There seems to be of late a more than usual activity in the circulation of the claim that the Catholic Church is founded upon St. Peter. Correspondents frequently write us, saying that they often meet these claims, and asking for some examination of the question. And now, a little four-page leaflet in defense of six leading dogmas of the Catholic faith, has been received, each one under the heading, “What does the Bible say?” This is not a little amusing, considering that the doctrines of that church are founded almost entirely upon tradition, and very little upon the Scriptures.
This is what the tract has to say upon the Peter question:—
“It is denied that our Lord appointed St. Peter to be his vicegerent, and head of his church upon earth. Now, on the headship of St. Peter, ‘What does the Bible say?’ ‘And when Jesus beheld him, he said, Thou art Simon the son of Jonah: thou shalt be called Cephas, which is by interpretation, Peter (rock or stone).’ See word ‘Peter’ in Cruden’s (Protestant) Concordance. John 1:42. ‘And I say unto thee, Thou art Peter [rock] and upon this rock I will build my church; and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.’ St. Matt. 16:18. ‘And I will give unto thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.’ Verse 19: ‘Jesus said to Simon Peter, feed my lambs. He said to him again, feed my lambs. He said to him a third time, feed my sheep.’ St. John 21:15–17.”
In thinking this matter over, it has occurred to us that perhaps it may not be so inappropriate after all to consider that the Catholic Church is founded upon Peter—a man, and a very human one at that. In looking over the history of the Catholic Church, one might very easily suppose that it was founded upon a man, subject to all the infirmities to which human nature is heir.
A scoffer once pointed Mr. Whitefield to one of his converts, lying drunk in the gutter, and said to him: “There, Mr. Whitefield, is one of your converts.” “Yes,” said Whitefield, looking at the man, “very likely; that looks more like my work than it does like the work of the Lord.” So, looking at the history of the Catholic Church, one may well say, “That looks more like a church founded upon a man, than it does like one founded upon the Lord.”
It was after the words quoted from Matt. 16:18, 19 were spoken to Peter that he fell into utter apostasy, and denied his Lord with cursing and swearing. Peter, cursing and swearing, makes a very good head and foundation for the Catholic Church, but not a very good head for a Christian church. This may account for the fact that many of the so-called successors of St. Peter, sitting in the papal chair, while very good heads of the church, were monsters of corruption and iniquity. As a foundation, we prefer the “prophets and apostles, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner-stone.”
After the resurrection of Christ, to be sure, he said to Peter, Feed my lambs and sheep. But he said the same thing to all the other apostles, as well as to Peter; for he said, “Go ye,” meaning all of them, “into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature.”
But Christ did not tell Peter that he was the rock upon which he would found his church; and therein lies the fallacy of the whole claim that is urged by our Catholic friends. They are very careful to conceal the fact that the word rendered Peter (rock) is a different word from the one rendered “rock,” on which he said he would build his church. The one is petros, a little stone, or, as we would express it, a cobble-stone. The other is petra, and means an immovable mass, or ledge of rock. It was such a rock as that upon which Christ said the wise man built or founded his house (Matt. 7:24); it was the surface of underlying ledge, on which the seed fell in the parable of the sower. Luke 8:6, etc. The term petra is never applied to the person, Peter, but it was upon this petra, great rock, and not upon the petros (Peter), little stone, that Christ said he would build his church. And this petra was not Peter, but it was the great truth which Peter had just uttered, according to the record of Matt. 16:16, namely, Peter’s confession to Christ, “Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God.” This great truth is the immovable rock referred to. Upon this great truth Christ declared he would build his Church, and the gates of hell should not prevail against it.
This does not contradict Eph. 2:20; for Christ was himself the embodiment of all truth (John 14:6); and upon the foundation laid, of prophets whom he had inspired, and apostles whom he sent forth, himself being the chief corner-stone, his church is built, and not upon a weak, vacillating, mortal man.
This being the true statement of Christ, there was of course no human head appointed for his church here upon the earth, and hence no succession of human authority to be continued in the church here below.
Christ repeatedly instructed his followers that they should call no man master here; for only one was their master, he said, that is himself, the Lord of heaven. He instructed them also that he is the head, and we are the body; and he has not appointed any sub-head, to represent him here on the earth. This takes out of the hands of any church the claim to have the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and to loose and bind on earth, to signify that the same would be loosed and bound in heaven, unless the church can show that it has received such commission; for whatever power may have been given to the apostles, it does not follow that it was given to others, or was to be transmitted through them to their posterity, or successors in office. Whatever degree of divine power the church possesses in any age, it must come to them directly from Christ, their head, and not through a long, antecedent human channel.