Last week's Review noticed the fact that the Peninsula Methodist was suffering acutely from the sale in its vicinity of the book “Bible Readings.” Looking at this paper again, we notice that it also has a grievance against one of its own members, even no less a personage than Bishop Foster. The Bishop has written a book entitled “Beyond the Grave,” in which he denies the resurrection of the body. So he is charged with teaching doctrines “wholly irreconcilable with the consensus of the Universal Church, and of course contrary to our articles of religion and established standards of doctrine.”
In the above criticism of Bishop Foster, we notice that he is not charged with teaching contrary to the Scriptures. Such a criticism would seem very tame with those who can see nothing but “fraud” in “Bible Readings.” The teaching of doctrines contrary to the “consensus of the Universal Church and of course contrary to our articles of religion and established standards of doctrine,” is something, however, which is thought to be a very serious matter.
As the Bishop’s book is published by the “Methodist Book Concern” without one word of dissent, good Methodists buying it, supposing it to be in harmony with Methodist doctrines, will find themselves deceived, and according to the reasoning in reference to the “Bible Readings,” those buying the book should demand a return of their cash on “penalty of prosecution for obtaining money on false pretenses.” But in reference to this book, no such action is recommended.
After having read what we have quoted above in regard to Bishop Foster, and much more of the same character, we were greatly surprised to read the following first count in the charges against the “Bible Readings”:—
“1. Man has no soul, no separate conscious spirit. Instead of his body being the house in which man’s soul lives, as Bishop Foster teaches, the body itself is the ‘living soul,’ so long, and only so long, as ‘the breath of life,’ which God breathed into his nostrils remains.”
Yes, the Peninsula Methodist actually charges that “Bible Readings” holds a position in reference to the soul not “as Bishop Foster teaches”; and yet Bishop Foster is the man who in the same issue is accused of holding a position in reference to this very subject of the soul, which is “contrary to our articles of religion and established standards of doctrine!”
The Bishop has simply carried the doctrine of the natural immortality of man to its logical conclusion, and “Bible Readings” would be one of the best books for him to read to get him out of his erroneous position and upon a good scriptural foundation. The best thing the Peninsula Methodist can do for Bishop Foster is to present him with a copy of “Bible Readings,” a careful study of which cannot fail to set him right upon the subject of the resurrection of the body. M. E. K.