The question of what we should read depends upon the question of why we should read. No literary production should be read unless it is capable of thereby serving some useful purpose to the reader. The printing-press is constantly turning out an ever-increasing stream of literature,—using the word in its broadest sense,—and it need not be said that not all of this is calculated to confer any benefit upon the race. This necessitates the exercise of discrimination, for no one can afford to waste time in filling his mind with literary chaff. Neither can he afford to neglect that part which is capable of conferring upon him great and lasting benefit.
When the art of printing was first discovered, it was turned to a wholly beneficial use, and was largely instrumental in forwarding the work of the Reformation. But the Devil, ever seeking some means to get evil out of good, has perverted the art to his own ends, until it has become one of the most gigantic agencies for the world's demoralization, and it is an agency which does its work stealthily, obtrusively, and persistently. It is not enough merely to let this agency alone; some positive effort must be put forth to avoid it.
The value of literature lies in the fact that it is one great means of education, and no literature which does not educate, which does not, in other words, tend to cultivate and strengthen some faculty of the mind, has any value. It is with reference to this truth that the selection of reading-matter should be made.
Historical literature is of especial value, since it stores the mind with useful information, and throws a flood of light upon the nature and tendencies of the great political, social, and religious developments of our own time. No one can be able either to understand the present or to read the future, who does not view them through the light which shines upon them from the past. The study of historical literature is unquestionably very sadly neglected. Were the lessons of the past kept in mind as they should be, history would less often repeat itself in folly and bloody tragedy.
Fiction, also, is of the greatest value, though serving an entirely different purpose. By the term “fiction” is meant works of the imagination. It is best designated thus, because it is a false idea that fiction is necessarily untrue. A tale of fiction often contains more truth than a narrative of fact,—not, indeed, as concerns the mere happening of events, but with regard to other truths which it may be of much greater importance to understand. This is so when fiction is true to life. An account which must confine itself strictly to facts, affords usually less opportunity of portraying those truths which the writer may desire to set forth, than one in which the characters may be created. Hence so far as truth is concerned, fiction is not necessarily to be rejected as unfit to be read, more than is any other variety of literature. Nor does a tale derive any virtue whatever from its being “founded on facts.” The question of its worthiness or unworthiness turns not upon whether the scenes and circumstances depicted were known actually to have occurred, but upon whether or not they express what is true in nature, and upon the character of that truth. A moment’s reflection should be sufficient to show that the mere happening or not happening of anything which comes within the range of human experience does not, whether set forth in a work of fiction or otherwise, have any appreciable value to the reader, unless it be something told for the mere purpose of imparting information. The events recounted in works of fiction are not the essential part of such works, but merely the background upon which the writer depicts the nature of his characters.
Fiction may have two uses. It may, in the hands of a skillful writer,—one who has had much experience and opportunity for observation,—give valuable information and set forth valuable truths relating to human nature, and by its influence upon the mind, strengthen the love for what is good and the aversion for what is evil. It may hold up high the standard of virtue and rectitude; and when its fascinating power is employed for this end, it becomes a very worthy part of literature in general. Again, it may stimulate the imagination (for the imagination, like any other faculty of the mind, should be cultivated). It brings the imagination of one person in touch with that of another, and the stronger imparts its vigor to the weaker. Some persons would of course derive much more benefit in this way than would others.
The misuses of fiction, it need not be said, are equally great and much more numerous. Granted that what is portrayed by it is strictly true to nature, it may still be bad, for it is quite possible that it should not have been portrayed at all. Not all the truth in this world should be told, at least to the general public. Since the natural heart “is deceitful above all things and desperately wicked,” it must follow that very much of that which is true to life is not fit matter for contemplation by any mind; and it is just this depraved side of human nature which such a work of fiction most often portrays, for authors of fiction write not to elevate the masses, but to please them, having in view their own popularity rather than the mental and moral good of their readers.
But again: very much of the fiction that is produced is not true to life, but written merely to gratify a depraved mental taste which cannot be satisfied with any of the good that is to be derived from truth. This kind of fiction is essentially unnatural, and its effect is almost wholly to pervert the mind. The individual whose mind becomes perverted suffers a very serious calamity, for just so far as it is perverted, so far is it unfitted to deal intelligently and successfully with all the issues of life. Every person must take life as he finds it; and however much he may wish that this life were not what it is,—however much he may desire that his circumstances and fortune should be other than they are, he is compelled to face the fact that he is here, in the midst of certain circumstances and surroundings, and that for the present, at least, he is obliged to deal with these and none others. He may turn from these in disgust, and sigh for surroundings less commonplace, more exciting, and to his perverted imagination more grand, and not being able to place himself amidst these in reality, may place himself there in fancy by means of the novel and the opera; but in the end he must come back again to the real, only more dissatisfied with everything and less fitted and less inclined to make use of the actual opportunities within his grasp. Such an experience is most unfortunate. Sooner or later, it must be discovered that no progress can be made toward what is higher and better, not a single advance step taken, except by taking hold of what is already within reach, and that the problem of success in life is not solved by turning from the actual and reaching up to bring some great thing down from the cloudy realm of imagination, but by building up to the clouds with the material of the circumstances, however little and commonplace they may be, which actually surround us. L. A. S.
(Concluded next week.)