THE TRANSFIGURATION AGAIN.
By W. H. Littlejohn
BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN. In the Review of Dec. 22, 1891, I published an article entitled, “The Transfiguration.” Below will be found a letter from a gentleman, which contains certain criticisms on the arguments employed in that communication, and my reply to the same. The objections contained in the letter in question are such as might occur to other individuals, and consequently it has been thought advisable to publish both the letter and the reply in the Review. Elder W. H. Littlejohn, Battle Creek, Mich. Dear Brother: Please excuse me for addressing you this, but there seems to be some unconsidered statements in your article on the “Transfiguration,” in the Review of Dec. 22. The transfiguration was a vision. Matt. 17:9. Peter’s expression in regard to the tabernacles was spoken in bewilderment, not knowing what he said. Mark 9:6; Luke 9:33. If Elias was there personally, why the conversation recorded in Matt. 17:9–13; Mark 9:9–13? Your statement that no man is able to demonstrate that Moses was not there in person, I think a little strong when compared with Scripture. (See Matt. 17:9, also Rev. 1:5 and Acts 26:23, compared with Luke 20:35, 36.) Christ was not the first in respect to title or dignity, as sometimes taught, but the first from the dead to an endless life, a resurrection. These texts prove conclusively that Moses was not there personally, bodily, or spiritually. Jude wrote his epistle some years after the death of Christ. How do we know but what Moses was among those who came out of their graves at the crucifixion and resurrection of Christ? and that it is this time to which he refers? This is not impossible. The dead had been brought back to life before Christ’s death and afterwards; but could any one of them say that they were henceforth incorruptible? that their mortality had put on immortality? that death was swallowed up in victory? Christ is to have the pre-eminence in all things. His was a resurrection to an undying life; the others, simply a restoration to the life that was. Dear Sir: Your letter of recent date is at hand. You will pardon me if I answer with extreme brevity on each point. 1. If the transfiguration was a vision in the sense that the apostles saw merely the semblance of things, and not the things themselves, then it proves nothing concerning the existence of spirits in a state of consciousness between death and the resurrection. This I understand that you virtually admit when you say that “Moses was not there personally, bodily, or spiritually.” 2. Even if the apostles were in ecstatic vision, it does not follow that what they saw when in that condition, was not real. In Rev. 1:1 we are told that the angel of God revealed to St. John the Apocalyptic vision. In Rev. 19:10 we learn that St. John fell at the feet of the angel in the act of worshiping him. This the angel forbade him to do. That John was in vision at this time, and that he saw the angel that he endeavored to worship, will hardly be disputed. But if this be true, then men in vision do sometimes see real objects. It follows, therefore, that even though Peter, James, and John were in ecstatic vision on the Mount, they might nevertheless have seen Moses and Elias clothed in their spirit bodies. 3. You say that Peter “spoke in bewilderment” when he suggested the building of a tabernacle each for Christ, Moses, and Elias. You urge this point as an answer to my argument to the effect that Peter (as proved by his remarks respecting the tabernacles) supposed that he had seen Moses and Elias in bodily form. I think that your objection is not well taken. It does not necessarily follow even though he was in a measure bewildered by what had occurred, that he was in error in supposing that Moses and Elias were there bodily. Luke says that Peter uttered these words, “not knowing what he said.” Mark has it, “He wist not what to answer.” Matthew says nothing on the point. To my mind, after putting these two statements together, the only safe conclusion to be drawn is this: Just before they entered the bright cloud, and after the transfiguration was really passed, there was a moment of delay. Peter as usual felt the burden of saying something, and yet he did not know exactly what to say. In his embarrassment, he said what he did about the “tabernacles.” This remark was ill considered, not because Christ, Moses, and Elias did not have literal bodies; but because he proposed to build on the Mount habitations for the three to dwell in. You certainly will concede that even though Christ, Moses, and Elias had literal bodies, it was unreasonable for Peter to suppose that they would take up their abode upon the Mount. My hypothesis proceeds upon the supposition that Peter had an intelligent idea of what he had seen, and that he was mistaken only in the matter of what he proposed to do on account of what he had seen. Your view would make him a blunderer in his conception of the import of what he had seen, as well as in regard to what he proposed to do. The three apostles were taken to the Mount in order that they might testify to others what had been shown to them there. What would the testimony of Peter be worth if you grant that he was deceived in so material a point as that of the bodily existence of Moses and Elias. That he believed that they had bodies is rendered certain by his proposition about the tabernacles. 4. I do not see that the conversation recorded in Matt. 17:9–13 and Mark 9:9–13 has any particular bearing upon the question at issue. It is probable that Christ told the apostles not to make known the substance of the vision until after his resurrection, because the public mind would be better prepared for such a revelation after that event, than it then was. What he says about Elias goes to show that the scribes were mistaken in expecting the literal advent of Elias. John the Baptist fulfilled in his time the prediction in regard to Elias. If Elias is to come again, that coming will not be personal, but his spirit and power will be possessed by some individual or church, even as it was by John the Baptist. 5. You think that my expression to the effect that no man can prove that Moses was not upon the Mount bodily, is a little too strong. You cite certain texts to prove that Christ was to be the first to be raised from the dead to everlasting life. This objection, like the others in your letter, is one that has been presented before, many times. There are two ways in which it can be answered, so far as the statement referred to is concerned. First, it might be admitted that Moses was there with a resurrected body such as Lazarus had; that is, one still subject to death. This admission made, it might be assumed that it was glorified for the time being, even as Christ’s mortal body was glorified to represent that body in the future world, and then divested of its glory, the nature of the body not being in reality changed. Such a supposition, I say, would196 be admissible, and would vindicate the soundness of the statement to which you object. Secondly, it has been well said that all general rules have their exceptions; for example, we read, “It is appointed unto men once to die.” Heb. 9:27. Again, “The soul that sinneth, it shall die;” once more, “If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us.” 1 John 1:8. By these texts all men are doomed to death, yet we find that the last generation of Christians, consisting as it will of many thousands, will never taste death. 1 Thess. 4:16, 17; 1 Cor. 15:51, 52. Interpret the texts given above with the same rigor as you do those that you cite respecting the fact that Christ is to be the first begotten from the dead, and the Scriptures will be broken. The only way to escape this, is to admit that the last generation of Christians will furnish an exception to the general rule. Apply the same principle to the case in hand, and all difficulty is removed; since Moses and Elias will become exceptions to the text relating to the fact that Christ was to become the first fruit from the dead to immortal life. This exception, no doubt, was made for wise purposes. Perhaps one of them was that they might appear on the Mount to personate the resurrected and the translated saints respectively. 6. You say that Moses might have been raised with those who came out of their graves at the crucifixion, and that, you claim, would explain Jude’s reference to him. Verse 9. I reply that there is no proof that there were any raised at that time who were not buried near Jerusalem. Moses’s grave was in the land of Moab, Christ could not have contended with Satan at the time of the crucifixion; for he was nailed to the cross. By reading the account in Matt. 27:52, 53 you will see that the dead at Jerusalem were raised on Friday, although they did not go into the city until Sunday morning. There are in the Jewish writings, traces of a tradition about a contest between Christ and Satan over the body of Moses, long before the Christian era. The text that I quoted from Rom. 5:14 confirms Jude’s account. 7. That the apostles were not in ecstatic vision on the Mount is implied, I think, in the language of Peter, “but were eye-witnesses of his majesty.” 2 Pet. 1:16. An eye-witness is one who sees a transaction through his natural eyes in a natural way, and not in rapturous vision. See the other use of the term found in the Bible, in Luke 1:2. In conclusion, let me say that the theory that I offer respecting the bodily presence of Moses and Elias, is the natural and obvious one. When you have an account of a conversation that took place between three persons, the witnesses to the conversation having seen the persons while talking, and knowing that one of them had a literal body, the presumption is that the other two were of like nature with the first. To destroy this presumption, positive proof is required. The burden of the argument therefore rests upon those denying that Moses and Elias were on the mount bodily. Certainly no one will charge that Messrs. Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown were not believers in the separate existence of spirits; nevertheless they admit that Moses and Elias were on the mountain in physical form, as proved by the following citation: “That Moses’s body was raised appears from his presence with Elijah and Jesus (who were in the body) at the transfiguration.”—The Pocket Commentary and Bible Dictionary on Jude 9. The extract given above is made for the sole purpose of proving that our theory of the subject in hand is the natural and obvious one. Were it not, the distinguished scholars just quoted, believing as they did in the natural immortality of the soul, would have been very glad to fortify that tenet by an argument drawn from the transfiguration based upon the supposition that it was the spirit of Moses that was on the Mount. 8. That the term “vision” is sometimes used, when the persons viewing a given object are in a natural condition of mind, and not in ecstatic vision, see Luke 24:23.