law. But were there not penalties attached to other precepts of that law as well as to the fourth commandment?—Most assuredly there were. There was a penalty of death for profanity. Lev. 24: 16. Is any one stoned to death now for taking God’s name in vain?—Certainly not. Then according to this writer, the law against profanity is now abolished. Adultery was also punished with death. Lev. 20: 10. This penalty is not now enforced. But shall we therefore conclude that God’s law against unchastity is not now binding? The fact is that the punishments inflicted by the civil law, then as now, are not the final nor principal penalties for sin. God “hath appointed a day in which he will judge the world in righteousness.” That tribunal pronounces upon the impenitent and ungodly of all past times a final penalty, and in that judgment the violators of the Sabbath cannot excuse themselves upon the ground that the civil law did or did not punish them for its violation. In dismissing this point, we will only say that neither the penalties enforced by the Levitical law, nor those now prescribed by the civil rulers of this world, have any effect either to mitigate or nullify the final penalty. Then will the “wrath of God be revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men who hold the truth in unrighteousness.” We may, if we choose, ignore the law of God, and thus treasure up unto ourselves “wrath against the day of wrath and revelation of the righteous judgment of God.”

Again: commenting on the death and resurrection of Christ, the writer says:—

“But those who keep the seventh day are compelled to celebrate a dead Christ.”

To this we reply that there might be some force to these words, if we dated the Sabbath from that point; but we do not. Neither the death nor the resurrection of Christ has anything whatever to do with the Sabbath; and the Bible nowhere teaches any such thing. The Sabbath dates from the creation of the world. Gen. 2: 2, 3. No amount of quibbling can ever erase the record of the sanctifying, or appointing, of the Sabbath at the very beginning of the history of our race. And as Christ was the active agent in the creation of the world (John 1: 10), and on the first Sabbath was resting and enjoying the work which his power had accomplished, we feel confident that we do not celebrate a “dead Christ” when we observe the divinely appointed memorial of all the works “which God created and made.”

As usual in writers who oppose the Sabbath, he holds that Christ never declared the Sabbath to be binding upon Christians.

To this we reply that both Christ and his apostles taught the binding force of that law of which the Sabbath was an integral part. (See Matt. 5: 17, 18; Rom. 3: 31; James 2: 10, 11.) Christ by his own words cautions his disciples in reference to future acts upon the Sabbath (Matt. 24: 20), and the disciples of Jesus kept the Sabbath after the death of Christ. Luke 23: 56. We might advance much evidence upon this point, but space forbids. This author does not stop to think that Sunday is nowhere commanded. Briefly stated, his argument is this: We need not keep the seventh-day Sabbath, because it is not commanded over again, but we should observe the Sunday which is never commanded at all!

Quoting from John 20: 19, 20, he says:—

“On the very day that Christ arose from the dead the disciples were assembled in a room, and for fear of the Jews the doors were shut. ‘Then came Jesus and stood in the midst of them and said: Peace be unto you, and he showed them his hands and his side. Then they were glad when they saw the Lord.’ Then down in the 26th verse it is said, ‘After eight days, being the first day of the week, again his disciples were within, and Christ stood in the midst and said, Peace be unto you.’ This of itself was sufficient to impress the minds of his disciples with the first day of the week being a holy day, if there was no other proof.”p. 73

But they were not thus assembled to celebrate his resurrection; for they did not at that time believe it. Further, his appearance on that occasion would no more make the Sunday the Sabbath than his meeting with the disciples on Thursday at the time of the ascension would make that day the Sabbath.

In closing, we call the attention of the reader to the fact that in this quotation a remarkable addition is made to the word of God. The writer has left out the words, “being the first day of the week,” from verse 19, apparently for the reason that they were not needed there to prove that day as Sunday, and has inserted them in verse 26 where they are very much needed to prove the very point he is trying to make; viz., that this second meeting of Christ with the disciples was also on Sunday! If this is not taking an unwarranted liberty with the word of God, we would like to know what would be. As it reads in his quotation, the human is very evident; for inspiration is not silly enough to try to squeeze eight days into one week! Perhaps some of our readers may think that we ought to be charitable enough to attribute this to ignorance or carelessness; but the whole history of Sunday exaltation has been in such perfect keeping with maneuvers of this kind that we cannot help thinking that this is another of the tricks of the Sunday trade.

The few points we have noticed are good illustrations of the reasoning of the entire article. And we think it will be evident to every thoughtful reader, that it must be a very shaky structure which rests upon such a foundation. M. E. K.