THE TREND OF ECCLESIASTICAL THOUGHT

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 15, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 11.

Read the full edition

THE TREND OF ECCLESIASTICAL THOUGHT.

BY ELDER DAN. T. JONES.
(Walla Walla, Wash.)
For several centuries previous to the Reformation and up to that time, a larger place was given to the discussion of religious questions than any other. All, from the king to the peasant, vied with each other in manifesting their zeal for the cross and the religion which it symbolized. As an illustration of the almost universal interest taken in religious questions and the prominent place which they held in the minds of the people, we have the crusades from the eleventh to the thirteenth centuries. When the news reached Europe that the infidels had taken possession of Jerusalem, and were desecrating the holy places, all Europe was indignant; and when the first crusade was preached by Peter the Hermit and others, the response from the people was almost unanimous. The historian Ridpath, speaking of this, says:—
The actual number of those who, from the various ranks of society, sprang up as if by a common impulse, took on the cross, and rallied at the call of Peter and his fellow-apostles, can never be authentically ascertained. Certain it is that all Europe seemed to rise as if by a common impulse. . . . For awhile it appeared that all Europe would be depopulated.
A few centuries later there was a great reaction. Religious questions were relegated to a secondary place, and then almost banished from many circles. It came to be considered impolite to introduce the Bible or any question pertaining to religion, at a social entertainment. The discussion of religious subjects was left almost exclusively to the pulpit and the religious press. Now the tide seems to be turning again, and a current is setting in which seems destined to bring ecclesiastical questions into greater prominence than they have been for several generations.
The prominent theological controversies of the last few years, the agitation for Sunday-closing of the Columbian Exposition, the promulgation of the doctrines of theosophy and Christian science, the agitation for a change in the Constitution of the United States, which will make that document permit the legalizing of Sunday observance, the Religious Parliament to be held in Chicago in 1893, with other causes, combine to bring about the result referred to above.
The Boston Congregationalist said recently:—
Never were so many questions asked about the Bible and its teachings as now. A few years ago if one sought discussion concerning it in periodical literature, he turned to the “Bibliotheca Sacra” or the Princeton Review. Now he will find Biblical themes prominent in the Forum, the North American, and other secular periodicals, which are not sustained for the sake of extending knowledge of the Scriptures, but which aim to furnish what the people most demand in literature. The daily press also gives large space to treatment of the Bible, which not long ago was left almost wholly to religious papers.
All religionists will rejoice to see the Bible receiving the portion of public favor which the character of its teachings and the importance of the subject which it treats would seem to justify; and they will be interested also to know the trend that the discussion of Bible subjects is taking in the secular press; for it is a well-known fact, as the writer last quoted says, that the larger majority of secular periodicals aim to supply what the people most demand, and not only what they demand, but of the character which best suits the public taste, and judging from what appears in the different periodicals and magazines, we must conclude that what is popularly termed the New Theology, or Advanced Thought, as applied to religion, is what the people want.
President Charles F. Thwing, in Education for January, under caption of the Higher Education and Christianity, says:—
The higher education promotes Christianity. We acknowledge that some minds assent to this proposition with hesitation. God’s kingdom is built on faith, it is said. And the higher education, it is also said, is antagonistic to faith. Thought is the mother of doubt; philosophy, the parent of atheism. Reasoning fosters agnosticism. The gospel of science is not the gospel of Christianity. And yet, we know that truth must be consistent with itself. The gospel of the rocks, properly interpreted, is one with the gospel of the Bible properly interpreted.
With his conclusions here, all believers in the Bible can fully agree, but the trend of his argument is revealed further on in a cautious but distinct manner; we indicate it by italics:—
If beings dwell on planets other than the earth, they in this kingdom have a share. If unseen spiritual existences move about us, they of this kingdom are citizens. The spirits of the redeemed are within its realms, and the souls of the lost are lost far more to themselves than they are to Him who is still their Father.
The Andover Review for January, speaking on Ultra-Conservatism and the New Theology, says:—
The most restive party in the various denominations is the party whose orthodoxy, in its own opinion, has been kept whole and undefiled, and is above suspicion by others. It has been supposed that unrest is confined to the liberals, who have been thought of as tossed to and fro by every wind of doctrine, as struggling painfully in the break-up of their old faiths, as torn asunder by conflicting opinions. . . . But whatever unrest may accompany re-adjustment of one’s beliefs in the light of increasing knowledge, there is also restiveness on the part of those who try to stand still while the world and the church are moving away from them. Indeed, signs are not wanting that the ultra-conservative party is at present more disturbed than any other.
William Riley Halstead, in the Methodist Review, writing on The Province of Philosophy, says:—
The fundamental problems of religion have always been among the important, if not the most important, problems of life. But religion begins with God and his attributes, and the world has never lost interest in the search for clearer apprehensions of him. The fact of virtue, the fact of vice, the fact of moral government, the fact of happiness, the fact of sorrow, the fact of existence itself—these are as plain as the facts of daylight and darkness, and the building constructed without them had better look well to the corners and sides of its foundation. The student who is given to details is not always prepared for an insight into this common scheme of things which constitutes one system. So philosophy, in its broadest sense, keeps science from gloom and disappointment in showing the affinity of all facts, their contracts, their eternal co-ordinations. Its purpose is to correct and clarify and lead human thought into safe moorings.
Rev. Walter Lloyd, in Westminster Review for January, writing under the caption Inspiration and Truth, says:—
The fact is that the best-informed men in the churches have at last come to see that the old unintelligent regard for the Old Testament must be abandoned. Its infallibility can no longer be denied, and no amount of declamation will long secure a belief in its plenary inspiration. It will have to be admitted that the chronicles of the history of Israel and its religious institutions are on a level with those of other nations. . . . In reality, there is nothing exceptional in that history except the pertinacity with which the Jews claimed to be the chosen people, and the subsequent perversity of Christians in admitting the claim to be well founded. . . . Even now, a Christian preacher will introduce a quotation from the Pentateuch or the prophets, by saying, “Let us hear what God says,” instead of referring it to Isaiah or Jeremiah or the author of Deuteronomy, as the case may be. The “Thus saith the Lord” throws a glamour over the utterance, and tends to perpetuate an illusion it seems impossible to dispel. . . . Nothing seems more absurd than to place on the same level such very mixed and widely differing portions of literature as those which are thrown together in the Old Testament; and all those persons, whether they belong to the old orthodoxy or the new, who insist upon “taking it as a whole,” are guilty not only of literary ignorance, but religious folly.
The Rev. Dr. Alford Cave, in the Homiletic Review for February, refers to the agitation on the subject of the errancy or inerrancy of the Scriptures, and after stating the positions held by the contestants on either side of the question, kindly offers his services as a mediator to settle the dispute. He says:—
Seeing, as I think, truth on both sides, I am desirous of saying a calm and mediating word. That word is, that revelation, but not inspiration, necessarily implies inerrancy. . . . It is the revealed rather than inspired character of the Bible which nowadays renders the Bible authoritative. . . . In other words, that the records exist is due to inspiration, but that the record is the supreme arbiter in matters of faith and practice, is due to revelation. . . . By so simple a distinction, the loftiest views of the supremacy of scriptures are safeguarded, at the same time that no such burden is put upon the shoulders of the thoughtful as the absolute inerrancy of all scripture. . . . If the revelations are accurate enough for all practical purposes, what matters it whether they are absolutely inerrant?
The New York Observer, noting the trend of theological discussion and apparently fearing the results, especially upon the youth, says:—
For the sake of the intellectual as well as the spiritual welfare of the youth of this day who are watching intently the drift of controversies among those who profess to believe the word of God, we call attention to one of the common statements of the new theology, in the strength of which it practically obliterates any distinction between essentials and non-essentials in the matter of belief. It denies emphatically that any dogmatic opinion whatever is an essential to true and acceptable Christianity. It makes salvation utterly independent of any intelligent faith in the name, person, and work of the Redeemer. It is the old Unitarian enlargement of the meaning of the word “Christian,” until it is broad enough to include any person with certain moral characteristics or spiritual sentiments. . . . Of course all this is absolutely destructive of the evangelical idea of the necessity of faith in Christ, in order to obtain acceptance with the Father. It is also destructive of any intelligent conception of what the evangelical churches have always insisted upon as being saving faith.
J. W. Etter, D. D., in the Quarterly Review of the United Brethren, says:—
This is a day of theological unrest. In this era through which we are passing, an era of transitions and revolutions in thought unparalleled since the days of the Reformation, men are rising and falling, shifting and drifting, theologically and ecclesiastically. The question, “Whither?” is giving way to another,—“What next?”
It is not to be expected that in a general upheaval of theology the men who burst the bands of their various creeds and launch out into independent fields of thought, will agree with each other. It may reasonably be expected that they will differ widely, and such we find is the case. In one thing, however, they very generally agree, that the Bible is not competent to make the man of God perfect and thoroughly furnish him unto all good works. Those who would become the arbiters between the old and the new theology decide that if the Scriptures are accurate enough for all “practical purposes,” that is sufficient. But let confidence in the inspiration of the Bible be broken down, and it is not difficult to see what the ultimate result will be. And this seems to be the work that is being pushed forward at the present time with a power and rapidity that is little realized by those who do not keep a close watch of the agitation.