AdventAI

THE RELIABILITY OF CHURCH HISTORIANS

By L. R. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 27., July 5, 1892

When all the efforts to establish Sunday-observance from the Bible fail, men often produce certain church histories, such as Mosheim’s and others, and point with an air of triumph to certain statements of these men, in which they assert that Sunday was observed during the time of the apostles and the early church. But we ask, On what do these men rest their statements? Can they produce some surer testimony concerning the time of the apostles and the early church, than the word of God?—Surely not. Have they lived at that time, or seen it themselves?—No; for they lived either in the last or the present century, and therefore, as far as actual experience goes, are as far from it as other men. Have they any reliable documents outside of the holy Scriptures, concerning the doctrines held in the first two centuries?—No. Then how do they come to such statements?—Why, simply by taking the same Bible that we all have, and drawing inferences. This being the case, as further investigation will show, the act of making such a statement after failing to find any clue for any Sunday observance from the Bible, means simply to rest on somebody else’s assertion against our own actual experience. But are the church historians agreed among themselves, in their statements concerning early Sunday-observance?—By no means. It is the same with them as with the defenders of Sunday at the present day, there being as many theories as heads, simply because the proof is wanting, and each one draws his own inferences. To illustrate the above, we will take the statements of two eminent German church historians, and compare them, and see how each one arrives at his conclusions. I have before me the original editions of Neander and Mosheim. Neander says concerning Sunday:—

“The festival of Sunday, like all other festivals, was always only a human ordinance, and it was far from the intentions of the apostles to establish a divine command in this respect,—far from them, and from the early apostolic church, to transfer the laws of the Sabbath to Sunday. Perhaps at the end of the second century, a false application of this kind had begun to take place; for men appear by that time to have considered laboring on Sunday as a sin.”*—*Neander’s Kirchengeschichte, first edition, Vol. I, p. 339.

Mosheim makes the following statement:—

“The Christians of this century assembled for the worship of God, and for their advancement in piety, on the first day of the week, the day on which Christ re-assumed his life; for that this day was set apart for religious worship by the apostles themselves, and that after the example of the church at Jerusalem, it was generally observed, we have unexceptionable testimony.”—*Mosheim’s Kirchengeschichte, first edition, Vol. I, p. 152.

Now how is it that these two eminent men arrive at such different conclusions? We will first consider Neander, taking the original German edition as basis. The paragraph in which the above statement occurs, begins the Sunday argument as follows:—

“The opposition to Judaism introduced at an early period the special observance of Sunday, instead of Sabbath: the first trace we find in Acts 20:7, where we find the church assembled on the first day of the week; a later one in Rev. 1:10; for the Lord’s day mentioned here can barely be understood to mean the day of judgment.”

Neander finds in his days and from the church history, that Sunday has taken the place of Sabbath, and looks about for reasons. As a good Protestant, he takes his Bible and searches it, but he finds no command of Christ, nor any intention of the apostles to establish a divine command. But in some way the observance of Sunday must be accounted for, so he begins to look for traces or inferences, and hits upon Acts 20:7. But even while mentioning this, he feels under obligation to add the following in a foot-note:—

“An absolute proof is this passage by no means; for as the apostle Paul was about to depart, this might have caused the gathering of the small church for a brotherly farewell meal, during which occasion the apostle held his last speech, even if no special Sunday observance took place as yet. Still less in this respect can be proved from 1 Cor. 16:2. All this would be sufficiently explained, if one should consider this as the usual beginning of a week in civil life.”

Now we know how Neander arrives at his conclusions. He searches in the Bible, and finds no tracesp. 426 of any command nor even a meeting, until he reaches Acts 20:7. Here he finds a Sunday-night meeting, but on a special occasion; namely, the departing of Paul. This he plainly sees furnishes no absolute proof or certain trace; still less he finds in 1 Cor. 16:2, and as to Rev. 1:10, he knows of but two interpretations,—either Sunday or the day of judgment. And as he hunts for a trace for Sunday, he rather decides that the passage must refer to this. After this, he quotes the very doubtful and, in fact, wrongly translated testimony found in the epistle of Ignatius to the Magnesians, and then expresses his conviction that as there is no divine command in the Bible and no positive proof of its observance, Sunday must be but a human ordinance, which somebody in some way introduced; otherwise it could not exist. He hunts also through the few and doubtful records of the so-called “Apostolic Fathers,” but fails to find any inference that people refrained from their business to hold any Sunday service, until he reaches the church father Tertullian, at the very end of the second century. And this very church father not only furnishes the first evidence for infant baptism, but mentions Sunday as originating from tradition.

One thing has been plainly proved by all this: that even the most eminent historians have nothing of any value except the Bible, and to this the humblest has access, and can see with his own eyes whether any proof is there or not. But we next consider Mosheim’s statement. The reader will remember that his history was written in the Latin, and thus the German, like the English, is but a translation. But the original, the German, and the English have the following important foot-note to the words “unexceptionable testimony,” marked “e” in the original German, and “a” in the English.

Phil. Jac. Hartmann, de rebus gestis Christianorum sub Apostolis, cap. 15, p. 387. Just. Hen. Böhmer, Dissert. 1. Juris Eccles. Antiqui de statu die Christianor. p. 20.

This proves, first of all, what unwarranted liberties Maclaine took in his translation of Mosheim, omitting the above foot-note, and calling the two writers, when he did not even know whether or not they really proved what Mosheim made them assert, “the united testimonies of the most credible writers.” But as both English translations omit this foot-note, the statement of Mosheim simply amounts to a mere assertion of a point, which demands the most positive proof. It may do for Catholics to produce the assertion of a certain pope as proof; for they believe him to be infallible; but for a Protestant to set aside the infallible rule of God by the simple assertion of an erring man, like Mosheim, is a painful sight indeed.

But we will investigate this “unexceptionable testimony” of these two writers, and see what wonderful proofs they produce. Both works are written in Latin. Phil. Jac. Hartmann’s work is entitled, “History of the Christian Antiquities,” and was published in Leipsic, in 1710. The above part treats of the deeds of the Christians at the time of the apostles. On page 387 he makes the following statement:—

“As the first church was composed of Jews, the established observance of the Sabbath remained for them at that time, and the apostles observed it once alone, as they visited the synagogues on the Sabbath day, to explain the gospel. To the Gentiles they spoke on every other day, concerning sacred things.

“But we deny by no means that the Sunday was introduced about the middle of the apostolic age; the Revelation mentions it plainly. The schools of the apostles and the elders of the apologists mention it as being introduced and kept already a long time, still thus, that its observance did not commence as long as Jerusalem stood.”

Concerning the introduction of Sunday after the destruction of Jerusalem, Hartmann makes the following statement in note 7:—

“Concerning the weekly observance of Sunday, no testimony can be produced except that of Rev. 1:10; for Acts 20:7 and 1 Cor. 16:2, on which Lightfoot bases his assertions, will not fit at all to Sunday. Lightfoot dares to assert to 1 Cor. 16:2 that the apostles and their disciples, converted to the faith in Judea, had not only observed Sunday, but had kept it holy also in consequence of a divine institution. Neither the Saviour nor the apostles have prescribed in any law new days to be observed.”†

These statements of Hartmann clearly prove that Mosheim was not justified in referring to this writer as “unexceptionable testimony” in substantiating his own assertion. Hartmann in the plainest terms denies everything Mosheim asserts. Instead of furnishing proof for the “express appointment of the apostles,” mentioned by Mosheim, he positively states that there was no such thing; and instead of showing that the church in Jerusalem introduced the Sunday observance, Hartmann agrees with the opinion that it was not introduced until after the destruction of Jerusalem. If a man before the court would call upon a man to witness to his assertion, and this man would state just the opposite, what would the judge think of such a man? He would surely question his truthfulness. But then Mosheim produces two witnesses, and we want to see if he fares better with the second one. The title of the second work, which was published in 1711 at Leipsic, would be in English, “Dissertations on the Ancient Canon Law About the Stated Day Referred to in Pliny’s Letter.” And the bad luck of Mosheim is, that this noted writer on canon law proves in these very dissertations, that the stated day in Pliny’s letter must be the Sabbath, or the seventh day, and cannot be Sunday. We first quote the passage on p. 20 of this work, on which Mosheim must try to rest his assertion:—

“It therefore remains that we investigate whether the day of the sun was also to the Christians in Bithynia a definite day, on which they were accustomed to assemble, which as it appears is the more asserted, because this was already at the time of the apostles a Christian holy day.” L. R. C.

(Concluded next week.)

Notes

  1. *Tertullian, on “Prayer,” chapter 23. ↩
  2. †D. Ph. J. Sklerando (Hartmann), Historia Antiquitatum Eccl. Christ. pp. 386, 387. ↩