In the Reviews of Dec. 16 and 23, 1890, appeared two articles under this heading, from the pen of Elder J. G. Matteson. They were in review of the position taken by a person in Sweden, signing himself “N.,” who came out in a tract in opposition to the views of Seventh-day Adventists on this subject. Elder Matteson fully exposed the weakness of the arguments set forth in the tract, showing its self-contradictions and its opposition to both history and Scripture.
The writer, we understand, has attempted a rejoinder to Elder Matteson’s articles, and, as a special point, endeavors to show that there is a disagreement between the articles of Elder Matteson and some statements in “Thoughts on Daniel and the Revelation;” although if such disagreement could be proved, we fail to see how it would help his position in any way.
But there is no such disagreement as is claimed, and none can be made to appear except by garbling the quotations and keeping out of sight the context which shows in what sense certain expressions are used; a practice which we are sorry to see resorted to.
One illustration will suffice: Mr. N. claims a contradiction between “Thoughts” and Elder Matteson in regard to the second angel’s message; and he makes it out by quoting the two authorities in this way: “Mr. Matteson says, ‘The message proclaimed in Rev. 18:1-4, is identical with the message of the second angel in Rev. 14:8.’” Then he quotes “Thoughts” as saying in reference to the message of Rev. 18:1-4: “But it cannot be identical with it [the second angel in Rev. 14].” Thus the reader would be given to understand that there was a positive contradiction between them.
Now let us quote the passages just as they actually stand in the works referred to, and the reader will see where the dishonesty comes in. Commencing on Rev. 18:1-4 in “Thoughts,” we say: “When may this movement be looked for? If the position we have taken is correct, that these [Protestant] churches, this branch of Babylon, experienced a moral fall by the rejection of the first message of chapter 14, the announcement in the chapter under consideration [chapter 18], could not have gone forth previous to that time. It is, then, either synonymous with the message of the fall of Babylon, in chapter 14, or it is given at a later period than that. But it cannot be synonymous with that; for that merely announces the fall of Babylon, but this adds several particulars which at that time were neither fulfilled nor in process of fulfillment.”
What is the point under consideration here?—It is the chronology or time of the message of Rev. 18:1-4. In what respect was it not synonymous with that of Revelation 14?—In point of time, or was not identical with it as a distinct movement.
Now we will hear what Elder Matteson says upon the point, by quoting his statement in full, a part of which Mr. N. omitted: “The message proclaimed in Rev. 18:1-4 is identical in its nature with the message of the second angel in Rev. 14:8.” The words which we have italicized, “in its nature,” were omitted by Mr. N. in quoting this passage. But these words change the statement entirely, and remove all semblance of conflict with the quotation from “Thoughts.” That spoke of the chronology of the message; this, of its nature; and that the two are identical in nature is believed and ever has been believed by us all. But one movement may be identical “in its nature” with another movement, and yet not be the same movement at all. Had Mr. N. quoted Elder Matteson correctly, and quoted from “Thoughts” in full, he would have lost his point. So it is to be presumed that he designedly made the quotations as he did. But when a person holds a position which requires such artifice to sustain it, he would much better abandon it.