Under the above heading the Catholic Mirror of March 12 devotes an article to the present outlook of Protestantism as seen through Catholic eyes. We wish the article could be read by every Protestant in the land; for we believe the majority of Protestants do not know how they are regarded by the Catholic Church, between whom and themselves there has existed such a difference of opinion, nor do they know to what extent Protestant practices in some important things have not been in harmony with the principles which they have laid down as the reasons for their separation from Rome.
Protestants have very pronounced opinions about the Catholic Church. Unless they have ceased to protest, they look upon her as the great antichristian power foretold by Daniel, Paul, and John, which was to sit “in the temple of God,” usurping the authority of Christ, which was to “cast the truth to the ground,” and was to “wear out the saints of the Most High, and think to change times and laws.” Such in brief, has been the opinion that has been entertained of the Church of Rome by all true Protestants from the earliest Waldensians down through the stirring times of the great lights of the Reformation,—Huss, Jerome of Prague, Luther, Zwingle, Knox, etc. It is safe to say that if these men had not believed that the Church of Rome was the fulfillment of John’s vision of the woman seated “upon a scarlet colored beast, full of names of blasphemy,” then they never would have raised their voices against her, nor have headed the mighty religious revolution which separated some of the most important nations of Europe from her communion. The belief that Rome was in its nature antichristian, was the seed thought from which the tree of Protestantism grew. Whether professed Protestants of to-day believe this doctrine which was held so tenaciously and propagated so successfully by the spiritual fathers of the Reformation or not, they must acknowledge the seed from which they sprang; and if the Protestantism of to-day recedes from the position then taken as to the character of the Church of Rome and the place she occupies in the estimation of God, just so far does it give up the principles for which so many noble-minded men jeopardized their lives, and declare by actions if not by words, that the Reformation and the separation from Rome was uncalled for, and that the Reformers were only reformers in name.
It is painfully apparent that the feeling of looking upon the Roman Church as being a “branch” of the Christian Church is rapidly growing among Protestants. We would not knowingly pen a thought that would cause any one to be lacking in Christian charity, but at the same time we believe it to bep. 443 imperative that every Protestant should realize that an acknowledgment that the Romish system is so near to Christianity that it may properly be called a “branch,” is a virtual surrender to Rome. If she is a branch, may she not be as good and pure as the churches who have separated from her communion, and who constitute the other “branches;” and then what becomes of the arguments of the reformers who declared her to be “Mystery, Babylon the Great, the Mother of Harlots and Abominations of the Earth.” The Church of Rome holds that she and she only is the true church, and she will not for one moment allow that there are any branches; and when Protestants allow that she is a branch, it is a tacit acknowledgment that she is the true church and an admission of her claim of supremacy.
There is no concealing the fact that the Protestantism of to-day stands in a difficult position. Not because there is any inherent difficulty, but because it has not remained true to Protestant principles, but has in many ways virtually turned its back upon the Scriptures, and has accepted in its place tradition and the authority of the Roman Church; and having gone so far in this downward course that they find it difficult to retrace their steps, and finding the gulf between them and the Catholic Church easier to cross than the one between them and the Bible, the mass of Protestants are drawing dangerously near the narrowing distance between themselves and Rome, and are looking with longing eyes to her communion as a panacea from a troubled conscience arising from the simple commands of the Scriptures.
That we are fairly stating the actual condition of things, and that all professed Protestants who may read these lines may see Protestantism as it is reflected in the Mirror, we give the following from the article referred to above:—
“Again: while the essence of Protestantism is individualism, the great body of Protestants, in their different denominations, have adopted much of Catholic truth, and, as Pere Lacordaire used to say, we thank God for it; for that will save them, if they are living up to their light, and are in good faith where they are. And so in many ways they have advanced,—developed, if you will,—from the cold barrenness of days gone by to a degree of warmth and richness in marked contrast with the simplicity of the past. The Protestant idea of worship, e. g., is a very different thing from what it once was. Forms and symbols and rites are not rejected, but reverently used. . . . And even many of the features of the Christian development, which are owned to have been borrowed from pagan custom, are used and enjoyed.”
That the above statement is essentially correct must be evident to every careful observer, although he may not realize that Rome lies at the end of this road. The change that has come over Protestantism, which is referred to in the Mirror as being “developed from the cold barrenness of days gone by,” has been so rapid that those who have not observed it must be very dull indeed. The Catholic Church rejoices at the sight; for to her it is an unmistakable evidence that the one time “heretics,” but now “separated brethren,” are receiving those things which the Fathers of the Reformation repudiated, even doctrines and practices confessedly of pagan origin.
How far the reformed churches are from living up to their own standard, and to what they must return to be consistent with the profession which has separated them from the Church of Rome, the same article thus sets forth:—
“We are wondering just now whether it is at all likely that Protestantism will ever go back to what are called ‘the simple truths of the New Testament.’ We don’t believe it will or can.
“When it is considered what the Protestantism of to-day is,—how much it has learned of the church idea—the Catholic idea,—it may be seen how useless it is to expect any such thing. To begin with, all of the immense majority of Protestants, in the simple matter of accepting the change from the Sabbath to the Sunday—from the last to the first day of the week—quietly admit an extra-scriptural authority, the authority of the church. Chillingworth’s famous maxim, ‘The Bible only, the religion of Protestants’ leaves this item, at least, out of the calculation. All unwittingly our separated brethren are here acting upon a Catholic principle, which does not deny or do away Scripture, but makes the rule of faith to consist of Scripture and—and something else—even tradition; and by this principle the ever-living voice of the church speaks with an authority always equal to that of the written revelation, and sometimes apparently transcending it.”
The difference between Catholic and Protestant ideas of authority, and one of the most noted deviations which Protestants have made from their own rule, are here plainly set forth. We hold it to be a self-evident truth that if the Reformers had been as ready to carry the work of reform into all points of faith and practice where the church had set herself above the authority of the Scriptures, as they were upon those doctrines which were the actual points of contest; and if they had adopted the same kind of reasoning which showed the pagan origin of those practices against which they had so manfully striven, they could not have failed to see that the dies solis, or day of the sun, was a miserable counterfeit of the Sabbath of the Bible, and in no way entitled to the respect which rightly belongs to that day on which the Creator rested, and which he sanctified and commanded to be kept holy.
As Protestantism to be true to its name, must be true to its first principles and all which those principles involve, and as this means a return of the reformed churches as bodies to the scriptural Sabbath, the Mirror is doubtless correct in its unbelief that “Protestantism will ever go back to what are called the ‘simple truths of the New Testament.’” Or to state it from the position of a true Protestant, the mass of the reformed churches have clung to and loved so many Romish errors for so long a time, that it will be harder for them to give one of them up, especially the traditional Sunday, than it will be to draw still nearer to that antichristian and blasphemous power which has made all nations drink of the wine of her fornication.
That the popular churches are largely in the current which is setting toward Rome, is evident from their clamorous appeals for national protection to the Catholic holiday of Sunday and the establishment of the Christian religion by law, which is perfectly in the line of Romish theory and practice.
To return to the question, “Will scriptural simplicity save Protestantism?” we reply that we have no idea that Protestants as a body will ever try the experiment; but we have no doubt that scriptural simplicity will save every Protestant and every Catholic who will receive it, and we thank God that the “third angel’s message” (Rev. 14:9-12), which is to go to all the world, is the heaven-ordained means of giving every one an invitation to keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus, and thus escape the plagues of God’s wrath which are to be poured upon those who worship the beast and his image. Rev. 16:1, 2. M. E. K.