It is a notorious fact, as stated by the United States Judge Parker in a recent charge to a grand jury, that the enforcement of criminal law in this country is by no means a perfect success. For example, the number of known murders committed during the last two years was 10,196, and only 552 of the murderers suffered death for the crime. Moreover, of these 552, only 230 were executed in pursuance of law, while 322 were disposed of by the lynching process. Judge Parker estimates that the undiscovered murders outnumber the discovered ones, which goes to show that hardly one homicide in fifty is duly punished. The same is true in a relative degree of other crimes. A large portion of them are never detected; a majority of the guilty parties are never caught, even when their identity is known; and in cases of those who are arrested and tried, more are acquitted than convicted. There must be grave defects in our system of criminal jurisprudence, or this remarkable failure of justice would not ensue. We have plenty of officers and courts, but somehow they do not serve the purpose to bring evil-doers to judgment and punishment with proper celerity and certainty.
In the opinion of Judge Parker, there are several reasons for this unsatisfactory condition. The carelessness of courts, the prevalence of perjury, the use of corrupting influences, and above all, the indifference of the people to terrible crimes are some of the sources of mischief that he mentions. It is not to be doubted that the courts are too much disposed to let criminals escape on technical grounds. There is always a lawyer ready to defend a culprit by the use of all known forms of strategy and sophistry, and juries permit themselves to be swayed by arguments that are addressed to their prejudices and their sympathies instead of their reason. In the event of conviction, a pretext is readily found for granting a new trial, and that usually means a reversal of the first verdict. The highest judicial tribunals are above listening to special pleas and interfering with the vindication of the law by ordering additional proceedings where there is no reasonable doubt as to the question of guilt. It is true, also, that money, social power, and other agencies are employed to shield the criminal and defeat the prosecution. The people are much to blame, undoubtedly, and the remedy lies chiefly in their hands. Public sentiment is the controlling force in this as in all other matters, and the laws will be enforced with more success whenever that sentiment demands such action with suitable clearness and earnestness.—St. Louis Globe-Democrat.