IS IT ANY BETTER?

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 12, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 15.

Read the full edition

IS IT ANY BETTER?

The popular misconception as to who was the author of the ten commandments does not seem to abate in the least. Men who profess to be Bible scholars, and who write learnedly of “Ingersoll’s mistakes about Moses,” talk glibly about the ten commandments of Moses. We do not deny that Moses may have written the ten commandments; but if he did, he wrote them from the copy which the Lord wrote himself upon the tables of stone; and the transcribing by Moses of the commandments which had previously been written by God himself, no more made them the commandments of Moses than it would make him God because he bore to the people the words of God.
We are moved to make these remarks by the following, which we clip from a late number of the Interior:—
“Considering the boasts of infidelity, one wonders at its meager results. We are reminded of this, when looking over our exchanges, we noted in a religious paper the so-called ten commandments written by Thomas Jefferson. Whether in truth written by him, we do not too critically inquire. They are put out as in the interests of an anti-Christian code. And as an illustration and fair sample of the rest, we quote the fourth: ‘Never buy what you do not want, because it is cheap.’ We have seen a good many attempts to rival the Bible in moral teaching, but like this they always fall infinitely below it, even though compared simply as intellectual products. Not even the man who wrote the Declaration of Independence could attempt to vie with Moses without making himself ridiculous.”
The Interior makes a good point when it says that “not even the man who wrote the Declaration of Independence could attempt to vie with Moses;” and this is true, notwithstanding Moses was not the author of the ten commandments.
But the Interior is very unfortunate in its selection of the fourth commandment of the Jeffersonian code for comparison with the one given by God,—unfortunate, because the rendering of the fourth commandment by the Christian world is as inferior to the real fourth commandment as the fourth commandment of the Jeffersonian code is inferior to it.
The fourth commandment reads: “Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy. Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work; but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God. . . . For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day: wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day and hallowed it.” Ex. 20: 6-11.
The fourth commandment of the code which is generally received at the present time in this country, is something like this: “Remember the first day, or Sunday, to keep it holy; six days shalt thou labor and do all thy work, but the first day is the American Sabbath: for . . . confusion! for the church commands it, shouts the Catholic prelate! Amen, responds an Episcopalian! for the Sabbath has been changed to the first day, says the representative of the Puritan theology. A “Disciple” here gains the floor, and declares that the fourth commandment is abolished, and that Sunday-keeping has no reference to the fourth commandment, and offers to debate the subject with any one.
And so nearly every church has a reason which generally conflicts with the reasons which are urged by every other church. How much better is this than Jefferson’s fourth commandment? His, although puerile compared to the precept of God, had at least the merit of being consistent. But the attempt to take the fourth commandment, which enforces the seventh day, because God rested on that day and then blessed and sanctified it at the close of creation week, to enforce another day,—the first day, and for another, and for various and conflicting reasons,—has no reason and no consistency. If the other nine commandments should be interpreted in a way to conflict with their obvious and plain meaning to the extent that it is done in the interpretation of the fourth commandment, we would as soon take the commandments of Jefferson for a rule of Christian obligation, as we would the real ten commandments thus amended. M. E. K.