CANNOT AGREE

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 29, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 13.

Read the full edition

CANNOT AGREE.

It was said of the witnesses against Christ, “But their witness agreed not together.” We are forcibly reminded of these words, as we notice the contradictory positions taken by prominent religious teachers in regard to the law of God.
Dr. Lyman Abbott, editor of the Christian Union, and pastor of “Plymouth Church,” has had much to say lately about the law of the ten commandments. He thinks it a very faulty law. According to his ideas of the ten commandments, any one might keep every one of them and still be unfit to mingle in good society in New York City.
Whether or not he makes this statement because he thinks the society there better or worse than it is in the rest of the country, we do not know; but presume it is because he thinks it is better. In that case we shall expect that he will take the position that the law of God may still serve a good purpose among the ignorant country rustics, but that it is not calculated for the latitude of New York, especially in their good society, the members of which are living far better than the law of God requires them to live. We willingly allow the doctor the privilege of enjoying his good opinion of the metropolis, only remarking that if New York society has reached that high standard in religious and society experience that it has no gods, not even of wealth, fashion, or pleasure, before the true God, then it has advanced much farther than the current newspaper reports would warrant us in believing.
Other men, however, do not take so flattering a view of the morals of New York City. Dr. Parkhurst, pastor of the Madison Square Presbyterian church, in a late sermon said:—
“We are living in a wicked world, and are fallen upon bad times. And the question that has been pressed upon my heart these days and weeks past has been, What can I do? We are not thinking just now so much of the world at large as we are the particular part of the world that it is our painful duty to live in. . . . In its municipal life our city is thoroughly rotten. Here is an immense city, reaching out arms of evangelization in every quarter of the globe; and yet every step that we take looking to the moral betterment of this city has to be taken directly in the teeth of the damnable pack of administrative blood-hounds that are fattening themselves on the ethical flesh and blood of our citizenship. There is not a form under which the Devil disguises himself that so perplexes us in our efforts, or so bewilders us in the devising of our schemes, as the polluted harpies, that under the pretense of governing this city, are feeding day and night on its quivering vitals. They are a lying, perjured, rum-soaked, libidinous lot. . . . Every effort to make men respectable, honest, temperate, and sexually clean is a direct blow between the eyes of the mayor and his whole gang of drunken and lecherous subordinates in this sense that while we fight iniquity, they shield and patronize it; while we try to convert criminals, they manufacture them. . . . I should not be surprised to know that every building in this town in which gambling or prostitution or the illicit sale of liquor is carried on, has immunity secured to it by a scale of police taxation. . . . The facts do not always get to the surface, but when they do, they let in a great lot of light into the subterranean mysteries of this rum-besotted and Tammany debauched town.”
We will now listen to Dr. Talmage, who, like Dr. Abbott, is a famous Brooklyn, N. Y., preacher:—
“I expect to see a political party with only two planks in its platform, the ten commandments and the Sermon on the Mount.”
As he couples the ten commandments with the Sermon on the Mount, it must be that Dr. Talmage considers the ten commandments a good foundation upon which to stand.
But how Dr. Abbott must be shocked by such a statement! We may imagine him rising in consternation at the thought, and exclaiming, “What! stand up for that old obsolete law, so loose in its requirements that those who observe it perfectly are not fit to move in New York society! ‘Away with such a fellow from the earth; for it is not fit that he should live.’ He will corrupt the nation.”
So their witness does not agree. In reference to all of which we would humbly have a word to say: We would remind Dr. Abbott that while it may be true that a commandment-keeper may not be considered worthy of a place in New York society, no one need feel depressed thereby; for we read in the word of God: “Blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city.” Rev. 22:14. The humble commandment-keeper may therefore be consoled by the thought that even if he is not considered worthy of a place in New York society, he can enter the city of God, and associate with Jesus and holy angels.
And to Dr. Talmage we would express the wish that he would strengthen his position on the perpetuity of the ten commandments by preaching the authority of the fourth commandment with a scriptural, rather than a church, construction of its scope and meaning; and that he will devote his efforts to impressing the law of God upon the consciences of the people, rather than trying to incorporate it into the platform of a political party.
M. E. K.