The following communication pertains to a question which has been treated quite at length in the “Question Chair;” but as the writer now presents his views more fully, and enters into an argument to sustain his position, we give it as a separate article:—
“With respect, love, and thanks to the esteemed occupant of the Question Chair, we submit the following thoughts and questions, subject to any comments or questions he may be pleased to make, and close our rather extended interrogations upon this important subject of God’s holy word:—
“1. The ‘interruption’ or ‘break’ in the eternal life at death, is bridged over by the Lord Jesus Christ who through his Holy Spirit receives the lives of all his dear children that die (Acts 7:59), and restores the same to them again at the resurrection of their bodies. 1 Thess. 4:14.
“2. Solomon in Eccl. 12:1-7 exhorts the unconverted to return to God ere the evil days come and death overtakes them, when body and spirit would return to the elements of earth again (Eccl. 12:7; 3:19, 20); but does the wise man refer to the death of the righteous at all, in these passages, any more than Paul refers to the righteous in Rom. 3:10-18, or to the Sabbath in Rom. 14:5?
“3. The Saviour of the world had eternal life to the extent that his very words were words of eternal life (John 6:68); but did not the divine Lord die, (Rev. 1:18) popular theology to the contrary, notwithstanding?
“4. Stephen’s dying request was the same as that of our crucified Saviour on the cross; these were his words: ‘Lord Jesus, receive my spirit,’ showing that Stephen understood that he had a principle of life, here denominated spirit, which is Christlike and eternal, which those murderers could not destroy, which Jesus received and will restore to Stephen again at the resurrection of the just.
“5. Stephen had no thought of any part of the ‘earthy’ or natural man (either soul, body, or spirit) ascending to heaven; for he had God’s word which teaches to the contrary. Eccl. 4:19-21.
‘Respectfully, “W. S. B.”
A few words in reply we will present in the order of the foregoing propositions, numbered accordingly:—
1. In our first remarks upon this subject in the REVIEW of Dec. 8, 1891, we said: “It would be easy to press this thought one step further, and affirm that man suffers no suspension of this life, or does not lose consciousness in death.” The foregoing communication is an evidence of the correctness of that statement; and we doubt if any believer in the immortality of the soul, would take any particular exception to the position set forth therein. The idea of continuity of existence is inseparable from the idea of the possession of eternal life in fact, either in this state or any other. Our correspondent recognizes this fact, when he makes provision for the space between death and the resurrection by saying that it is “bridged over” by Christ, by his taking the lives of his children to himself and restoring the same to them again at the resurrection of their bodies. But when we begin to treat the life or the life principle, as a separate entity, having individuality and identity of its own, we have only to name this principle “the immortal soul,” and the work is done; we are then completely over, body and baggage, upon the ground of the “orthodox.” The logical and inevitable conclusion from the proposition that we have, in this state, eternal life in fact, is the immortality of the soul; and this is, and has been from the beginning, our chief objection to that view.
2. In Eccl. 12:7, the writer declares that the body returns to the earth as it was, and the spirit returns unto God who gave it; not that the spirit returns to “the elements of the earth again.” We see no evidence that Solomon refers here to the unrighteous exclusively; and our correspondent seems hardly to be consistent with himself; for he holds that the spirit which returns to God is that of the righteous; but here he would have it refer only to the “unconverted.” Is not Solomon rather giving a general description of the dissolution of all men, the bodies of both righteous and wicked going back to the dust and the spirit, the breath of life, which is imparted to men by God, being given up, and so said to return to him who gave it?
3. The case of the Son of God was explained in the REVIEW of March 1. He was brought into this world in a new condition for the express purpose of suffering death. Heb. 2:9, 14. How he could lay aside for a time, the high prerogatives which he enjoyed with the Father, and so come into this world and suffer death, is one of the mysteries of godliness, which we may not in our present state, attempt to fathom. “Great is the mystery of godliness,” says Paul; God was manifested (margin) in the flesh.” 1 Tim. 3:16. Christ indeed died. He “was made a little lower than the angels for the suffering of death.” Heb. 2:9. But the suspension of his eternal life was not confined merely to the time he was in the grave; it covered all the time he was in this world previous to his resurrection from the dead. The “words of eternal life” which Peter told Christ that he had (John 6:68), referred simply to the truth which Christ taught, and which, if received and practiced, will bring us to eternal life, or enable us to secure it in the end.
4. Under this division, see remarks on proposition 1. If man has in him an entity called “spirit” which is a “principle of life,” which men cannot destroy, then there is something in him which continues to live on; for the continuance of an indestructible life principle, is a continuance of life. And it is difficult to conceive of such a continuance of life, without supposing that the thing so living, should have both consciousness and intelligence; and here comes the immortal soul again. Let us rather suppose that in Stephen’s case will be fulfilled Christ’s repeated promise, a representative statement of which we find in Matt. 16:25: “For whosoever will save his life shall lose it; and whosoever will lose his life for my sake shall find it.” We cannot lose and save a thing at the same time. If there is in us a life principle which men cannot destroy, which is the true and real life, then we cannot “lose” it at all; for that which is in the hands of Christ is not lost, and the life he gives us hereafter is not the life which we lose. But we may lose our life here, for the sake of Christ; and if we do, he has promised us eternal life in the world to come. That promise is sure to every believer; and in this sense our life (the life which we are to have) is hid with Christ in God. And this is just as true of the living saints, as of those who are sleeping in the grave. But there are not millions of life principles stored away in heaven corresponding to every saint who has died waiting to be given to each identical owner in the resurrection. But Christ is the great source and fountain of life for his people; and in the great day he will impart of that life to all those whose names are in the book of life, who by faith in him, and by the bond of his Holy Spirit in the heart, have been his children here in this world. But he does not take something from us at death, to give us back that identical thing in the resurrection.
5. In this proposition the same thought again appears, that there is something in us which “ascends to heaven” when we die. And, we repeat, there is scarcely a hair-breadth between this idea and the immortal soul of pago-papal theology. We trust our brother, and all others who are adopting like views, will see where they inevitably lead when carried out to their logical conclusion, and so be able to guard themselves against departing from Bible ground.