In the Christian Statesman of Feb. 27, Mrs. J. C. Bateham gives twenty-five reasons why the World’s Fair should be closed on Sunday. The arguments used are so illogical that we are constrained to notice some of them.
1. “It would be a flagrant national violation of God’s law, and expose us to his righteous wrath.”
As the nation has no jurisdiction over the sovereign State of Illinois, we cannot see how any action of the people of Illinois within the limits of the Constitution could be a national violation of anything. Further, we cannot see how opening an exhibition or doing any kind of work or business on Sunday by any individual or corporation is a violation of God’s law, for the very simple reason that God has nowhere said anything about Sunday’s being a holy day. To be sure the “church” has said something about it, but what right has the church to enforce church regulations upon those who do not belong to her communion? The church has as much right to compel people to be baptized or to partake of the Lord’s Supper as she has to say that they must keep the day she has chosen for religious services.
2. “Sabbath is the sacred day of America, and should be protected from desecration.”
This statement is chiefly remarkable for its indefiniteness. If the writer had said, “Sunday is the sacred day,” etc., then there would, at least, have been no ambiguity. To assume that “Sabbath” is the generally received appellation of Sunday is to fly in the face of all history. It was never so called until the Puritans gave it that title. The largest and most influential body of the so-called Christian church, the Catholic, never call it the Sabbath. The idea that Sunday hadp. 251 taken the place of the Sabbath was not thought of until modern times, and is now confined to people of puritanical tendencies.
3. “We are a Christian nation, and wish to honor our Lord and the Lord’s day, and the consciences and sentiments of the people would be outraged.”
We fail to see how the conscience of any one can be outraged by what some one else does. Conscience is supposed to be the monitor which approves or condemns our own conduct. It is our right and privilege to have “sentiments” and “conscience” for ourselves; but when we attempt to have “sentiments” and “conscience” for other people, we are making attempts to “stretch our conscience” far beyond its legitimate sphere of action. So if any one visits the Fair on Sunday and his own conscience is not outraged thereby, then no conscience will be affected. Others may think he is doing wrong, but they cannot be conscience for him. “To his own master he standeth or falleth.” The proposition rests on a false principle, and one that has caused a vast amount of trouble in the world. The attempt to be conscience for some one else resulted in the Inquisition. The Puritans in their attempts to be conscience for others drove Roger Williams from the colony of Massachusetts, nailed up the doors of a Baptist meeting-house, and whipped and put to death the Quakers.
4. “For six months it will deprive the thousands of exhibitors and an army of employees of any rest day, though specially needed.”
Does the writer believe that no one can be obtained in Chicago to take for one day the places of those who wish to rest? We have no hesitation in saying that we believe there are thousands of capable people who would be ready to take the places of those who wanted to rest, at any time. So no one will be deprived of “any rest day” after all.
5. “Visitors to the Fair greatly need a weekly day for absolute rest, and the Chicago people need it.”
If they need a day of rest, pray who is going to hinder their taking it? Is not each individual as good a judge of how much rest he needs as any other person is likely to be? And won’t the burden be just as heavy for the Chicago people to have these visitors taking their dinners in one place as in another? How are those whose houses are open to receive this large army of visitors going to obtain any absolute rest any day during the continuance of the Fair?
6. “The mass of working people do not desire its opening, preferring a day of rest.”
Upon this point we would prefer to hear from the working people themselves.
7. “We want to give the world an object lesson of the best of our American institutions,—the Sabbath,—and invite them to follow our example.”
So the Sabbath is an “American” institution like the “freeman’s meeting.” We would be glad to be told what Americans instituted it, and what American history contains a record of this action. If we had no better reason why men should keep a Sabbath than that it is “American,” we should have little hope to induce them “to follow our example.”
8. “If open, some exhibitors and multitudes of people will stay away for ‘conscience’ sake,’ and will thus be deprived of all its benefits.”
We feel very doubtful about the exact truthfulness of this statement. Ministers who have the most to say about Sunday street-cars, patronize them “just the same,” and we have no doubt that even if the Fair is open to the public Sundays, when it is once opened, those who have had the most to say against its being open Sunday, and have declared they would not be there, will be among the first to put in their appearance!
They will ease their “conscience” by going on some other day than Sunday, which of course is their privilege. If Seventh-day Adventists should say, “We won’t go to the Fair at all because it is opened Saturday,” these very people who threaten by their absence to jeopardize the success of the Fair (?) would look upon our conduct as the very essence of narrowness and self-imposed penance. We do not propose to do anything of the kind. If we visit the Fair, it will be some other day than the Sabbath, and our strict Sunday-keeping friends can enjoy the same privilege of selecting the day of their visit. What more can they ask for?
M. E. K.