CONGRESS ON SUNDAY-CLOSING OF THE WORLD'S FAIR.
By L. A. S.
The long-looked-for discussion in Congress on the question of closing the World's Fair on Sunday took place last week in the United States Senate, the result being an overwhelming vote in that body in favor of closing the Exposition on the first day of the week. To Senator Quay of Pennsylvania belongs the honor of precipitating the discussion, by introducing an amendment to the pending Act providing for an appropriation of $5,000,000 by Congress for the World's Fair, so as to make it conditional upon the closing of the Fair on Sunday. The whole proceedings relative to this action of the Senate afford a most instructive illustration of the truth that history repeats itself, and of the manner in which history will be repeated in connection with the steps already taken and to be taken in our land in the direction of religious legislation. Notice first the source from which this effort in behalf of governmental Sunday-closing of the Fair proceeds. The familiarity of the general public with the recent political history of Mr. Quay renders it unnecessary to say much on this point; but we quote from the Congressional Record of July 10, the following sarcastic utterance from Senator Morgan:— “Mr. Morgan.—Mr. President, the high source from which this Sabbath-day amendment comes will silence me from any observations at all, because I know that the senator from Pennsylvania [Mr. Quay] is the highest possible authority upon all questions of that kind, and if I follow him, I shall follow him in silence.” The reason of Mr. Quay's action is not difficult to guess. In the unpleasant consciousness of his unsavory reputation in connection with national politics, he looks about for some means to elevate himself to a position of favor with the people, and lo! he sees a way by which to do it; he will become an advocate of that religio-political movement for which a large and influential element of the church people are zealously working; he will appear as a champion of the enforced observance of Sunday. The revelation of Mr. Quay's motives in this respect before his fellow-senators constitutes one of the amusing incidents in connection with the discussion. We quote on this point from the Inter Ocean of July 13:— “As Mr. Pettigrew is chairman of the Columbian Exposition Committee, the various appeals made by telegraph from religious bodies were not surprising, but after his batch had been read, Senator Quay announced that he had a large number of dispatches received to-day which he would send to the clerk's desk, and ask that they be read and printed in the record. As Mr. Quay is from Beaver Falls, it did not strike the senators as unusual that seven or eight telegrams should have come from the residents of that town, but as the number increased, and the tenor of each dispatch read the same, senators began to smile, and then to laugh. Out of twenty from Beaver Falls and vicinity, each one was addressed, the Hon. M. S. Quay, United States Senate, ‘Stand457 firm by your Sunday-closing amendment,’ ‘Stand out by your amendment,’ ‘Please stand firm,’ ‘Do not make any compromise,’ and so on, until the monotony was varied by one, ‘We trust you will stand firm.’” “Senators who seldom smile and very seldom indulge in outbursts of laughter, were gradually drawn from seriousness to levity, and from restraint to loud laughter, as one after another of these sententious appeals was read.” “Finally there came a climax, in which the spectators and the senators joined in a chorus of loud and prolonged laughter. Their cause was the reading of a dispatch which fully explained why so many telegrams from so many different sources were substantially alike. It read: ‘In accordance with your request, we hope you will stand firm by your Sunday amendment.’” “In accordance with your request!” In other words, Mr. Quay had himself dictated the tenor of these dispatches, and requested that they be sent to him, to be read in the Senate, and published in the Congressional Record, in order that he might pose before the country as a moral hero. And that he might so pose, the Sunday institution, as now manipulated by the religio-political organizations of the country, was a very convenient instrument. Who cannot see the use that will be made of religious institutions by unscrupulous and hypocritical men, to lift themselves into favor with the people, or to retain what favor they already have, when religious qualifications, real or pretended, become with the constituents of our political leaders a test of fitness for holding office? And thus will politicians and churchmen trade their influence with each other, the one supporting religious measures in return for political support from the other, exactly as was done in the days of Constantine, in the formation of the papacy. It is worthy of note that the amendment of Senator Quay, as originally worded, provided that the Exposition should be closed “on the Sabbath day,”—a wording which led Senator Manderson to say, “I submit that if the senator from Pennsylvania desires that the Exposition shall be closed upon Sunday, this language will not necessarily meet that idea. The Sabbath day is not Sunday. Decisions are abundant upon the proposition that that language does not mean the first day of the week, even in this Christian nation.” He then proposed to amend Senator Quay's amendment by substituting for “the Exposition on the Sabbath day” the words, “mechanical portion of the Exposition on the first day of the week, commonly called Sunday,”—a proposition which Mr. Quay accepted, as he said, so far as concerned the phraseology designating the first day of the week. Thus while it is known and admitted in the United States Senate that Sunday is not the Sabbath, the vote is still overwhelmingly in favor of enforcing that day as a day of rest. A few quotations from some of the leading speakers upon the question will no doubt be of interest to the reader. The first is from Senator Palmer:— “I grant there is a large number of good people who ask for the closing of the Exposition on Sunday, but I will state to the senator from Pennsylvania that I have a very large number of petitions from those who believe that Sunday is not the Sabbath, who believe the seventh day is the Sabbath, and not the first, and a proper regard for their opinion, it seems to me, would at least prevent this arbitrary interference on the part of the United States, in electing a particular day which would be offensive to the consciences not of a majority, but of a very large number of good people. They insist that if the United States government is to elect, is to fix, is to appropriate a day; if it is to adopt a day and compel its observance, it is a hardship upon them. They are a minority, and the question as to which is the Sabbath is one about which honest men are divided. I think it will be far better that the matter should be left to the discretion of those to whom the United States has intrusted everything else which pertains to the management of this great enterprise.” “I am thoroughly convinced that it is for the financial interest of the Fair, that it is for the interest of the laboring men of this country, and responsive to the entire religious sentiment of the United States, that the Fair shall be closed on Sunday; and therefore with great pleasure I shall vote for the amendment offered by the senator from Pennsylvania.” Senator Hawley, evidently with the recent decision of the Supreme Court that this is a Christian nation, fresh in his mind, made a speech in favor of Sunday-closing, which, as nearly as we can judge, could not have been improved upon by a National Reformer himself. “I would not,” he said, “for the wealth of ten Expositions have upon my shoulders the responsibility of having decided the question wrongly upon what may be a turning point in the history of the United States. Open the Exposition on Sunday, and the flood-gates are opened. Hereafter it will be forever pointed to as a precedent of high authority for opening [on Sunday] all exhibitions and places of amusement or alleged instruction.” He referred to the fact that legislative bodies open their sessions with prayer, to the prayers offered daily in the Senate and House of Representatives, the Thanksgiving proclamations of the Presidents, and even the observance of Christmas, as precedents upon which to base the action of closing the Fair on Sunday. He alluded to the Sunday laws of the States and Territories, which he said were based upon a religious regard for the day as well as upon physical grounds, and asserted that if the ten commandments “had not been discovered in the Old Testament, wise men would have devised something very similar to them!” Finally he showed the regard which leading churchmen had for Sunday, by quoting liberally from the utterances of Roman Catholic and Protestant bishops upon that subject. Senator Peffer referred to the fact that the senators, however piously they might express themselves in the matter of Sunday observance, were in the habit of receiving their mails twice on that day, and said: “A great deal of this talk of ours about the observance of Sunday is sheer hypocrisy.” And what “sheer hypocrisy” it was may be seen from the action of the same body with reference to the subject of the prohibition of liquor-selling at the Fair. On Wednesday the Senate passed, together with the Sunday-closing provision, an amendment providing that the sale of liquor on the grounds of the Fair should be prohibited; but the next day this action was re-considered, the prohibitory liquor clause was stricken out, and the appropriation passed with the Sunday amendment alone. Thus those who are in favor of a closed Sunday record themselves at the same time as in favor of open whisky. The provision as thus amended will go to the House of Representatives in a day or two, and the probability is that it will pass that body by a small vote, after which only the signature of the President will be necessary to its validity. This is the first time in our history that national governmental action has been taken with reference to the observance of Sunday, and it need not be said that the proceeding is significant of what is soon to follow.