IN THE QUESTION CHAIR

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 16, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 7.

Read the full edition

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

144.—EVERY DAY ALIKE. ROM. 14:5.

Please explain in the Question Chair, the 14th of Romans. Does verse 5 refer to the weekly day of rest? or does the chapter throughout when speaking of eating and observance of days, refer to the law of ceremonies? O. S.
Answer.—It refers to the law of ceremonies only. It has no reference whatever to the weekly Sabbath. The term “every day” does not here include the Sabbath, any more than it does in Ex. 16:4, where the same term is used, and the Sabbath is expressly excepted. (See article “Epidemic of Romans 14,” in REVIEW of May 26, 1891, where this chapter is fully examined.)

145.—THE MARK OF THE BEAST. REV. 13:16.

A First-day Adventist here in Tacoma, Wash., who is doing his utmost to oppose the truth, claims that the mark of the beast refers to what Catholic priests do on Ash-Wednesday, when they make a paste of ashes and pitch called “holy chrism,” and make a cross with it on the right hand and forehead of believers. Can such a ceremony fulfill Rev. 13:16? J. M. C.
Ans.—It cannot. If our opponents would stop and reason a little, they would see that no such incidental ceremonies of the Catholic Church could constitute the mark of the beast. The papacy is that man of sin (2 Thess. 2:3, 4) who was to exalt himself above all that is called God, or that is worshiped. The antagonism is between himself and God. A mark is a badge of authority. The mark of the beast is some badge of his authority as arrayed against that of his antagonist, God. It must pertain to some point in which its authority and that of God come in conflict. It must be on some point, therefore, on which God has made known his will and set forth his authority. But whether we shall daub ourselves up with ashes and pitch or not, God has never said one way or the other. The papacy can therefore raise no issue between itself and God on that point. The authority of God is set forth in his law. It is in reference to this alone, therefore, that the papacy can set up counter claims, and endeavor to raise itself above God. And this is the very thing the papacy has endeavored to do in the change of the Sabbath, the only change it has attempted in the law, but the most radical change it could attempt, inasmuch as the fourth commandment is the great memorial of Jehovah, setting forth the claims and prerogatives of the Most High. It is absolutely impossible that the mark of the beast can be anything else than this change which it has attempted in the law of God.

146.—DOES THE LORD DECEIVE? JER. 20:7.

Please explain through the REVIEW Jer. 20:7: “O Lord, thou hast deceived me, and I was deceived.” How is it that the Lord deceives? C. H. H.
Ans.—By looking at the text, it will be seen that for the word “deceived,” as used in the second instance, the margin reads “enticed;” and it is the same word from which “deceived” is rendered in the first instance, and it would have been better so rendered there. The root, pathah, signifies “to persuade or entice.” All that the prophet says, therefore, is this: “O Lord, thou hast persuaded me, and I was persuaded.” That is, the Lord had moved upon him, led him, or caused him, to declare his message of warning faithfully to the people. But he had been brought into great trouble thereby, and was tempted to feel that the Lord had forsaken him. But faith triumphed, and he declared that his enemies would stumble, and he would be delivered. (See context.)

147.—WAS JONAH A FALSE PROPHET? JONAH 3:10.

Jonah was commissioned to warn Nineveh that in forty days the city should be overthrown. But the record says that the Lord repented, and did not destroy it. As the Lord is unchangeable, how could he repent? and as the city was not destroyed in forty days, did not the Ninevites have good reason to consider Jonah a false prophet? C. H. H.
Ans.—The very reason why the Lord repented, in this case, was because he is unchangeable. The invariable condition on which he deals with nations and individuals, is stated in Jer. 18:7–10: “At what instant I shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a kingdom, to pluck up, and to pull down, and to destroy it; if that nation, against whom I have pronounced, turn from their evil, I will repent of [or turn from] the evil I thought to do unto them. And at what instant I shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a kingdom, to build and to plant it; if it do evil in my sight, that it obey not my voice, then I will repent of [or turn from and not do] the good wherewith I said I would benefit them.” This is plain and consistent. God cannot be a friend to, and favor, iniquity; and he cannot be the enemy of repentance. This shows that all his threatenings and his promises are based on conditions; and if men change their position, that will change the result in their cases; that is, if they turn from a wicked course to righteousness, God will turn from the judgments he would have inflicted upon them if they had continued in wickedness, and instead, will do them good; and if on the other hand they turn from a course of righteousness to a course of sin and rebellion against God, God will turn from the good he would have done them if they had continued in their uprightness, and, instead, will do them evil. The case of Nineveh illustrates this invariable rule. God purposed to destroy the city on account of its wickedness, and would have done so, had they continued therein. But they humbly repented before him; consequently he turned from that purpose and did not destroy it, according to his unchangeable rule to accept of repentance and reformation. Now if God had destroyed the city, notwithstanding their repentance, then he might have been charged with being a changeable being, sometimes acting on the rule he had laid down to govern his conduct, and sometimes not. This of course does not apply to such as pass beyond the limits of his mercy to inevitable destruction.
In regard to the Ninevites considering Jonah a false prophet, did they not enter upon the work of repentance on the very ground that God would, if they did so, turn away from his fierce anger, and they would not perish? (Chap. 3:5–9.) And when the Lord heeded their supplications and did not destroy them, they would have no occasion to forfeit all the blessing they had received, by turning around and accusing Jonah of being a false prophet, and giving up the whole transaction as a fraud.
It might be well to remark that the word “repent” is sometimes used with reference to man, to denote the fickleness and changeableness characteristic of him; and in this sense God does not repent. (See 1 Sam. 15:29.)

148.—LAYING DOWN OUR LIVES. 1 JOHN 3:16.

1. Christ laid down his life for us. Did he die to satisfy the demands of a broken law? If so, did he die the same as the transgressor would have died, if there had been no remission for sin? 2. And as the text says that we should lay down our lives for the brethren, does this mean the life we now live, or the hope of eternal life? R. U. M.
Ans.—1. Christ in our behalf took the place of a sinner before the law, and laid down his life for us. That was an offering of such infinite merit that every son and daughter of Adam who will accept of the provision on the conditions offered, can plead that death in place of his or her own, as full satisfaction for the demands of the law. Unnecessary difficulties are sometimes raised on this question, by taking in circumstances which are only concomitant and incidental, and are no part of the real issue involved. Thus it is sometimes presented in this way: “The penalty for sin is eternal death; and if Christ paid the penalty for sin, he must have suffered eternal death;” which would make the situation very puzzling. But this matter of the duration of the condition of death, is only incidental, depending on circumstances. The death Adam died would have been eternal, had not the plan of salvation been devised. But the fact that this plan makes that death only temporary, in no way affects its character as the threatened penalty of Adam’s transgression. So Christ died, and his death, simply as an accomplished fact, without reference to the question whether he would ever be released from it or not, is the sacrifice he made, the penalty which he suffered. In the case of the finally lost, their death becomes eternal, because there is no provision made for any release from it.
2. The injunction that we ought to (be willing to) lay down our lives for the brethren, can refer only to this present life, as this is all that we have. The hope of future life is not the life itself. It seems more consistent to understand both Moses and Paul in those famous passages—Ex. 32:32 and Rom. 9:3—to refer to this present life and temporal judgments upon the Jewish people, according to the views of critics generally upon these scriptures.