BY EDGAR KELSEY. (South Lancaster, Mass.)
Though both of these words convey the same thought to many minds, a little examination will prove that there is an important distinction between them. If conscientiousness were righteousness, the way of truth could not be called a narrow way; for nearly every commandment of the decalogue is violated in the name of conscience. This statement is not an argument against the necessity of conscientiousness; for we cannot be right without being conscientious; it only shows that it is quite as possible to be conscientiously wrong as it is to be conscientiously right. What a forcible illustration of this fact it would make if we could see, side by side, all of the varied fruits of conscience from the different ages and races of men! Such a spectacle, without including a single sin that is done in violation of conscience, would present many a contrast as great as the widest difference between right and wrong. It would exceed the bounds of our imagination to embrace the details of such a strange mixture of conflicting elements in a picture that would begin to compare with the reality. Yet even what we can see of the reality within the scope of our personal observation, showing as it does an almost unlimited capacity of the conscience to adapt itself to the false as well as to the true, is a sufficient antidote for the fallacy that it makes no difference what a person believes, if he is only sincere.
But, without considering that conscience in different persons will give approval to the most conflicting courses of conduct, there are many who suppose that it is always a reliable guide, when it is not the real function of the conscience to guide at all. Here is a very good definition from Worcester’s dictionary: “CONSCIENCE.—The faculty of judging of one’s own conduct with reference to some standard of right and wrong; moral sense; honesty; scruple; justice.” This definition concentrates all of the moral faculties in the conscience. When they are separated to analyze the moral power of the mind, we have moral sense, moral judgment, and sense of obligation. Moral sense is the faculty which can be educated to distinguish right and wrong; moral judgment decides what our duty is according to the light in which our moral sense is educated; and conscience proper, which is our sense of obligation, perceives and affirms our obligation to act according to our best moral judgment.
In order to have a correct moral judgment, our moral sense must be rightly educated in a right standard. If our moral judgment is not correct, evidently our conscience, or sense of obligation, will not be right in its perception, and will consequently affirm a wrong obligation. From this analysis it is easy to discover why the conscientious often differ so widely in their interpretations of duty; they cannot do otherwise while they follow conflicting standards. When a conscientious person commits sin, his fault does not consist in yielding to his honest convictions; for his motive cannot be good unless he acts according to what he thinks is right. Probably the fault is that he has a false standard, though he may have the true one, and not be properly educated in it.
If we could do no better than to select a moral code formulated by human wisdom, the path of duty would be uncertain indeed; but God himself, who understands the true purpose of our existence, has provided us a perfect law. The psalmist says: “Through thy precepts I get understanding: therefore I hate every false way. Thy word is a lamp unto my feet, and a light unto my path.” So we see that our Creator has not left us without a guide; and we will be much safer to follow his guiding hand than we would be if left wholly to our own wisdom. We must not conclude, however, because the conscience is not a guide, that it is not a very important factor in forming our characters. It is exalted to the high position of a judge, and occupies a place that cannot properly be filled unless it has the most careful training in addition to its native fitness.
No one can consistently maintain that conscience thus enthroned would be qualified for its responsible position without recognizing the great criterion which marks the distinction between good and evil. “The wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.” Then it does make a difference what we believe. We are all to be judged by God’s law, and though we cannot fulfill its requirements without divine aid, if our consciences do not recognize its claims, and our sinful and lost condition out of Christ, we will not realize our need of a Saviour; and if we neglect the great salvation, failing to be clothed with the righteousness of Christ, we can never enjoy the rich blessings that God has in store for those who love and obey him.