AdventAI

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 11., March 15, 1892

[We aim to reply under this head, to questions which are of such a nature that the answers will be of general interest and profit to the readers of the REVIEW. Those sending in long lists of disconnected texts for explanation, evidently as a mere matter of curiosity to see how certain puzzling passages will be disposed of, need not be surprised if no notice is taken of them. Many more inquiries are received than can be answered in this department; and the editor reserves the right to decide which to notice in this manner. All correspondents should therefore give their names and true post-office address, that queries not replied to here may be answered by mail.]

159.—GOD A SPIRIT.— JOHN 4:24.

What is taught by the statement that “God is a spirit,” found in John 4:24? H. C. W.

Answer.—The word “spirit,” as applied, in the manner here used, to God, doubtless means “a spiritual being,” the same as when applied to other beings. For instance, the angels are called “spirits” (Heb. 1:7); but angels are real, literal beings; for they have many times manifested themselves as such unto men. (See Acts 1:10, 11; 5:19, 20; 12:7, 8; Judges 6:22; etc.) We would say to H. C. W. and a number of other correspondents who have sent in questions of a similar nature, that the subjects of soul and spirit, man’s nature, the state of the dead, and final destiny of both righteous and wicked, with all the scriptures bearing upon these subjects, are examined and explained in the work “Here and Hereafter,” published at this Office. Price $1.

160.—THE CHURCH FORGIVING SIN. JOHN 20:23.

1. Has the church ever had power to forgive sins? If not, what is the meaning of John 20:23? But if they have, do they have the same power still? 2. Do we ever reach a state in this world in which we cannot sin? 1 John 3:9. 3. What is meant by being born again? A. M. J.

Ans.—To ten of his apostles Christ said, according to the passage referred to, “Whosoever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whosoever sins ye retain, they are retained.” But mark also what is said in the verse before: “He breathed on them, and saith unto them, Receive ye the Holy Ghost.” Here was a special endowment which no others had before, or have since, enjoyed. It is not intimated that what they received they were to transmit to others, or that they were then installed in an office in which there was to be regular succession, and that they were to transfer the same prerogatives to their successors. When a church can be found upon which the Lord has personally breathed to confer a special impartation of the Holy Ghost, and whom he has told that they were granted the power to remit or retain sins, we may believe that they can forgive sin, but not otherwise. Especially is it inadmissible to suppose that a church which has not retained the purity of the gospel, has power to forgive sins, because Christ once permitted his special apostles and them alone to do so. 2. We reach a condition when converted, in which it is morally impossible for us to deliberately engage in conscious sin; but not physically. Any Christian if solicited to take part in a theft or robbery, would reply at once, “I cannot do it.” Understand “cannot” in 1 John 3:9 in the same sense. 3. Any change which introduces us into a new life, is a new birth, or being born again. The expression is most frequently applied to that change which takes place in one at conversion, when he enters upon the new spiritual life of the Christian. (See this question answered more at length in the REVIEW of Nov. 11, 1890.)

161.—THE SHADOW OF DEATH. PS. 23:4.

What is meant, in Ps. 23:4, by “the shadow of death”? I lately heard a minister quote this text to prove the immortality of the soul, claiming that it was not death that we pass through, but only the shadow of it. J. W.

Ans.—The Bible often speaks of the “vain imaginations” in which men indulge. This seems to be one of them. If passing through only the shadow of death produces such results as we see, we wonder what it would be, on this man’s hypothesis, to pass through death itself. According to his view, there is no such thing as passing through death; for all are immortal, and cannot die, and only pass through the shadow of death. Then what is death itself? The Bible represents that we pass through death; but to suit this theory the Bible will have to be revised so as to read, “The soul that sinneth shall not die, but only pass through the shadow of death.” Eze. 18:20. “The wages of sin is the shadow of death.” Rom. 6:23. The logical absurdity of this man’s position is apparent. According to his view, there is no death; then how in reason can it cast any shadow? But according to his logic, here is something that casts so dreadful a shadow that the thing itself doesn’t exist! The expression David uses, “The valley of the shadow of death,” is clearly only a poetical description of death itself.

162.—A QUESTION OF CHRONOLOGY. 1 KINGS 6:1.

How long was it from the exodus to the building of Solomon’s temple? 1 Kings 6:1 gives it as 480 years. Acts 13:18–22 makes it about 570 years. And I have seen it elsewhere stated to be over 600 years. An explanation will greatly oblige. L. B.

Ans.—The correct period can be computed from the statements of Paul in Acts 13:18–22. Paul here names periods amounting to 530 years. To this sum we are to add six years from the death of Moses to the division of the land, forty years for the reign of David, and three full years of the reign of Solomon (for it was in his fourth year that the building of the temple began), and we have just 579 years, making it the 580th year after the exode to the building of the temple. Why then do we have 480 in 1 Kings 6:1?—Barrett in his “Synopsis of Criticisms,” on this passage says that in the earliest Hebrew and Greek texts there was no such number expressed in 1 Kings 6:1; that it is a fictitious number added at a later time by the Jews, and adopted by Eusebius about the middle of the fourth century, and that modern translators, misled by him, have inserted it in the text. Josephus had no number in his Hebrew copy of the book of Kings. He has a computation of his own, however, making in one instance 592 years, and in two or three other instances 612 years. His testimony being thus inconsistent with itself, is of no account. As authority for these facts, Mr. Barrett refers to Jackson’s Chronology, vol. 1, pp. 147–162.

163.—FORGIVENESS OF SIN.

1. When are sins forgiven? at conversion, or at the day of judgment? 2. When a person truly repents and seeks forgiveness of his past sins, are they forgiven at the time of asking, or will they stand against him till the day of judgment?

Ans.—Sins are forgiven when they are repented of and confessed; but they are not blotted out till the judgment. The account, so to speak, is kept open till the individual’s probation ends; for until that time, it is possible for him to apostatize, and so lose all the benefit of his past repentance and pardon. Eze. 18:21–24. The sanctuary service shows us that until the decisions of the judgment are passed, forgiveness is only relative, not absolute; that is, by pleading the merits of the divine offering in his behalf, the sins of the sinner are removed from him and transferred to the sanctuary. But whether they will always remain away from him, and rest upon him no more, or not, depends upon his perseverance in the ways of righteousness. For all these sins are to be removed from the sanctuary, when the sanctuary is cleansed, or the atonement is made, and placed upon the heads of their responsible authors, who will perish with them. If those who have once been pardoned continue faithful to the end, their sins will be laid on the head of the antitypicalp. 169 scape-goat; if not, they will be rolled back upon their own heads. The same truth is also taught in the parable of the unjust servant in Matt. 18:23–35.

164.—TEMPTATION TO SIN. JAMES 1:13, 14.

Does the word “tempted” in James 1:13, 14, mean simply tempted to sin? or does it mean led to commit sin? Are not the temptations of the child of God rather from without than from lust that dwells within? and are not the sins which overcome him the result of yielding the will to the power of temptation from without, and thus admitting lust or perhaps developing it, instead of being the result of lust that dwells in the heart? M. A. W.

Ans.—“Tempted” as used in these texts means “solicited to sin.” In this sense God tempts no man. While God does “tempt” men in the sense of trying or testing them, as he is said to have tempted Abraham (Gen. 22:1), he never tempts any one in the sense of soliciting to sin; neither is he responsible for the unfavorable conditions with which we are environed, nor for our natural propensities to sin. All these men have brought upon themselves. The downward tendency of the human race since the first defection of Adam, has made the heart of man most congenial soil for the growth of evil. Taking advantage of our natural propensities, the tempter incites us to sin. The word “lust” is here used in its broad sense, signifying wrong desires of any kind, covering the whole range of worldliness, appetites, and passions. The desires are stimulated through all the avenues of the senses, and as we are constituted by nature, are easily stimulated in the wrong direction, and clamor for indulgence. This is the “enticing” of which James speaks. The sin is surrendering our wills to these wrong desires and passions, and letting them lead. The result of this unlawful connection is sin. Verse 15. “Then when lust hath conceived it bringeth forth sin.” Then sin in its turn becomes an awful progenitor and brings forth death. So, as Dr. Deems tersely puts it, “The sinner is the father of his own sin, and the grandfather of his own death.” It is the office of the grace of God so to change man’s nature, so renovate the soil of his heart, that good desires and impulses will take root and grow there instead of evil.