In the attainment of our salvation God has not left us to do all the work ourselves, neither has he promised to do it all for us. He will make all the advances and provisions in our behalf that love and mercy can make; and then it remains for us to do something to show that we respond to the overtures of his grace, and will accept and act upon the conditions offered.
For man is a free moral agent. His service and love to God must be voluntary and free. God does not, and will not, compel any one to obey and be saved. He has not made his intelligent creatures mere machines, compelled to move in just such channels as the designer had foreordained for them.
To adjust in due proportion the divine and human agency in the actions of men, to decide how much is to be attributed to God’s absolute sovereignty, and how much to man’s free will, has caused a great amount of study, and in some minds no little perplexity. This is a question which should not be decided without due thought; for it is one on which there is liability of adopting wrong conclusions, and of running to dangerous extremes.
That man, in some services at least, is taken into the high position of being a co-worker with God, is stated in such scriptures as these: 1 Cor. 3:8, 9: “And every man shall receive his own reward according to his own labor. For we are laborers together with God; ye are God’s husbandry, ye are God’s building.” Again, 2 Cor. 6:1: “We then, as workers together with him, beseech you also that ye receive not the grace of God in vain.”
But lest it might be said that these scriptures refer more particularly to the work of those who are laboring in behalf of others, we will turn to another passage, which speaks expressly of our own experience, and of the relation in which we stand to God in this matter. Phil. 2:12, 13: “Work out your own salvation with fear and trembling: for it is God which worketh in you both to will and to do of his good pleasure.”
The words, “Work out your own salvation with fear and trembling,” are very strong. They imply labor on a matter of infinite importance, and labor put forth with great earnestness and anxiety—work “with fear and trembling.” Having said this, it certainly cannot be that the apostle in the very next clause turns around and contradicts it all by asserting that the Lord is going to do all this work himself, and that we have nothing to do ourselves. So we think it will be found that in the closing statement of this quotation we are not released from “willing” and “doing” something in our own behalf.
This is made clear by the construction of the passage itself. In the expression, “For it is God which worketh in you,” the verb is the participle with the article. Literally it would read, “For God is the working in you;” that is, “the one working in you.” Now if the idea is that God is the one who does all the work next mentioned, namely, “to will and to do of his good pleasure,” the sense would demand that the same construction be carried through the sentence, and these verbs be in the participial form also, so that literally it would read, “For God is the one working in you, the one both willing and doing of his good pleasure.”
But such is not the construction. After the word “you,” there is a change from the participial form to the infinitive mode, so reading, not, “willing” and “doing,” but “to will” and “to do.” Who to will and to do?—“You to will and to do;” showing that to will and to do pertain to the “you,” and not to God. God is the one working in you, that you may both will and do his good pleasure.
And this brings us back to the thought of man’s free moral agency, and the important part which man’s free will acts in this matter. For, as stated above, man is a free moral agent; and any theory that overlooks this fact, or fails to recognize its proper influence on this question, is sure to be misleading. In the presence of that awful prerogative of free will with which God has endowed the human family, he holds in abeyance his own omnipotence, that every man may be the arbiter of his own destiny. And this arena of man’s free will, is, in his case, the great battle-ground between truth and error, and right and wrong. God, Christ, and good angels bring all proper influences to bear upon men, and set before them all proper motives to lead them to the right way; while, on the other hand, the Devil and his evil angels bring to bear upon them all the influence they can exert, to lead them to the wrong. And that is all that either party can do in his case, till man sins away his day of grace. Man has the power to decide and choose in reference to all these influences; and for the exercise of that power he is responsible.
How much then does Paul mean when he says that “it is God which worketh in you”?—He refers simply to those means which God uses (stopping short of any infringement upon our free will) to lead us to the right way. God makes known to us himself and his will; he sets before us promises to win us to the good, and threatenings to deter us from the evil; he gives us the marvelous manifestation of his love in the offering of his beloved Son; and he grants us the influence of the Holy Spirit to set home with due weight these great facts upon our minds. And what is the object of all this?—It is to lead us “both to will and to do of his good pleasure.” That is the first point to be gained—to induce us to yield to his desires and offers, to win over our wills to be in harmony with his own. And until this is done, he can neither use us nor do anything directly for us toward the attainment of our salvation. But when our will is yielded and turned in the direction of his invitations to us, then the doing of his good pleasure naturally follows; for then it is our pleasure to do his will, and our will to do his pleasure. And in this attitude toward God he can consistently give us, and has promised to give us, all the help we need, to enable us to do what we have to do. “I can do all things,” said Paul, “through Christ which strengtheneth me.” Phil. 4:13. So Joshua said: “As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord.” And having thus “willed,” he went on and did the service.
To illustrate: B is in possession of a certain book which A desires for some necessary purpose to consult; and he asks B for the loan of his book. If B is not inclined to accommodate him, he must first be made willing. And therefore A brings arguments to bear upon him, telling him how much he needs and desires it, and offering all the inducements in his power to lead him to comply with his request. A thus works in B. Finally, under this influence B yields, and producing the book, loans it to A for his use. Now B has done A’s will and good pleasure, has he not? But suppose B, in a state of insane passivity, had listened to A’s request, but made no move to comply with it, and A had stepped forward and taken the book himself, B simply letting him do it, could A then turn and thank and commend B for having complied with his request? Could it be said that B then had willed and done A’s good pleasure? No more can it be said of us that we will and do the Lord’s good pleasure, if we do nothing, but, as it is said, let him do it all. But remember that the apostle says, “You to will and to do of his good pleasure.”
Some seem so desirous of having it appear not only that we have nothing to do, but that it is absolutely impossible for us to do anything, that they liken the Christian to a pen in the hand of a writer. We are to be instruments in the hands of God, we are told, as the pen is an instrument in the hands of the penman. And as the pen of itself can do nothing, so, it is said, we can do nothing. But a writer takes up the pen, and then a good and effectual work is wrought with it. So God takes us, and then we are instruments in his hands to accomplish his work.
The trouble with both this idea and this illustration, is, that it ignores man’s free moral agency, which will never do. When the apostle teaches that we are to be instruments in the hands of God, what does he say?—“Yield yourselves unto God . . . and your members as instruments of righteousness unto God?” But suppose we will not yield? suppose we will not “will”?—Then we cannot become instruments of righteousness unto God, and we will not do of his good pleasure. If we were irresponsible sticks and stones, then God might use us as the penman uses his pen; but then our lot would be a hopeless and inexorable fatalism. We do not go to the pen or hoe and ask them if they will be instruments in our hands for the accomplishment of certain things, and leave them to decide the matter, as God comes to us and asks us if we will do his will or his good pleasure, and then leaves it with us to decide what we will do.
A note on Phil. 2:13, in Dr. Clarke’s Commentary, so well expresses what must commend itself to every one as the true sense of this passage, that we copy it for the benefit of the reader:—
“For it is God which worketh in you.—Every holy purpose, pious resolution, good word and good work, must come from him; ye must be workers together with him, that ye receive not his grace in vain; because he worketh in you, therefore work with him, and work out your own salvation. To will and to do—to thelein kai to energein. The power to ‘will’ and the power to ‘do’ must necessarily come from God; but the act of volition, and the act of working is of man. God gives power to will, man wills through that power; God gives power to act, and man acts through that power. Without the (divinely given) power to will, man can will nothing good; without the power to work, man can do nothing toward effectuating his own salvation. God neither wills for man, nor works in man’s stead, but he furnishes him with power to do both; he is therefore accountable to God for these powers. Because God works in them the power to will and the power to do, therefore the apostle exhorts them ‘to work out’ their ‘own salvation,’ most manifestly showing that the use of the powers of volition and action belongs to themselves. They cannot do God’s work, they cannot produce in themselves a power ‘to will and to do’; and God does not do their work, he does not work out their salvation ‘with fear and trembling’ (but enables them to do so). Though men have grievously puzzled themselves with questions relative to the will and power of the human being, yet no case can be plainer than that which the apostle lays down here: the power to ‘will’ and ‘do’ comes from God by the inworking of the Holy Ghost; the use of that power belongs to man. He that has not this power can neither will nor work; he that has this power can do both. But it does not necessarily follow that he to whom these powers are given will use them; the possession of the powers does not necessarily imply their use, because a man may have them and not use them; therefore the apostle exhorts: ‘Work out your own salvation.’”